Led Zeppelin tainted legacy

When I say to 'some extent', it wasn't blatant.

The court had to get experts to analyze the cadence, rhythm, and what not to determine if it was plagiarism.

Sometimes I would imagine, songs are burned into a musician's subconscious and goes into their creative machinations.
Agreed. I don't believe Harrison lifted it deliberately - or believed the debt would go unnoticed had he done so - but only the most tone deaf wouldn't have been able to recognize the melody is identical to 'He's So Fine'.
 
Seems like Led Zeppelin has blatantly plagiarized many a song, note for note, rift for rift, word for word. I was aware that many groups, the Stones, the Beatles often covered other groups songs but eventually produced masterpieces of their own. Zeppelin however took plagiarism to the extreme, taking from American blues artist, Joan Baez and others and getting away with it for a long time, including " Stair Way to Heaven" . The arrogant thieving bastards took in hundreds of millions of dollars pretending that the music was of solely of their own making. Zeppelin and Atlantic Records have had numerous legal battles with the original artists. Jimmy Page is an excellent cover guitarist, Plant and excellent cover vocalist. An interest read is found in Bloomberg's May 19-24, 2014. Howard Stern had a show exposing the plagiarism, playing the original followed by the Zeppelin theft. WTF, I still listen to them and enjoy, but much less so as I like originals. This is like finding and enjoying a beautiful lady for years and years, thinking that she was all natural only to find that all this time she has been surgically enhanced masterfully, all over. I hate implants. The song no longer remains the same for ZOSO IMHO.


Zeppelin was such a big part of my teenage years that I found this to be extremely disappointing, and rather than describe it as you did: "This is like finding and enjoying a beautiful lady for years and years, thinking that she was all natural only to find that all this time she has been surgically enhanced masterfully, all over. I hate implants. ..."

For me it's more like having an amazing time in bed only to wake up the next morning where a confession is made that "she" used to be a "he"!!!!!!
 
Zeppelin was such a big part of my teenage years that I found this to be extremely disappointing, and rather than describe it as you did: "This is like finding and enjoying a beautiful lady for years and years, thinking that she was all natural only to find that all this time she has been surgically enhanced masterfully, all over. I hate implants. ..."

For me it's more like having an amazing time in bed only to wake up the next morning where a confession is made that "she" used to be a "he"!!!!!!

Ironically, Zeppelin was NEVER a part of my teenage years. In fact I detested them. I grew up in Hamilton and in the late 70's, early 80's, every meat-head at my High School (and there were tons of them) loved Zeppelin. All you saw was black teeshirts with Zeppelin this and Zeppelin that and posters. I associated Zeppelin with stoners and hoods and since I didn't particularly get along well with hoods, by default, I didn't like Zeppelin.

I suppose that was just teenage stupidity on my part.

But I was hugely into the Beatles (almost no-one else was because the Beatles had been out of the music scene for 10 years and were considered ancient and irrelevant by 99% of my High School peers), and then U2 and new wave. Once I hit Grade 13 and university, the hoods all faded away and my hatred of Zeppelin did too.

Now I love their music and whether or not they drew their influences from whoever, or even copied a few notes or even a riff along the way doesn't detract it for me in the slightest. They are a remarkable musical talent.
 
Ironically, Zeppelin was NEVER a part of my teenage years. In fact I detested them. I grew up in Hamilton and in the late 70's, early 80's, every meat-head at my High School (and there were tons of them) loved Zeppelin. All you saw was black teeshirts with Zeppelin this and Zeppelin that and posters. I associated Zeppelin with stoners and hoods and since I didn't particularly get along well with hoods, by default, I didn't like Zeppelin.

I suppose that was just teenage stupidity on my part.

But I was hugely into the Beatles (almost no-one else was because the Beatles had been out of the music scene for 10 years and were considered ancient and irrelevant by 99% of my High School peers), and then U2 and new wave. Once I hit Grade 13 and university, the hoods all faded away and my hatred of Zeppelin did too.

Now I love their music and whether or not they drew their influences from whoever, or even copied a few notes or even a riff along the way doesn't detract it for me in the slightest. They are a remarkable musical talent.


I was more into funk (Tower of Power, Kool and the Gang, Earth, Wind and Fire and the like), but couldn't help to know about the metal bands cuz my bro is a guitarist. Led Zep was associated with that 'stoner' crowd lol. But Stairway To Heaven was a great slow song to dance with that pretty girl at the school dance.

I had a resurgence into Zeppelin years later.
 
Agreed. I don't believe Harrison lifted it deliberately - or believed the debt would go unnoticed had he done so - but only the most tone deaf wouldn't have been able to recognize the melody is identical to 'He's So Fine'.

He's So Fine sounds like a do-wop song.
 
Ironically, Zeppelin was NEVER a part of my teenage years. In fact I detested them. I grew up in Hamilton and in the late 70's, early 80's, every meat-head at my High School (and there were tons of them) loved Zeppelin. All you saw was black teeshirts with Zeppelin this and Zeppelin that and posters. I associated Zeppelin with stoners and hoods and since I didn't particularly get along well with hoods, by default, I didn't like Zeppelin.

I suppose that was just teenage stupidity on my part.

But I was hugely into the Beatles (almost no-one else was because the Beatles had been out of the music scene for 10 years and were considered ancient and irrelevant by 99% of my High School peers), and then U2 and new wave. Once I hit Grade 13 and university, the hoods all faded away and my hatred of Zeppelin did too.

Now I love their music and whether or not they drew their influences from whoever, or even copied a few notes or even a riff along the way doesn't detract it for me in the slightest. They are a remarkable musical talent.


Funny how things work; peer pressure and stereotypes and how we can luckily grow out of them when we become our own person.

I loved Led Zep, but wasn't a stoner. Although too many of my friends were until most had dropped out of school and we lost touch. I had Zeppelin concerts shirts etc. but I never really wore them because I didn't want to be stereotyped.

James T Kirk, you loved The Beatles and discovered Zeppelin later---it was the opposite for me. Didn't appreciate the Beatles at all when I was young. Think I was influenced by my BF's old sister who always said they sucked (and she had nice big tits so she had to be right!). Discovered the Beatles in University and love them more and more with every passing year. I can listen to "1" their hits album forever and love discovering some of their older less popular tracks too . However, I rarely listen to Zeppelin anymore. But if I'm dial surfing in the car and hear a Zeppelin song come on (and nobody is in the car to complain) I always crank it up!
 
. However, I rarely listen to Zeppelin anymore. But if I'm dial surfing in the car and hear a Zeppelin song come on (and nobody is in the car to complain) I always crank it up!

LOL, yeah, sometimes the right song comes on the radio and I'm in the right mood and I just crank it up too. Better yet, with the windows down on a nice summer night and even speeding a bit. Makes you feel great.
 
LMAO!

My high-school was a notorious drug haven, everyone got high. To give you an indication of how prevalent it was, the Valedictorian of my graduating year dropped out of university after three weeks. We were split into two camps. The mainstream stoners listened to Led Zeppelin and at Holloween would go the Rocky Horror Picture Show route. The hardcore stoners listened to Black Sabbath and at Halloween would become Droogs (A Clockwork Orange).

Funeral March for Queen Anne, by Henry Purcell.

 
LMFAO!!!

I remember being in a line-up at a variety store with a friend who wore a denim vest with a Black Sabbath patch on the back, and overhearing two really old bitties behind us say something like "oh my Mildred, I think there's a Devil worshipper ahead of us"....
 
No big deal, really. The untold side of the music biz.

Song similarities have been happening for decades.
In most cases, record labels do their due diligence and make pre-arrangements with labels and publishers.
 
:blah: Oh stop your bellyaching. Dixon only got a credit. They didn't rename the songs or remove LZ's authorship. Those songs are not identical.

stop with your sanitizing..LZ are rip off artists.............
 
LMFAO!!!

I remember being in a line-up at a variety store with a friend who wore a denim vest with a Black Sabbath patch on the back, and overhearing two really old bitties behind us say something like "oh my Mildred, I think there's a Devil worshipper ahead of us"....

I must have been considered a devil worshipper then. I loved Black Sabbath too. In my teen years I was a stoner and so were most of my friends and that was the music we listened to. Had a Muntz 8track player in the car just blasting out the tunes. Fucking awesome.