
‘The province can’t just walk away’: Olivia Chow wants Doug Ford to stick to the terms of the Science Centre lease. Here’s what that lease says
Mayor Olivia Chow argues that agreements Queen’s Park has signed with Toronto mean Premier Doug Ford’s government can’t abandon the facility.
Updated 2 hrs ago
Mayor Olivia Chow is urging the province to reconsider its decision to abruptly shutter the Ontario Science Centre, arguing that the agreements Queen’s Park has signed with Toronto mean Premier Doug Ford’s government can’t abandon the facility.
“The province can’t just walk away,” Chow told reporters at a press conference Wednesday morning ahead of a council meeting where the fate of the 55-year-old Flemingdon Park attraction will be discussed.
The mayor said she would support a motion, expected to be debated Thursday, that would ask staff to examine the Ontario government’s obligations under its lease with the city for the site at 770 Don Mills Rd
“We have a lease with the province for 99 years for a science centre. And they have some responsibility,” Chow said of the province.
The mayor also cited the Ford government’s obligations under the fiscal “new deal” reached with Toronto in November. Under its terms, the city accepted Queen’s Park had the authority to move ahead with its controversial redevelopment of Ontario
Place and to relocate the Science Centre to the waterfront.
But in exchange, the province agreed to “discuss future partnership opportunities” for “public, community-oriented science programming” at the current Science Centre site.
According to the mayor’s office, although preliminary talks about the future of the site have taken place, formal discussions on any science programming have yet to occur.
Last Friday, the Ford government announced the immediate closure of the Science Centre over concerns that its roof panels — which are constructed with reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete — could collapse.
Infrastructure Minister Kinga Surma said the move was necessary to “protect the health and safety of visitors and staff,” and relocating the centre would result in “a new, state-of-the-art facility.”
But the decision was met with dismay by residents who say the Raymond Moriyama-designed museum was a treasured cultural amenity for generations of Torontonians, and an architectural gem. Chow declared herself “heartbroken.”
A spokesperson for Surma said Wednesday that “no decisions have been made” on the future of the Don Mills property, but as “part of the new deal, the province and city will discuss future partnership opportunities.”
The province didn’t respond to questions about what it believes its obligations are under the Science Centre lease.
The Ontario government owns the centre, but leased the lands it’s built on from the City of Toronto and the Toronto and Region Conservation Authority for a 99-year term that expires in 2064.
The mayor didn’t specify which parts of the lease she believes might prevent the Ontario government from walking away from the Science Centre.
But a copy of the document obtained by the Star shows the province agreed to lease the land “for the purpose of maintaining and operating” a museum, and agreed to “cause good management and care to be taken of the site and any buildings or structures thereon.”
Download PDF

It doesn’t spell out what the penalties would be for ceasing to operate the museum, or allowing it to fall into disrepair.
The lease also contains a provision that would allow the city to purchase the centre and any of its exhibits in the event the building is seriously damaged and the province doesn’t fund repairs within a year.
Coun. Josh Matlow (Ward 12, Toronto-St. Paul’s), who introduced this week’s Science Centre motion, said it would “not be responsible” for the cash-strapped city to exercise its right to buy the damaged building. But he said it’s clear the government hasn’t lived up to the lease requirements.
“Queen’s Park had a responsibility to maintain the Science Centre in good order. Not only have they not done that, they’ve clearly been neglectful,” he said.
Matlow claimed the province owes the city compensation for breaking the terms, “we just need to understand what that means, how much, and what the scope of that would be.”
His motion asks city staff to report to Chow’s executive committee next month on any “provincial requirements” under the lease, and on the feasibility of Toronto operating the centre at its current location. Matlow said the city should only consider running the Science Centre if the province agreed to fund it.

