Khamenei addresses the NAM summit

seth gecko

Well-known member
Nov 2, 2003
3,744
81
48
Excerpts:
"The Islamic Republic of Iran considers the use of nuclear, chemical and similar weapons as a great and unforgivable sin. We proposed the idea of 'Middle East free of nuclear weapons' and we are committed to it. This does not mean forgoing our right to peaceful use of nuclear power and production of nuclear fuel. On the basis of international laws, peaceful use of nuclear energy is a right of every country."

"I stress that the Islamic Republic has never been after nuclear weapons and that it will never give up the right of its people to use nuclear energy for peaceful purposes. Our motto is: "Nuclear energy for all and nuclear weapons for none." We will insist on each of these two precepts, and we know that breaking the monopoly of certain Western countries on production of nuclear energy in the framework of the Non-Proliferation Treaty is in the interest of all independent countries, including the members of the Non-Aligned Movement."

He does rant about the UN, America, Zionists, Palestine, etc etc, but assuming he wants to die peacefully of natural causes, there's just no way he could make such a statement (second or third time now) before an int'l audience and currently be pursuing the development of nukes.
 
Ok, then is he suffering from Saddam Hussein syndrome i.e. that Iran won't be open about their nuclear program, because for some reason they believe that doing so would be more harmful than provoking an attack by the U.S. or Israel?
 
Ok, then is he suffering from Saddam Hussein syndrome i.e. that Iran won't be open about their nuclear program, because for some reason they believe that doing so would be more harmful than provoking an attack by the U.S. or Israel?

Iran isn't as isolated as the US thinks they are. Sanctions are being bypassed left & right. Without absolute, ironclad certaintly that Iran is building nukes, any escalation of hostility would likely play to Irans benefit (after the short-term problems of removing all the rubble, that is). Iran is calculating that they can afford to be opaque, and they're probably right. Smart thing to do IMO is forget about Parchin & what may have happened 10 years ago there & deal with whats really happening in Natanz & Fordo & the facailites that the IAEA are regularly & thoroughly inspecting. Build some trust.
 
Iran isn't as isolated as the US thinks they are. Sanctions are being bypassed left & right. Without absolute, ironclad certaintly that Iran is building nukes, any escalation of hostility would likely play to Irans benefit (after the short-term problems of removing all the rubble, that is). Iran is calculating that they can afford to be opaque, and they're probably right. Smart thing to do IMO is forget about Parchin & what may have happened 10 years ago there & deal with whats really happening in Natanz & Fordo & the facailites that the IAEA are regularly & thoroughly inspecting. Build some trust.

Parchin was inspected a few years ago, and worse, the info the IAEA has that makes them want to inspect again is actually rehashed info from about 2001 or so.
But most of that is irrelevant to the fact that iran's uranium production is still under inspection. They couldn't produce weapons grade material without everyone knowing, and without it can't build a bomb. What the IAEA's clients (and non-client) are worried about is Iran building the infrastructure to build a bomb, should they ever desire, so that it could be built quickly when they are threatened more seriously with war. And given the amount of threats going on against them and the info out that says they still aren't building the bomb, its fairly rational to believe that they aren't going to.
 
Keep spinning groggy, the reason they have to work with rehashed information from 2001 is that Iran is flouting the requirement to open its facilities for proper inspections on a regular basis.

You are trying to present the lack of information as evidence there is no program when in fact the lack of information is the problem.
 
Iran isn't as isolated as the US thinks they are. Sanctions are being bypassed left & right. Without absolute, ironclad certaintly that Iran is building nukes, any escalation of hostility would likely play to Irans benefit (after the short-term problems of removing all the rubble, that is). Iran is calculating that they can afford to be opaque, and they're probably right. Smart thing to do IMO is forget about Parchin & what may have happened 10 years ago there & deal with whats really happening in Natanz & Fordo & the facailites that the IAEA are regularly & thoroughly inspecting. Build some trust.

The Iranian currency and standard of living would differ with your assessment of how well the sanctions are working.
 
If you start blockading and/or intercepting Iranian ships, isn't that the same as a declaration of war?

The Iranians could certainly treat it that way, but the time has come to stop pussy footing around the issue. They need to come clean about their nuclear program and provide full access to inspectors as required by the binding resolutions demanding that.

