Mob Week on AMC

GPIDEAL

Prolific User
Jun 27, 2010
23,294
21
38
Enjoyed watching Scarface and Donnie Brasco this week.

What's your favourite mob movie?

These are mine:

Goodfellas

A Bronx Tale (actually, this is a real gem)

Casino

Godfather I & II

One Upon Time In America

Donnie Brasco

Scarface

Carlito's Way
 
casino. Joe Pesci is great.
 
A bunch of great movies. Unfortunately, unless AMC has changed, every bit of cursing
by Pesci, Deniro and the others will be overdubbed. And it almost ruins the movies for me.

From Goodfellas, PG-13 version:

"Funny how? Like I'm a party clown, I make you laugh? I somewhat amuse you?"

"Can you believe this mess? Two African-Americans just stole my truck!"

Unfortunately, AMC also cuts some violence, like in The Godfather Part II, when Vito shoots Don Fanucci in the mouth. Watching censored versions of films I know well is sort of like a CBJ.
 
You're right gentlemen. I thought the overdubs ruined it too. But that's not the point of my thread. What are your favourite mob movies?
 
You're right gentlemen. I thought the overdubs ruined it too. But that's not the point of my thread. What are your favourite mob movies?

Marty: Goodfellas, Mean Streets
Francis: I and II

Semis: Goodfellas, II

Finals: II

I'm in a small minority on this, but I never liked Scarface, despite watching it more than once. I found no redeeming quality in Tony from the beginning on, so there was no tragedy when the scumbag got what he deserved. Michael Corleone is very different. When his cheekbone was broken by Captain McCluskey, his persona changed. I like II best, both because the 'young Vito' segments with Bobby Di are my favorites in the entire trilogy, and because Michael is like a volcano throughout, with brief, intermittent eruptions.
 
Man, I can't remember Mean Streets. I've got to check that out.

I agree with your points about Godfather II. In Scarface, the tragedy might be those close to Tony around him that died as a result of his sociopathic behaviour. What's also tragic is that Tony Montana ultimately dies by the sword because he wouldn't let an assassin blow up innocent children around the intended target. He made a few remarks about liking children, and judging from what he and his mother say in the movie, Tony must've had a bad childhood (no good father figure, crime, etc.), so he never had a chance to be a good father.


Marty: Goodfellas, Mean Streets
Francis: I and II

Semis: Goodfellas, II

Finals: II

I'm in a small minority on this, but I never liked Scarface, despite watching it more than once. I found no redeeming quality in Tony from the beginning on, so there was no tragedy when the scumbag got what he deserved. Michael Corleone is very different. When his cheekbone was broken by Captain McCluskey, his persona changed. I like II best, both because the 'young Vito' segments with Bobby Di are my favorites in the entire trilogy, and because Michael is like a volcano throughout, with brief, intermittent eruptions.
 
Never liked Scarface. Pacino was way over the top in it. I think both the Godfathers were great, Goodfellas, Casino and Donnie Brasco are the best. Goodfellas was based on Henry Hill's story, Brasco happens to be the true story of FBI agent Joe Pistone and Casino was based on the true story of Lefty Rosenthal who only died a short time ago.
 
From Goodfellas, PG-13 version:

"Funny how? Like I'm a party clown, I make you laugh? I somewhat amuse you?"

"Can you believe this mess? Two African-Americans just stole my truck!"

Unfortunately, AMC also cuts some violence, like in The Godfather Part II, when Vito shoots Don Fanucci in the mouth. Watching censored versions of films I know well is sort of like a CBJ.

They also edited Godfather 2 when Vito slices up Don Ciccio in Sicily.
 
AMC did a good job even though it was "cleaned up" for public consumption. Who could choose from all the greats as listed earlier? Its like asking what is your favorite BJ. The idea of Rudy Guilianni doing the hosting was a stroke of Bella Forutunata so to speak and a nice touch. I am a little disapointed that Casino was omitted from the line up, we could have used a break from a repeat of some of the lesser, if you could call them lesser films. However all in all a great line up of "mob films" Cudos to the folks at AMC.
 
Hoffa with Jack Nicholson was interesting, although I wouldn't call it a Mob movie per se.
 
AMC did a good job even though it was "cleaned up" for public consumption. Who could choose from all the greats as listed earlier? Its like asking what is your favorite BJ. The idea of Rudy Guilianni doing the hosting was a stroke of Bella Forutunata so to speak and a nice touch. I am a little disapointed that Casino was omitted from the line up, we could have used a break from a repeat of some of the lesser, if you could call them lesser films. However all in all a great line up of "mob films" Cudos to the folks at AMC.

Indeed!!!! Plus some of the real life undercover cops and mobsters on witness protection like Henry Hill.
 
Is Henry Hill still in the Witness Protection Program?
It that like a fatwah? Will it ever expire or will he have to keep looking over his shoulder for the rest of his life?

All I know was that he was on WPP. I think you're on it for life until you abandon it at your own peril. The mob never forgets. Even if all the old members died, you'd think that new blood would use Henry Hill as an example to emphasize the rule of 'omerta'.
 
Enjoyed watching Scarface and Donnie Brasco this week.

What's your favourite mob movie?

These are mine:

Goodfellas

A Bronx Tale (actually, this is a real gem)

Casino

Godfather I & II

One Upon Time In America

Donnie Brasco

Scarface

Carlito's Way


Too bad Lilo Brancato Jr. from a Bronx Tale is serving 15 years for manslaughter. He played Matt Bevilacqua on The Sopranos.
 
Is Henry Hill still in the Witness Protection Program?
It that like a fatwah? Will it ever expire or will he have to keep looking over his shoulder for the rest of his life?

Not sure but he sure is out there enough doing interviews, tv appearances etc. On AMC he said he still has an active contract out on him for $500,000!
 
All I know was that he was on WPP. I think you're on it for life until you abandon it at your own peril. The mob never forgets. Even if all the old members died, you'd think that new blood would use Henry Hill as an example to emphasize the rule of 'omerta'.

In the interviews on AMC the subjects said that the omerta or rule of silence doesn't really apply much anymore these days cuz no one wants to do 30 years on murder and/or drug trafficking. It's easier for them to turn state's witness and just go into the WPP.
 
I didnt get to see the end of carlito's way and wish they'd replay it at least once.

Theyve replayed untouchables and godfathers at least 5 times each
 
Man, I can't remember Mean Streets. I've got to check that out.

Mean Streets was Scorcese's film right after Boxcar Bertha with Barbara Hershey, (for Roger Corman), followed by Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore and Taxi Driver. It was Robert De Niro's second starring role, after Bang the Drum Slowly, followed by II. It was also Harvey Keitel's first screen role of any substance. It's not among the four best Mob films, but it is among my four personal favorites. It probably isn't hard to find on torrents.

Mean Streets at rottentomatoes.com: http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/mean_streets/
 
Last edited: