Middle East in Crisis

oil&gas

Well-known member
Apr 16, 2002
17,223
3,470
113
Ghawar
JUNE 13, 2025
M. K. BHADRAKUMAR

Why did Israel jump the gun?

The Israeli Defence Forces called the aerial attack on Iran by some 200 planes in the early hours of Friday, June 13, as a “preemptive strike.” International law gives no scope to attack a country over 1000 kms away on a vague pretext of ‘self-defence’ — or, ‘an immediate operational necessity.’

The UN Charter allows acts in self-defence, but there is nothing that Iran has done in the recent period — at least after President Donald Trump returned to the White House — that can be construed as threatening Israel. Israelis claim to have significantly weakened Iran’s capacity to threaten their country.

So, call it naked aggression. The statement by US Secretary of State Marco Rubio sought to distance the US from Israeli strikes stressing that “Israel took unilateral action” and had advised Washington that “they believe this action was necessary for its self-defence.”

Trump had been telling Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu that such attacks would only undermine the ongoing nuclear negotiations with Iran. The sixth round of US-Iran negotiations is scheduled to take place in Muscat on June 15.

Rubio’s statement underscored that “We are not involved in strikes against Iran and our top priority is protecting American forces in the region.” Rubio did not make the slightest attempt to voice US support for Israel in defending against any Iranian counterstrikes. This is extremely unusual.

The big question is, what forced Netanyahu’s hands — apart from the obvious one of distracting attention from the aggravating domestic political crisis?

One factor is that his personal equations with Trump have been steadily going south, especially since the removal of Mike Waltz on May 1 from the crucial post of National Security Advisor, a key policy-shaping role in the White House.

Waltz’s reassignment as ambassador to the UN came in the aftermath of the so-called “Signalgate” incident, but with hindsight, his leaning towards aggressive military action against arch foe Iran too weighed on Trump’s decision.

No sooner than Waltz lost his position, a purge of key foreign policy and national security positions in the White House began. Known ‘Iran hawks’ whom Waltz had handpicked to assist him have been shuffled out while ‘America First’ realists are in ascent.

They include Eric Trager, who was heading the Middle East and North Africa portfolios for the National Security Council who is considered an ‘Iran hawk’ whom Waltz brought into the post from the pro-Israel Washington Institute for Near East Policy. Again, Morgan Ortagus, considered one of the “strongest pro-Israel supporters in the administration,” was shuffled out of her role as the Lebanon envoy under Trump’s special envoy Steve Witkoff.

According to YNet News, Ortagus’ removal from the position “stunned officials in Jerusalem, where she is viewed as closely aligned with Israeli interests.” Also, Merav Ceran (an Israeli-American who was a former official in Israel’s Ministry of Defense) has been removed from the Iran and Israel desk in the National Security Council.

Certainly, Israel’s moles who favoured war over diplomacy with Iran, have been shown the door while the president himself is negotiating with Iran to curb its nuclear program! (See a fuller account of the White House changes in two reports by the Responsible Statecraft website of Quincy Institute — here , here and here.)

Israelis claim that there was “full and complete coordination” with the Americans ahead of Friday’s attacks but the sentiment has not yet been echoed in Rubio’s statement. Admittedly, Rubio did issue a warning for Iran: “Let me be clear: Iran should not target US interests or personnel.” But that is more of a red line.

Another sensitive factor at work is the growing pressure on Trump from some recognised figures in the Make America Great Again (MAGA) camp backing him, such as Steve Bannon, former chief White House strategist and influential figure. They warn Trump against a hawkish foreign policy stance, particularly by way of support for military interventions abroad, as that is fraught with the risk of splintering the MAGA camp, which would be politically damaging.

Finally, there is the big picture of geopolitical realignments. Last fortnight was a critical period. The audacious Ukrainian attack on Russian nuclear triad on June 1 prompted a call from Trump to Russian President Vladimir Putin within forty-eight hours.

The outcome of their conversation appears to be that: i) US-Russia constructive engagement must run its course; ii) diplomacy will continue on the Ukraine issue even while new facts on the ground may keep shaping diplomacy; and iii) the US is decoupling from European allies in the proxy war in Ukraine.

The stunning part of the phone call was that Trump sought Putin’s intervention in Iran nuclear issue. Putin agreed to help. Only a week later, Iran’s government spokesperson Fatemeh Mohajerani was quoted by Russia’s state RIA news agency as saying, “Putin’s trip to Tehran is currently being worked out, preparations are underway.”

Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei holds Putin in great esteem. Succinctly put, Israel’s worst nightmare is coming true — US-Iran negotiations gaining in the statesmanlike gravitas of a world leader. Without doubt, Putin knows that this could be potentially a game changer in Russia-US relations as resolution of the Iran issue remains critical to the stabilisation of the Middle East and further opportunities may arise to address the Middle East crisis, including the Palestine issue.

Evidently, time is running out for Israel. And Netanyahu has chosen to act now, whether Trump likes it or not. From the Iranian perspective, advantage lies in continuing the talks with Steve Witkoff in Muscat on Sunday. Any attack on the US bases in the region is avoidable in the retaliation that can be expected for sure. Let Israel stew in its aggression. Hurt them where it matters most in the upcoming war.

BBC reported that “In the hours before Thursday’s attacks, US officials were briefing that there would be no American support in the event of Israeli action, even going as far as to say they would not help with any aerial refuelling. That was meant for Tehran’s consumption.”

Trump’s first reaction to Israeli strikes is also in the nature of a case for negotiations and compromise:

“I gave Iran chance after chance to make a deal. I told them, in the strongest of words, to “just do it,” but no matter how hard they tried, no matter how close they got, they just couldn’t get it done.

“I told them it would be much worse than anything they know, anticipated, or were told, that the United States makes the best and most lethal military equipment anywhere in the World, BY FAR, and that Israel has a lot of it, with much more to come – And they know how to use it.

“Certain Iranian hardliners spoke bravely, but they didn’t know what was about to happen. They are all DEAD now, and it will only get worse!

“There has already been great death and destruction, but there is still time to make this slaughter, with the next already planned attacks being even more brutal, come to an end.

“Iran must make a deal, before there is nothing left, and save what was once known as the Iranian Empire. No more death, no more destruction, JUST DO IT, BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE. God Bless You All!”

 
JUNE 16, 2025
M. K. BHADRAKUMAR

Netanyahu’s war on Iran has no future

An unnoticed undercurrent of the Israel-Iran war is that three Christian nations in Europe — UK, France and Germany — have joined the fray with alacrity on the side of Israel.

Strange, isn’t it, that these European countries comprising the so-called E-3 have a well-established exclusive path of dialogue with Iran but are joining Israel’s warpath? It’s a Crusade, stupid!

The three ‘Crusader nations’ share Israel’s obsession to check the rise of a Muslim nation as an emerging power in the Middle East that could radically transform its geopolitical alignments. Simply put, destroying the Islamic regime in Iran is the real objective of Israel’s war — and of the three Christian nations from Europe.

Reportedly, Israeli fighter jets which attacked Iran used the British air base in Cyprus; British refuelling planes are on deployment in Syrian-Iraqi airspace for use of Israeli fighter jets; French president Emmanuel Macron, as defender of Roman Catholicism openly vows that he will act to prevent Israel’s defeat; Germany, the fountainhead of Protestantism, has also similarly positioned itself behind Israel.

However, on the other hand, what emerges from the hour-long phone conversation between Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin on Saturday is that they will work together to advance the path of dialogue with Iran, the current conflict situation notwithstanding. The Kremlin readout stresses that Putin forcefully denounced the Israeli aggression.

Such a line-up of the principal actors signals that Israel’s best bet lies in killing the war itself as a strategic error and create a ‘new normal’? But will Tehran allow Netanyahu to get away with murder? That’s the million dollar question. Putin will have to use all his persuasive power doing the planned visit to Iran — ie., if it still goes ahead.

The Israeli thinking behind its assassination of the IRGC leadership and military commanders stemmed out of the foolish miscalculation that Tehran lacks a political will to resist aggression. The Israeli objective is on the one hand to create conditions for a regime change in Iran and on the other hand to derail any form of US-Iran constructive engagement.

All through, terror has been the chosen weapon for Israel and the western powers to undermine and weaken Iran. But a point has been reached where a containment of Iran is no longer feasible. Logically, Iran’s neighbours in the Muslim world should have rallied in support of Iran but that’s too much to expect, given their limited sovereignty to act independently.

Nonetheless, Iran will not capitulate. Iran’s sense of national pride and honour as a civilisation state will prompt it to circle the wagons and wage a protracted war until victory. From the early days of the revolution, the Islamic republic which was founded on the principles of justice and resistance on the bedrock of nationalism and independence, got attracted to Mao’s concept of ‘protracted people’s war’ to keep predator nations at bay. That strategy paid off during the Iran-Iraq War (1980-1988).

