I asked this in a thread someone else started in the incall forum asking about the current laws, and thought it would be more appropriate to start a different one here.
----------------
If hell froze over and the federal government got rid of the laws that made incalls and brothels criminal, what type of operations should be allowed? This would probably be decided at the municipal level (although I suppose all levels of government could be involved).
Incalls run by a very small number independent SPs would seem logical, and probably what most SPs would want. Yet it's what the general public would superficially find the most objectionable -- "I don't want a brothel in the house or apartment next to me". It's what cities are least likely to allow, although I doubt they would put any more effort into going after incalls than they do now.
Large brothels away from residential areas would be more acceptable to people, but are more likely to be run by organized crime, and disliked by SPs who would prefer to not be controlled by brothel owners.
Letting the massage parlours legally become small brothels would seem reasonable and in line with what we already have in most cities, but they've already screwed up that situation with licensing.
-------------------
In looking through the transcripts of some of the meetings of The House of Commons Subcommittee, it looks like Australia and New Zealand were mentioned by many people, which would seem relevant since they have much in common with us, including the fact that their former laws were very similar to Canada's. Unfortunately many of those speaking to the subcommittee were abolitionists trying to portray these changes as negative, which seems strange since some Australian states have allowed brothels for quite a few years with other states and NZ following more recently, and not one has reversed this move.
----------------
If hell froze over and the federal government got rid of the laws that made incalls and brothels criminal, what type of operations should be allowed? This would probably be decided at the municipal level (although I suppose all levels of government could be involved).
Incalls run by a very small number independent SPs would seem logical, and probably what most SPs would want. Yet it's what the general public would superficially find the most objectionable -- "I don't want a brothel in the house or apartment next to me". It's what cities are least likely to allow, although I doubt they would put any more effort into going after incalls than they do now.
Large brothels away from residential areas would be more acceptable to people, but are more likely to be run by organized crime, and disliked by SPs who would prefer to not be controlled by brothel owners.
Letting the massage parlours legally become small brothels would seem reasonable and in line with what we already have in most cities, but they've already screwed up that situation with licensing.
-------------------
In looking through the transcripts of some of the meetings of The House of Commons Subcommittee, it looks like Australia and New Zealand were mentioned by many people, which would seem relevant since they have much in common with us, including the fact that their former laws were very similar to Canada's. Unfortunately many of those speaking to the subcommittee were abolitionists trying to portray these changes as negative, which seems strange since some Australian states have allowed brothels for quite a few years with other states and NZ following more recently, and not one has reversed this move.

