Nba All-time Top 5 Team

Some interesting analysis there MLAM. Hard to believe that Hayes was left out until now - good choice! For what it's worth, Bill Russell was interviewed in tonight's pre-game show - his choice for the best ever: The Big O.
 
Hayes is one of the top 5 PF's to ever play the game, and he probably has the best baseline fadeaway aside from Bernard King and Hakeem Olajuwon. However, he was a "blackhole". Once he touched the ball, it never came back out. That is one of the reasons why it took him 10 years to win a championship. I think Duncan has already surpassed him and I can't rate him higher than Bob Pettit and Karl Malone.

My Lineup:

C - Chamberlain; Jabbar in his prime couldn't dominate him even though Chamberlain was 35 and came off leg surgery. Wilt was so dominant that they widened the lane in '64 to prevent him from dominating.

F - Duncan ; He's a more complete player than Barkley, Hayes, and Petit. He also is alot more clutch than Karl Malone.

F - Bird; In the mid-80's Bird was considered the best baller and was rewarded with 3 MVPs. As great as Baylor was, he never won MVP. Julius Erving, Hondo, and Rick Barry also get consideration here.

G - Johnson ; Oscar was a better defensive player, offensive player, and shooter than Magic. However, Oscar's Cincinnati teams never showed up in the playoffs and Oscar didn't perform very well in the playoffs. Magic's numbers are better in the playoffs.

G - Jordan; He barely beats out Jerry West by a hair.
 
Last edited:
I heard someone ask this same question on the fan today, I wonder if it was the same guy that started this thread. Well here is my top 5
1)M.J.
2)Magic
3) My token white guy-Larry Bird
4) Oscar Robertson
5) The best defensive player to ever play the game Bill Russell , remember Offense is fun to watch but defense wins championships.
My 6th man will be Wilt the stilt
 
I don’t mean to be too technical here guys...BUT

All the playa’s that ya’ll mentioned so far are some of the best the NBA has ever had BUT! As a x-ball player myself (20 years to be exact) and a avid NBA fan one thing I’ve learned from watching countless games over the years is that just because you have 5 All Stars on a team it doesn’t mean you’ll have a great team.
You guys have to remember these “great players” play on teams where there’s only 1 or 2 great players so they are used to getting a certain number of touches/rebounds/points. To stack a team with All Stars might not work since now they’ll have to cut their point scoring in half maybe too accommodate everyone else on the team. I’ll construct my dream team based on compatibility not just the greatest players of all time.

Hmmmm…. here goes…


C – Akeem : great scorer but also an amazing rebounded/ passer, IMO the most agile center I’ve ever seen. He’ll get you a easy 15 ppg but more importantly block anybody’s shot within the key. Great shot blocker, intimidating presence.

PF – Tim Duncan: great scorer but doesn’t need a lot of touches to be effective.
He’ll get you 15 ppg easy and a hell of allot of rebounds. If they double team him he can kick it out to an open MJ, Scottie or Nash for the 3-p.

SF – Scottie Pippen: one of the best all around players ever, great passer, 3-p shooter, drives the lane great, court smart player and best of all an amazing defensive player.
He’ll get you 15 ppg easy but also steal, block and create turnovers.
+: since he won nuff rings with MJ they’ll already have great chemistry.

SG – MJ: If Mike actually played with a LEGIT point guard and never needed to bring the ball up the court he would have been a much more effective playa. This way he’ll have wayyy more energy at the end of the game since now he doesn’t need to push the ball and run the offense. To be a great scorer and defensive player is hard enough physically but to be asked to run the offense at point is too much. Da Bulls never had a good point guard or else they would of won more rings allot easier. MJ = 30 ppg

PG – Steve Nash: great point guard that can break defensives down and still be able to kick it out to the open guy outside/ inside. Doesn’t need to score much points jus push the ball up the court and pass. Does all of this very well and can shoot the 3ball.
He’ll get you 10 ppg easy but more importantly give you close to triple doubles almost ever game….sic playa

