Guest workes in the Niagara area are very important to the economy. We would not have much of a wine industry without them. The working conditions may not be that great - but much better than in Mexico and in the US. Their work creates higher value work in the wine industry - marketing, production etc.
I think the system works well for all parties - many of the workers come back year after year. It is seasonal work - so it is not attractive to Canadians. But it is crucial for the wine companies.
I think that there should be far more training in the trades - carpenters, plumbers, welders, tool & die etc. These trades can be very lucrative but because they are "blue collar" students are discouraged to pursue. A good, experienced carpenter can easy clear $100k. Nothing wrong with that.
There actually is not a training program in Canada to become a butcher. A good butcher - at least $60 K and over $100 if he owns his store. All are either trained at work or are foreigners. What is wrong with being a butcher?
I have always thought that butchers more often than not start out as apprentices to existing butchers, in a manner similar to plumbers or electricians. Correct me if I am mistaken about this.