No more oil sales until they comply would perhaps finally get the message across.
 
Parchin was inspected a few years ago, and worse, the info the IAEA has that makes them want to inspect again is actually rehashed info from about 2001 or so. ...

Yes, all those satellite images of current clean up is from 2001??????

And Iran allowed access to a very small part of Parchin years ago.
 
The Iranian currency and standard of living would differ with your assessment of how well the sanctions are working.
The sanctions are biting hard, Iran has admitted as much, and the gov't has already put the country into a severe austerity economic plan.
But the sanctions are being circumvented by lots of Iran's neighbours & clients - India, China, Pakistan, etc. For every peabrain out there who applauds Ecuador for standing up to the US re the Assange situation, there's just as many doing the same for Iran. Lots of nations are finding common ground in their dissatisfaction with US foreign policy. Unless the US wants to continue the with the same scenario for the next 30 years (or worse, should the next Ayatollah reassess the the situation and decide nukes are worth having), they should consider a shift in their policy regarding Iran - IMO & experience with those cultures, you get much better results with finesse rather than force.

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/30/business/inquiry-looks-at-chinese-banks-iran-role.html
 
Seth, just read an interesting take on the IAEA Iran statements and the UNSC responses.

Seems that Iran actually decreased their stock of 20% enriched uranium in the last report, amongst other things not reported here.
http://www.iranaffairs.com/iran_affairs/2012/08/analysis-of-latest-iaea-report-on-iran-august-2012.html

Also seems the UNSC is overstepping the bounds of their resolutions, assuming Section 39 powers to resolutions based on Section 40.
http://www.iranaffairs.com/iran_affairs/2010/02/brill-kuperman_iran_unsc-resolutions.html

And the NAM backs Iran's nuclear power industry:
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/01/world/middleeast/iran-criticizes-egypts-mohamed-morsi-over-syria-comments.html?_r=1
 
I agree with Iran's nuke free policy for the middle east, but all the Israel backers are avoiding that logical step towards easing the tension. When will Israel open up for inspections, Fuji?
 
I agree with Iran's nuke free policy for the middle east, but all the Israel backers are avoiding that logical step towards easing the tension. When will Israel open up for inspections, Fuji?

When North Korea and Iran open up first..... :D
 
Iran is a signatory still undergoing monitoring and is not blocking a move to a nuke free middle east.

Iran has serially violated almost all of its requirements to allow monitoring. It is not in compliance, far, far from it. That's the problem. If Iran actually did comply with the UN requests to open its facilities up for monitoring this whole crisis would go away.
 
I agree with Iran's nuke free policy for the middle east, but all the Israel backers are avoiding that logical step towards easing the tension. When will Israel open up for inspections, Fuji?

Let me put it to you bluntly, you may disagree--if you like dicatorships and love tyranny you certainly will disagree--but here's reality: Israel is a full fledged democracy, Iran is one of the worlds worst dictatorships and a state sponsor of terrorism. I have absolutely no problem with Israel having nuclear weapons. I have a big problem with terrorists getting ahold of nuclear weapons. If you love terrorism and if you love tyranny you will probably cal this hypocritical, but it's not. I apply different standards to modern Western democracies and I'm going to defend that position. Democracies are better in every way.

Iran in particular if it got ahold of nuclear weapons could not be trusted with them. It really might provide nuclear materials to terrorist organizations, which really might use them in terrorist attacks.

Now I know from your posting history that you hate the West, you think democracies like Canada, the United States, and Israel are evil, and you love dictatorships and sponsors of terrorism. I think it's some sort of misguided guilt trip on your own part, I don't think you've thought it through. But that's what I gather from your posting history. You always seem to think that the dictators and terrorists are being hard done by.
 
Iran in particular if it got ahold of nuclear weapons could not be trusted with them. It really might provide nuclear materials to terrorist organizations, which really might use them in terrorist attacks.

Oh why oh why must I occasionally open up a Fuji post? Ignore is so much better.

Ok Fuji.

So Iran isn't to be trusted but Israel is?
Israel who is lead by someone who worked to steal nuclear technology and material from their ally, the US?
Israel who tried to sell the bomb to Apartheid era South Africa?

Such double standards.

You make Ahmadenijad's call for a nuclear free middle east sound comparatively sane and trustworthy.