So there you have it all. Killer speed all around agile players (agile big men that can run the floor) at every position, unselfish indivduals that can all run the floor hard and is in top condition. Also all with a high B-ball I.Q. absolutely no weakness with this squad

So that’s what? 85 points between these guys. So now the bench jus has to play good defensive and maybe score 15 points between them and they’ll win games/ rings.. :D


PS: Not to hate but Magic and Bird would get killed against this squad. They were never the most agile, athletic guy’s on the court so they would be liability’s trying to chase Nash, Pippen and MJ down the court.lol
Magic had bad knee problems most of his career and Bird got a taste of MJ back when he first entered the league. MJ made Bird look foolish many a times. After they're very first game Bird said MJ is the best player he’s ever seen in his life. I think he scored 63 that game but lost. Lets face it guys the game has changed since 1986 and the speed/strength and conditioning these guys like Nash, A.I and MJ have is just plain sic.
We have a sayin on our court “You Can’t Defend What You Can’t Catch”
 
PS: Not to hate but Magic and Bird would get killed against this squad. They were never the most agile, athletic guy’s on the court so they would be liability’s trying to chase Nash, Pippen and MJ down the court.lol
Magic had bad knee problems most of his career and Bird got a taste of MJ back when he first entered the league. MJ made Bird look foolish many a times. After they're very first game Bird said MJ is the best player he’s ever seen in his life. I think he scored 63 that game but lost. Lets face it guys the game has changed since 1986 and the speed/strength and conditioning these guys like Nash, A.I and MJ have is just plain sic.
We have a sayin on our court “You Can’t Defend What You Can’t Catch”
No! Even though you have been following the NBA for 20 years or so, I believe that you have never seen Bobby Jones play because of the statement that you just made. He was NBA & ABA all-defense 10 times and is considered by many, including me, as greatest defensive forward to ever play the game. Yet, Larry Bird lit him up like a christmas tree everytime they played. The Lakers had a perenial all-defensive player in Michael Cooper (8 times all-defense) and Bird lit him up as well. I also believe that you missed game 1 of the 1991 finals where Magic got Jordan in serious foul trouble because of size advantage. It wasn't until the Bulls put Pippen on Magic that series changed.

As for defense, you are thinking too much in terms of one-on-one defense. Yeah, Bird is slow and he can't jump. Why then did he make the all-defensive team 3 times from '84-'86? Bird was arguably the most cerebral player to play the game along with Russell and Magic. He made the all-defensive team because he had the quickest pair of hands of any forward of his era. He was slow, but he compensated by telegraphing where the ball would go 3 passes later. The 1987 Eastern conference semis against the Pistons is the best example of his quick hands. With 4 seconds left, he stole an inbounded pass by Isiah Thomas and dished it off to a streaking Dennis Johnson, while falling out of bounds, for the game winning layup. Bird was a lousy one-on-one defender, but he was a superb team defender.

By the way, Bird is a forward. He never guarded Jordan when the Bulls played the Celtics. That was primarily the responsibiliy of Danny Ainge and Dennis Johnson. So the talk about Jordan lighting up Bird is moot.

PG – Steve Nash: great point guard that can break defensives down and still be able to kick it out to the open guy outside/ inside. Doesn’t need to score much points jus push the ball up the court and pass. Does all of this very well and can shoot the 3ball
Nash is a great player, but he is no legend. All this talk of how bad Bird and Magic are on the defensive end, yet you place a guy who was lit up by Tony Parker on the greatest team list. If Parker could light up Nash, I'd be worried about what Tiny Archibald, Isiah Thomas, and Walt Frazier would have done to him.

If Mike actually played with a LEGIT point guard and never needed to bring the ball up the court he would have been a much more effective playa. This way he’ll have wayyy more energy at the end of the game since now he doesn’t need to push the ball and run the offense.
You and I are watching two different things. Ask any Bulls fan, and they'll tell you that Pippen was the primary PG on the Bulls.

