The brand matters. My periodontist once said that for Listerine, you should use it full strength for some time. Another time, he said that the alcohol in mouthwash can irritate your mouth, and that warm, salt water is better to rinse with. Crest makes a mouthwash without alcohol. I think Tom's is also alcohol free but uses baking powder.
There once was a product available in Canada called Viadent. It was orange in colour. It contained sangria extract. I liked it because if you gargled with it before you went to bed, you wouldn't wake up with any morning breath (the sangria would kill the sulfur compounds responsible for bad breath). My periodontist called it 'Viledent' cuz he thought it was too potent.