Leica V-Lux 1 digital camera

markvee said:
The giftee and I have never needed to shoot a picture more than once every minute or so.

If I wanted faster, I would just shoot a movie.

Assuming that shot to shot time is important, the Canon PowerShot S3 IS is slower (at 1.7 seconds) than the Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ50 (at 1.5 or ~1.6 seconds depending on the review).

http://reviews.cnet.com/Leica_V_Lux_1/4505-6501_7-32077813.html?subj=fdba&part=rss&tag=MR_Search+Results

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/canons3is/page4.asp

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/panasonicfz50/page5.asp

I don't know if they are comparing taking pictures in the same format. I'm assuming that the Lumix would take longer to record in RAW format.

Either one are fine cameras. I know people with the original Canon S1 IS, and they love it. I've played with it, and it was great, easy to use. I have the older Lumix, and it works well. No, you can't zoom during taking movies, as far as I know. If that is important, I'd look elsewhere.

The items I was looking for that swayed me to the Lumix at the time was the larger optical zoom on the older Lumix versus the S1, better low-light shooting, and the flash hot shoe (can use an external flash for more variety of capabilities.) Since then, Canon has been matching the optical features, and I think have introduced a wireless remote flash. Competition is cool stuff.

The shot-to-shot timings are virtually identical, I wouldn't worry about it. There's burst mode (aka continuous mode) in case you need it.

The Lumix has a RAW format, but I've never bothered with it. It would take longer to write out to the card. The low-compression JPEG's are good enough for me. Some serious photoshoppers might want the TIFF's, so it is really up to you.

One very popular addition that people make to the older Lumix's is the installation of a lens adapter tube, and a UV filter on the front. This keeps the lens clean, adds some protection in case you drop the camera. I think the newer ones are designed a bit differently, but still allow a UV filter via an adapter.

The Lumix is a relatively large camera. About as big as an old-style SLR. Go take a look at one. You'll not be tucking it into a tiny camera bag, especially with a UV filter & adapter on it. My memory is the Canon S1 was definitely smaller, not sure about the S3.

Oh, the Lumix has a focus ring on it. It isn't mechanically focusing the lens directly, but electrically controls the focus, simulating the older SLR lens experience. Once in a while manual focus is handy, and the ring is a natural way to do it if you're used to a traditional SLR.

The www.dpreview.com site has very knowledgeable people in the forums, you might want to search through there too for people's likes and dislikes for both models.
 
monkeychan said:
If it can be done with dSLR at 5 fps (meaning from shot to shot is 0.2 of a sec wait), there is no reason for any camera (especially nowadays) requiring more than 0.5 sec from shot to shot. :)

Like a wiseman once said "you can't go wrong with Canon".

I think the issue there is that when not in burst/continuous mode, the camera goes out to redraw the display, possibly refocus/reevaluate lighting, etc. It takes time. You can get that time down lower, but you'll pay for it.

The dpreview guys sum it up in the timings commentary for the new EOS-1D. Even though it can do 3 fps continuous, the process of getting a normal shot ready is over a second. Cheaper cameras (a Lumix or S3 is likely about $300+ USD cheaper if you need to buy a lens for the EOS-1D) will be a bit slower -- 1.7 secs or more.

The overall performance of the EOS 400D was good although not perhaps as 'snappy' in-use as its major competitor, the Nikon D80. Startup 'off to shot' time is as good as instant, which means assuming you are sure of camera settings you can flick the power switch and take a shot (auto focus willing) within a few tenths of a second. However the use of the LCD monitor for status display means if you wish to check your settings before shooting (as most of us do) you will have to wait just over one second.

Anyhow, we're getting waay off-topic. The basic point that I originally wanted to point out was that 2.1/1.7 seconds, (or a little over a second for a new Canon DSLR) is the normal shot-to-shot setup time, not the time it takes from pressing the shutter button to activating the shutter.
 
benstt said:
The Lumix has a RAW format, but I've never bothered with it.

Benstt...explore it! Raw is the format you are looking for. If you are shooting for basic photographs then pick a camera that shoots only jpegs.

Jpegs are prety much passe` in the pro world now. We output to tiff and with CMYK seperation.

But you still want that flexibility of RAW in your shots. If you are at all interested in correcting your photgraphs you want RAW capability. It allows you several f/stops of correction plus white balance and a slew of other corrections.

If the camera has it..explore it! It is the digital darkroom before you get to photoshop!

M2
 
And the winner is ...

Canon

Canon PowerShot S3 IS ($489.95 at Vistek) ($459.99 at Bestbuy)
Best movie mode, 6.2MP, no RAW


Sony Cyber-shot H5 ($549 at Vistek) ($479.99 at Futureshop)
Good movie mode, 7.2MP, no RAW

Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ50 ($759.95 at Vistek) ($739.99 at Downtown Camera)
RAW, 10.4MP, no autozoom on movies

Fujifilm Finepix S6000fd ($449.95 at Vistek = cheapest)
RAW, 6.3MP, no image stabilization on movies

The biggest and cheapest SD card I can find:
2GB SD card ($49.99 at Futureshop)


I have a few more questions:

1) Any better in-store prices on the camera or SD card are appreciated.

2) Is this the address for Amazing Photo (It's not in Market Village but rather between Warden and Victoria Park on Steeles East)?
Amazing Photo Inc 905-944-8805 3636 Steeles Avenue East, Markham

3) Recommendations on the longest lasting rechargeable AA batteries (plus recommendations on where to buy) are appreciated.

Thanks again for all the help.
 
markvee said:
Canon

Canon PowerShot S3 IS ($489.95 at Vistek) ($459.99 at Bestbuy)
Best movie mode, 6.2MP, no RAW


Sony Cyber-shot H5 ($549 at Vistek) ($479.99 at Futureshop)
Good movie mode, 7.2MP, no RAW

Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ50 ($759.95 at Vistek) ($739.99 at Downtown Camera)
RAW, 10.4MP, no autozoom on movies

Fujifilm Finepix S6000fd ($449.95 at Vistek = cheapest)
RAW, 6.3MP, no image stabilization on movies

The biggest and cheapest SD card I can find:
2GB SD card ($49.99 at Futureshop)


I have a few more questions:

1) Any better in-store prices on the camera or SD card are appreciated.

2) Is this the address for Amazing Photo (It's not in Market Village but rather between Warden and Victoria Park on Steeles East)?
Amazing Photo Inc 905-944-8805 3636 Steeles Avenue East, Markham

3) Recommendations on the longest lasting rechargeable AA batteries (plus recommendations on where to buy) are appreciated.

Thanks again for all the help.

I buy me memory cards from http://www.cty.ca (located in west Beaver Creek), they tend to have the cheapest price

The Warden & Steeles location of Amazing Photo will be closed down in January '07 and be merged together with the one located in Market Village. Phone number is 905-947-8998.

For rechargeable AA batteries, get a known brand name such as Power 2000, Pro Tama, Sanyo that's at least 2,800 mAh. I personally use Power 2000 and Sanyo. The Sanyo charger sold at Costco is the best value I've ever used (4 channel, super fast charger -- charged 4 AA 2,800 mAh batteries in less than 3 hours)