MERB...jus sayin

wow, was checking out MERB....must say the mods there are strict as hell...you can't even make comments on the posts....just reviews...lol...wonder if we should do the same here ? one dude got a month suspension for posting a PM conversation between two memebers...can you get banned for that here?

The mods there are out of control and have effectively reduced traffic on that board. They editorialize far too much, censor opinion and basically act like bitter vice-principals.

The terb mods have a more difficult job but get it right by letting us kids play most of the time. Hats off to them.
 
Last edited:
The terb mods have a more difficult job but get it right by letting us kids play most of the time. Hats off to them.

lol...true..i've been invovled on flame wars, have posted link to non advertisers, talked shit about crappy service from a paid advertiser..and yet not one ban. :D
 
The mods there are out of control and have effectively reduced traffic on that board. The editorialize and censor opinion and basically act like bitter vice-principals.

The terb mods have a more difficult job but get it right by letting us kids play most of the time. Hats off to them.

I haven't really noticed a problem with that, except when things get uncivil which people in another thread were complaining about here.

One odd thing is that there is a mod that seems to have a thing about quoting. Not people who quote pages just to add a me to, but if you quote one line from the post above you he will delete it and replace it with a "useless quote removed" even though the board rules specifically allow you to do this and it has been pointed out to him.

That being said, I'd put up with that sort of petty bullshit if it meant a merb style reduction of bullshit that is on Terb.

I'd suspect the real difference between terb and merb which are run by the same guy and have the same rules is that terb gets much much more traffic and yet seem to have about the same number of mods, so things get missed and things almost seem to get done at random. Terb would need about 10 active mods to handle the workload.
 
I'd suspect the real difference between terb and merb which are run by the same guy and have the same rules is that terb gets much much more traffic .

Maybe the reason is less censorship although we could do with a few less jerks.
 
The difference is that if you think someone is a jerk you can choose to ignore them or engage them here. On merb you are not afforded that choice which leaves about a dozen regular posters and a steady parade of infrequent posters.

At the end of the day what gets me is the needless proofreading and editing even if 'rules" aren't brokem. They will delete posts if the mod doesn't think they are on point except instead of the original post you get to read the mod taking glee berating some poor poster who probably isn't perfectly bilingual for being verbose.

Hard to believe the asshat ratio is that much higher in Montreal or perhaps its just that the "record keeping" is so much more public.
 
Hard to believe the asshat ratio is that much higher in Montreal or perhaps its just that the "record keeping" is so much more public.

A couple of factors that you may not have considered.
1) there are three boards in Mtl with three very different styles. Regular posters from one may forget to change his style when switching over to the other, causing all kinds of issues. Imagine if you will, if a poster from the TO not so friendly board came on terb and posted as though he was on that other board. Ugly.
2) The language barrier sometimes causes for misinterpretation. Some things that are relatively innocent in one language's culture are more offensive in the other. This beyond straight up misinterpretation.
 
My last venture onto MERB was some years ago when I innocently asked about a girl and supplied her link, just as I have done dozens of times on TERB. Turns out that I breached the rule about supplying a link for a non advertiser and was immediately suspended from MERB for a day. Luckily, I wasn't headed for MTL for another week or so and could still read the posts after my suspension ended with time to do enough research for my trip.

But needless to say, I no longer post on MERB. For an irregular poster such as myself, the risk of being suspended or kicked off the board is overwhelmingly probable given the # of rules they have and how aggressive the mods are.

And frankly, there's also the "who needs this crap? factor" as well. For instance when I DID previously contribute some reviews to MERB, every one of my posts was edited by the MERB-mods to remove my trademark blue ink and rewrite the post in ordinary black ink. Surely to fuck they must have better things to occupy themselves with. I have used blue ink on TERB for 10 years or so with no problems.
 
A couple of factors that you may not have considered.
1) there are three boards in Mtl with three very different styles. Regular posters from one may forget to change his style when switching over to the other, causing all kinds of issues. Imagine if you will, if a poster from the TO not so friendly board came on terb and posted as though he was on that other board. Ugly.
2) The language barrier sometimes causes for misinterpretation. Some things that are relatively innocent in one language's culture are more offensive in the other. This beyond straight up misinterpretation.

Was only aware of a second board which seems to be populated by oddballs, but I don't think any of your points changes my opinion or is in any way an excuse. The complaints/observations about merb are not exactly new. Having said that it must be quite difficult to get bilingual mods there.