Saddam Hussein too, like Netanyahu, miscalculated that Iran was a hopelessly weakened nation in the civil war conditions with its economy in virtual collapse, army in disarray, state formation yet to crystallise, and with no allies in the region to lend a helping hand. But as it turned out, Iran fought an 8-year war defiantly to a stalemate, undeterred by the lavish support extended to Saddam by the Western powers and their regional allies.

The US even equipped Saddam’s army with chemical weapons to stop the human-wave–attack tactics of Iranian fighters, but of no avail — although, an estimated quarter million Iranians sacrificed their lives.

At some point, in a very near future, Israel will also meet the fate of Saddam, having miscalculated Iran’s grit to resist. Netanyahu also estimated that Iran is a much weakened country compared to last year due to the setbacks taken by the Axis of Resistance. Such naïveté underestimates the potency of resistance at the very core of Shi’ism.

Last week, the resistance forces that were supposedly vanquished from the face of the earth regrouped and began firing missiles at Israel — from Syria, of all places! On May 4, Houthis fired a ballistic missile at Tel Aviv hitting the perimeter of the main terminal of Ben Gurion Airport! Reports suggest that Hezbollah has restored its supply routes from Iran.

What Israel fails to grasp is that resistance movements do not die their raison d’être remains. Israel is, in reality, in very deep crisis fighting on multiple fronts amidst a cascading domestic political crisis and an economy that requires drip feeding by Washington.

As the US’s capacity to influence events in the Middle East keeps diminishing, Israel’s unviability as a nation propped by the Jewish Lobby in the Beltway appears sharper in focus. Already, there is resentment within the US about bankrolling Israel and fighting its wars.

On the contrary, the rise of Iran is inevitable — with a population base 10 times bigger than Israel’s, vast mineral resources, a self-sufficient agricultural sector and broad-based industry, innovative progress in technology, big domestic market, highly strategic location and trained manpower.

Iran’s stamina is of a long distance runner, as Iran-Iraq war showed, whereas, Israel’s forte is as sprinter on a 100 metre track. Make no mistake, Israel, a small country with a population of 8 million people will get hollowed out in a protracted war.

In the current scenario, what goes against Israel critically is that while President Donald Trump tried and failed to stop Netanyahu on the warpath, he is not going to deploy American forces to fight Israel’s war.

Trump has an evangelical base in US politics and is on friendly terms with wealthy Jewish donors, but has nothing in common with the Crusader nations of the Old World — be it on Ukraine or Iran. In both cases, actually, he tends to view the paradigm through the America First prism where he sees immense potential to generate wealth through business links with Russia or Iran.

Besides, Trump is far too smart a politician to risk the future of his MAGA movement whose core tenet is the total rejection of all interventionist ‘forever wars’. Trump knows only too well that American public opinion is staunchly opposed to Middle Eastern wars.

The replacement of Mike Waltz as NSA on May 1 (a known Israeli proxy who found himself in the top echelons of Trump administration) and the subsequent purge of the entire pack of ‘Iran hawks’ in the National Security staff under him, signalled that Trump is wary of Netanyahu’s diabolical plots to derail his negotiations with Iran through back channels. (here and here)

During their phone conversation on Saturday, according to the Kremlin readout, Trump and Putin agreed to prioritise the “negotiating track in Iran’s nuclear programme… Trump noted, the team of US negotiators is ready for resuming work with Iranian representatives.” Clearly, a military confrontation with Iran does not figure in Trump’s calculus.

That being the case, Netanyahu’s bombastic rhetoric apart, Israel’s best interests lie in ending this futile war in the quickest way possible. Conceivably, that is also the preference of the IDF. A protracted war on its own steam with a clutch of crusader nations in tow as cheer leaders is not something that can save Israel from destruction.

Curiously, Trump in his latest Truth Social post on Sunday after the conversation with Putin advised Israel “to make a deal” with Iran! Does that fit into Netanyahu’s war mongering? And Trump went on to burnish his own credentials as a peacemaker president!

Trump concluded predicting that “we will have PEACE, soon, between Israel and Iran!” Succinctly put, Trump has no intentions whatsoever to risk American lives by fighting Netanyahu’s wars.

Obviously, “PEACE, soon” will be Russia and Iran’s preference too, as serious negotiations can be resumed and agreement reached that would herald a US-Iran normalisation and the lifting of American sanctions. But does that suit Netanyahu?

The paradox is, Israel has no future in a protracted war with Iran, but an inconclusive end to this war will pose the high risk for Netanyahu of a cascading demand for a regime change in Israel. Loss of power means loss of parliamentary immunity from prosecution that Netanyahu hitherto enjoyed from corruption charges against him and his family members, and a possible imprisonment.