Lies Hollywood has told us Thread

we do know that these are movies, right? Entertainment?

If you would pay $12 to go watch a scientist in a lab doing real mind-numbing work for 12 hours a day, then maybe Hollywood would change their tactics. It's storytelling and excitement for movies.
 
happy0188.gif


Time to cut down on the caffeine tboy... LOL!

lol maybe.....but when they start debating on whether or not a charater would have an old saying memorized from an old president? TFM
 
lol maybe.....but when they start debating on whether or not a character would have an old saying memorized from an old president? TFM

I agree with T boy

The essence of my thread is to spot lies not implausibilities in order to establish the plot

That they need to lie to create a movie shows a lack of responsibility and creativity

Also they want to perpetuate lies to sell to a willing public that wants them like the lies of the Alamo and OK corral


Fantasy and science fiction is different as you go there to escape and you know it is all BS
 
we do know that these are movies, right? Entertainment?

If you would pay $12 to go watch a scientist in a lab doing real mind-numbing work for 12 hours a day, then maybe Hollywood would change their tactics. It's storytelling and excitement for movies.

exactly, the second people take what happens or is written into a script as fact, that's when they really need to give their head a shake.....

Better yet, let's see them pay $12.00 and see a scientist sitting in his lab 12 hrs a day, for 4 yrs to find a cure for polio. THEN have him go through the long process of the approval process for 4 more years. I don't know about you but I'd rather see Jennifer Aniston's bum when she gets out of the shower TYVM....
 
lol maybe.....but when they start debating on whether or not a charater would have an old saying memorized from an old president?
You forget that a lot of people believe that it is history rather than fiction in a historical setting.
 
4 brothers being drafted all at the same time? 3 of them getting killed at the same time? yeah ok....Or how about a math teacher being put in charge of a combat platoon? He'd be behind a desk somewhere.
The Sullivan brothers all volunteered. As to a math teacher it all depends - when did he join, was he a National Guard Officer etc. . .

After all there were Lawyers and Financiers etc. . . who were Naval Officers and Army Combat Arms Officers (Artillary, Cavalry, Infantry etc. . .) and Army Air Force pilots.
 
even titanic is bullshit because there was no Jack and no jewel of the seas diamond. Fucking assholes for making a movie so untrue.....
Titanic was bullshit, but it was bullshit because it did a very grave disservice to those who died, portraying First Class male passengers as almost universally being total shits rather than as men who gave up their lives because they actually believed in a code of behaviour.
 
Titanic was bullshit, but it was bullshit because it did a very grave disservice to those who died, portraying First Class male passengers as almost universally being total shits rather than as men who gave up their lives because they actually believed in a code of behaviour.

actually, did are you referring to the james cameron version? they portrayed only ONE first class male passenger as being a shit.......the rest were all very civilised (until panic set in then everything went to hell).

If you're referring to the times when Jack was trying to see his girl, well, that's how the first class passengers acted so why NOT show them honestly? BTW: for the most part, especially when Jack was having dinner with the upper ups, he was generally well accepted by everyone......specially Molly Brown.
 
Titanic was bullshit, but it was bullshit because it did a very grave disservice to those who died, portraying First Class male passengers as almost universally being total shits rather than as men who gave up their lives because they actually believed in a code of behaviour.

You are incorrect.

Of the three classes onboard titanic, the so called "First Class" males survived in greater numbers and percentages than either second or third class. The men in first class DID behave as total Shits and DID take the place of women and children from the lower classes in the lifeboats. Even J Bruce Ismay - Managing Director of White Star Line who was on board titanic when she sank, did hop on a lifeboat exactly as portrayed in the movie. He was scorned for his cowardice for the rest of his life and was referred to as J "Brute" Ismay.

The FACT of the matter was it was the second class males who acted with chivalry that cold April night. More than 90 percent of Second Class Male Passengers on board Titanic perished as men rather than as cowards as was the case with the First Class Males. Same goes for the Third Class males – though they died in far greater numbers than the first class pricks.

Like everything else in life – it’s the middle class who always pays the freight.
 
You are incorrect.

Of the three classes onboard titanic, the so called "First Class" males survived in greater numbers and percentages than either second or third class. The men in first class DID behave as total Shits and DID take the place of women and children from the lower classes in the lifeboats. Even J Bruce Ismay - Managing Director of White Star Line who was on board titanic when she sank, did hop on a lifeboat exactly as portrayed in the movie. He was scorned for his cowardice for the rest of his life and was referred to as J "Brute" Ismay.
Most first class male passengers died that night, a fair number of others went into the water but survived because they were able to get on rafts or were picked up by lifeboats.
 
Most first class male passengers died that night, a fair number of others went into the water but survived because they were able to get on rafts or were picked up by lifeboats.

You are still incorrect.