Da Bulls never had a good point guard or else they would of won more rings allot easier. MJ = 30 ppg
Nothing but speculation. I could also say that if Bill Russell wasn't injured in the '58 finals, the Celts would have one 10 titles in a row. Or if Magic Johnson wasn't injured in the '89 finals the Lakers would have been the 1st team to 3-peat since the Celtics.
 
Big Papa Smurf said:
No! Even though you have been following the NBA for 20 years or so, I believe that you have never seen Bobby Jones play because of the statement that you just made. He was NBA & ABA all-defense 10 times and is considered by many, including me, as greatest defensive forward to ever play the game. Yet, Larry Bird lit him up like a christmas tree everytime they played
Youre right about one thing, i've never seen Bobby Jones play but I dont really rate old school (pre 1988ish defensive players besides the dominant centres like Wilt) I dont think there was much defensive back then and the players were all flat footed one handed dribblers so gaurding them was a joke. I have tapes of allot of those games still the thing that makes me laugh watching them is the fact that most only go one way and dribble the ball high and off there body. They didnt have a fraction of the handle these new guys have like MJ and on.



[Q]I also believe that you missed game 1 of the 1991 finals where Magic got Jordan in serious foul trouble because of size advantage. It wasn't until the Bulls put Pippen on Magic that series changed[Q]

I did see that game and what I watched was the way the game was evolving. Lakers were old school champs but the Bulls were the new age juggernaut. All around complete players like MJ and Scottie were just too athletic and well conditioned for Magic and his Lakers to handle. That's why they dethroned them 4-1. Yes they lost the first game but then sweep them.



[Q]As for defense, you are thinking too much in terms of one-on-one defense. Yeah, Bird is slow and he can't jump. Why then did he make the all-defensive team 3 times from '84-'86?[Q]

Good question, I don't know why he would be on that team. Bird was a great player of course (he's my 2nd fav game ender in history besides Reggie Miller) but he was never a defensive threat and yes couldnt jump or run fast. He was great shooter. I think they gave him those awards for d cause he was one of the most popular player's in the league and he was well respected. Nobody thinks of Bird as all defensive. Sure he knocked the ball out of a few players hands in the dying min but so what, MJ has done that 1000's of times and still shut-out his man and scored 30+ points.
 
cont...


[Q]He made the all-defensive team because he had the quickest pair of hands of any forward of his era[Q]

Well quickest pair of hands of 1984 woundnt cut it now-a-days. Now every player has killer cross overs that would break LB's ankles and have him gasping for breath every 5 min. They would have to bench Bird and he would be in foul trouble all the time.


[Q]By the way, Bird is a forward. He never guarded Jordan when the Bulls played the Celtics. That was primarily the responsibiliy of Danny Ainge and Dennis Johnson. So the talk about Jordan lighting up Bird is moot[Q]

I know was a F but because of picks and screens that MJ ran allot of time they would have to switch for the play and if you watch any ball high lights you'd see MJ taking Bird first inside the key then back out, crossing him over about 5 times until Bird almost fell down, then stepping back and stroking a jumpshot in his face. Bird was about 5 yards away trying to catch MJ. After that game Bird stated in a interview that MJ was the best player he's ever seen.



[Q]Nash is a great player, but he is no legend. All this talk of how bad Bird and Magic are on the defensive end, yet you place a guy who was lit up by Tony Parker on the greatest team list. If Parker could light up Nash, I'd be worried about what Tiny Archibald, Isiah Thomas, and Walt Frazier would have done to him]

I never said I was making my team based on "Legends" I said my team would be based on compatibillity. Yes Nash is not best defensive player and he did get killed by TP BUT like I stated before Nash is on my team because he's a great ball ditributer, can shoot 3's and is a smart player. If he played with this team he would have allot of help on defensive with MJ and Scootie
just like how they helped BJ Armstrong, John Paxston and Steve Kerr. these guys were horrible on d but the team as a hole was amazing and helped them out.


[Q]You and I are watching two different things. Ask any Bulls fan, and they'll tell you that Pippen was the primary PG on the Bulls[Q]

Yes, he did bring the ball up the court sometimes but BJ, Paxston, Kerr and Hodges was the point g's.


Nothing but speculation. I could also say that if Bill Russell wasn't injured in the '58 finals, the Celts would have one 10 titles in a row. Or if Magic Johnson wasn't injured in the '89 finals the Lakers would have been the 1st team to 3-peat since the Celtics.[/QUOTE]

Youre right, it is speculation. I was just pointing out that they won 6 rings without a ledit centre or PG so if you were to asemble my dream and have Nash and Akeeem doing their thing MJ and Scotties jobs just got a hell of allot easier.

This is just my picks, it isnt gauranteed :cool:
 
I have tapes of allot of those games still the thing that makes me laugh watching them is the fact that most only go one way and dribble the ball high and off there body. They didnt have a fraction of the handle these new guys have like MJ and on.
I've seen Wilt in his declining years in the early 70's and nearly every player from 1970-2005. What you fail to realize is that what is termed as defense by today's standards would be considered dirty play in th e 70's and 80's. A forearm to the back in today's game was considered a foul back then. As for players being flat-footed, I take that with a grain of salt because you have never seen Sidney Moncrief, Bobby Jones, Walt Frazier, Dan Roundfield, Michael Cooper, Alvin Robertson or Kevin McHale play defense. You probably did not see Alvin Robertson's defense frustrate Jordan in his rookie year.

Youre right about one thing, i've never seen Bobby Jones play but I dont really rate old school (pre 1988ish defensive players besides the dominant centres like Wilt)...I dont think there was much defensive back then and the players were all flat footed one handed dribblers so gaurding them was a joke.
You have proof to back up your claim that they did not play defense? The reason why the scores are much lower in today's game than in the 80's is due to the fact that the number of possessions has fallen dramatically. The average number of possessions for teams in the 80's was 103. Back in 2002 the number of possessions was 91. Points per Possession back in the 80's was 1.07. That means that for every 100 possessions a team would score 107 points. In 2002 the points per possession for the league was 1.05. That's 105 points per 100 possesions. That's not much of a difference from the early 1980's.
I did see that game and what I watched was the way the game was evolving. Lakers were old school champs but the Bulls were the new age juggernaut. All around complete players like MJ and Scottie were just too athletic and well conditioned for Magic and his Lakers to handle. That's why they dethroned them 4-1. Yes they lost the first game but then sweep them.
Or could it be the fact that James Worthy, their #1 scorer, was suffering from a severe ankle sprain that he suffered during the end of the Western Conference finals. You forget that this unathletic Laker team upset the Blazers in the Western Conference finals 4-2. That Blazer team finished 1st overall in the regular season and boasted a more athletic lineup than the Bulls.
Good question, I don't know why he would be on that team. Bird was a great player of course (he's my 2nd fav game ender in history besides Reggie Miller) but he was never a defensive threat and yes couldnt jump or run fast. He was great shooter. I think they gave him those awards for d cause he was one of the most popular player's in the league and he was well respected. Nobody thinks of Bird as all defensive.
Bird was more than a great shooter. He was the best passing SF, aside from Rick Barry, to ever play the game. He was also a terrific rebounder. Bird did deserve to make those all-defensive teams because along with Kevin McHale and Dennis Johnson, the Celtics boasted one of the top 3 defensive units from '84-'86. They were top 5 in both defensive FG% and points allowed. They accomplised this feat even though they were the most unathletic team in the league.
 
Interesting approach John E - but if you want to pick a "team" instead of "great players" - why not just pick the Bulls team that won 72 games in their best season. Arguably the best "team" ever.