I’m a Titanic nut. Read quite a few books about Titanic, including the most fascinating one about her technology. But I digress. James Cameron is also a Titanic nut and took incredible pains to reproduce the details of the ship and the voyage.

I am afraid you have been mislead as to the mortality rates of the so called “First Class” Males. Only 3 people were picked up from the water (that fact was also in movie). If you went into the water, you died. The film Titanic is very accurate in that respect. White Star Line was very much a microcosm of the rigid British class system of the day. The First Class males survived in greater numbers because they were cowards and elbowed their way into the life boats without regard for the women and children of the lower classes. This is a statistical fact and probably reflective of how they thought of themselves in life – better than everyone else. Completely predictable I would say.

You can google it yourself, or if you like I will provide you the link herewith:

Read "Aftermath"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RMS_Titanic

I was slightly off in my mortality rates among Second Class males. It was actually 92%. (My memory is getting dusty in my old age.)

Statistics do not bear your position out. Looking at the numbers, Third Class Passengers had the highest mortality rates, and Second Class Males truly did adhere to “Women and Children” first. (The only class that can really make that claim frankly.)
 
You are still incorrect.

I’m a Titanic nut. Read quite a few books about Titanic, including the most fascinating one about her technology. But I digress. James Cameron is also a Titanic nut and took incredible pains to reproduce the details of the ship and the voyage.

I am afraid you have been mislead as to the mortality rates of the so called “First Class” Males. Only 3 people were picked up from the water (that fact was also in movie). If you went into the water, you died. The film Titanic is very accurate in that respect. White Star Line was very much a microcosm of the rigid British class system of the day. The First Class males survived in greater numbers because they were cowards and elbowed their way into the life boats without regard for the women and children of the lower classes. This is a statistical fact and probably reflective of how they thought of themselves in life – better than everyone else. Completely predictable I would say.

You can google it yourself, or if you like I will provide you the link herewith:

Read "Aftermath"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RMS_Titanic

I was slightly off in my mortality rates among Second Class males. It was actually 92%. (My memory is getting dusty in my old age.)

Statistics do not bear your position out. Looking at the numbers, Third Class Passengers had the highest mortality rates, and Second Class Males truly did adhere to “Women and Children” first. (The only class that can really make that claim frankly.)
Then again it may be just who one knows about.

John B. Thayer III - sat atop the capsized Collapsible B
Richard Norris Williams, II - sat atop the capsized Collapsible A
Archibald Gracie IV - sat atop the capsized Collapsible B
Algernon H. W. Barkworth

The above all went into the water and survived.

All of the following men refused to get into lifeboats and died that horrible night.

John B. Thayer, Jr.

Charles D. Williams

George D. Widener
Harry Elkins Widener

John Jacob Astor IV

Washington A. Roebling, II

Wyckoff Van der Hoef

Isidor (and his wife Ida) Straus

Benjamin Guggenheim

John E. Maguire

The movie spent way too much time on "Cal" being a shit, and not nearly enough time on the above.
 
You should compile a list of the Second Class male passengers who died - it works out to be 92% of them. That would be some long list.

You are an Upper Crust Appologist aren't you. In all of your posts, all the time, I have observed that you lick the boots of the rich and slag the middle class every chance you get. Your outlook on life even shows through on a stupid thread like this.

Even when confronted with statistical facts that contadict your assertion, you refuse to acknowledge that you are incorrect and try to twist things round.

End of Rant.

The fact is that the so called "First Class" males on board Titanic survived in far greater numbers than even the women and children in Third Class. They did not obey the First Rule of the Sea - "Women and Children First" Sure, there were exceptions, but not too many - 10 by your own list.
 
You are an Upper Crust Appologist aren't you. In all of your posts, all the time, I have observed that you lick the boots of the rich and slag the middle class every chance you get. Your outlook on life even shows through on a stupid thread like this.
If you believe this about me, then you likewise give every impression of À la lanterne. For every J. Bruce Ismay or Cosmo Duff-Gordon there was a John Jacob Astor or Charles D. Williams. It is popular these days to mention the former but not the later.
 
Well even if Aard fails to see the light, I do James. Thanks for the corrections. If your stats are true, then the upper class were actually schmucks and cowards.......
 
Well even if Aard fails to see the light, I do James. Thanks for the corrections. If your stats are true, then the upper class were actually schmucks and cowards.......
This is a problem with statistics - it leaves out real people living real lives.

I have no reason to not believe the statistics, however personally I'm aware of two men who pushed their way onto a lifeboat, several others who were put onto lifeboats by the ships officers because they had small craft experience (which I would hope others would also see as an utterly different thing), and finally over a dozen who did not attempt to push others out of the way. To catagorize the lives and debase the heroism of the latter two groups based on statistics is to put it very mildly unjust.