Incalls/brothels- What SHOULD be allowed?

HaywoodJabloemy

Dissident
Apr 3, 2002
655
0
0
Never the safest place
I asked this in a thread someone else started in the incall forum asking about the current laws, and thought it would be more appropriate to start a different one here.
----------------
If hell froze over and the federal government got rid of the laws that made incalls and brothels criminal, what type of operations should be allowed? This would probably be decided at the municipal level (although I suppose all levels of government could be involved).

Incalls run by a very small number independent SPs would seem logical, and probably what most SPs would want. Yet it's what the general public would superficially find the most objectionable -- "I don't want a brothel in the house or apartment next to me". It's what cities are least likely to allow, although I doubt they would put any more effort into going after incalls than they do now.

Large brothels away from residential areas would be more acceptable to people, but are more likely to be run by organized crime, and disliked by SPs who would prefer to not be controlled by brothel owners.

Letting the massage parlours legally become small brothels would seem reasonable and in line with what we already have in most cities, but they've already screwed up that situation with licensing.
-------------------
In looking through the transcripts of some of the meetings of The House of Commons Subcommittee, it looks like Australia and New Zealand were mentioned by many people, which would seem relevant since they have much in common with us, including the fact that their former laws were very similar to Canada's. Unfortunately many of those speaking to the subcommittee were abolitionists trying to portray these changes as negative, which seems strange since some Australian states have allowed brothels for quite a few years with other states and NZ following more recently, and not one has reversed this move.
 
rubmeister100 said:
Girls could rent a room from the property manager running a hotel with smaller specially designed rooms (bed, shower, sink etc) rooms.
Why smaller? I find many hotel rooms are rather small to begin with. But then, I'm in a wheel-chair which makes isle space seem even smaller.

Personally, I think I'd like to see a brothel with a lounge area, where you could have a drink and relax - maybe play some cards or shoot some pool. The ladies would be encouraged to chat and mingle. With private rooms in the back of course.

Oh, and the law should require that all brothels be wheel-chair accessible! :D
 
What about Bukakke conveyor belts for the cash strapped?
 
My view is once you allow it you let entrepeneurs and SP's decide how they want to set up. Each muniicipality would regulate where they allow the business to be set up. In larger cities you might have sex hotels, in the burbs you might get a small industrial plaza location. The premises would be inspected on a surprise basis and full disclosure of the finances would be needed to ensure money goes to the girls, taxes are paid and crime figures are not skimming some off. Other restrictions would be no locations should be near schools etc.

My most preferred would be larger facility where you can preview the providers in a lounge etc. and select the one you want, prices are up front so you know what you are paying for. :cool:
 
I would approach the issue differently. Each woman would have an ID card that she would have to show to customers upon request. Whatever regulations the government required (health checks, taxes, etc.) would be reflected on the card (some sort of date stamp would be needed to show that it was current, e.g. from a monthly STD test).

With a valid card the woman could sell her services in any way she wanted: incall, outcall, brothel, streetcorner. There would be local rules (e.g. no brothels next to schools) but in general the marketplace would decide.
 
what should be allowed

I should be allowed to set up an incall at home, all this travelling around is such a time waster!
 
George OTJ said:
...I'd like to see a brothel with a lounge area, where you could have a drink and relax... The ladies would be encouraged to chat and mingle. With private rooms in the back of course.
From what I've read, I think that's the way most of them are in Australia, although some aren't allowed to serve alcohol. At least one of them in Melbourne let everyone know they were wheelchair accessible 4 years ago.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/1219879.stm
 
HaywoodJabloemy said:
Large brothels away from residential areas would be more acceptable to people, but are more likely to be run by organized crime, and disliked by SPs who would prefer to not be controlled by brothel owners.

Why organized crime, if it is legalized?

Also, my ideal brothel setup is here:
http://www.fkk-oase.de/
or
http://web129.ehoster04.de/index.php

It's, large, clean, with lots of mingling, food, non-alco drinks, sauna, massage, pool..... at reasonable prices.

If a few of these would pop up around TO (wishful thinking) they would wipe out a good portion of MPs and SP agencies.

And, GotJ, it is wheelchair friendly.
 
Meister said:
Why organized crime, if it is legalized?
I suppose bigger brothels bring in bigger profits, and maybe easier to control a small number of large ones than many little ones.
http://www.parl.gc.ca/infocomdoc/38/1/SSLR/Meetings/Evidence/SSLREV15-E.HTM
...created huge brothels that could be controlled by organized crime. They admit that's what's happening. When you create huge brothels where sex workers don't control what's going on, it invites organized crime, and they have seen an increase in organized crime controlling these brothels. That's in Melbourne, in Victoria.

...The problem that happened in Victoria was they set very high costs, and organized crime were the only ones that could afford to pay. So they created these massive brothels, which are not good for sex workers.
 
Just make it legal and let the market work it out. There are already zoning bylaws that prevent you from running a business in a residential area. That should be all that regulation that is required to prevent people from having to worry that it is going to happen in their back yard.
 
OK, the only regulations I think would be appropriate:

1) All sex workers should be licensed the way strippers are, but by the province rather than the city. The licensing process should involve a really simple test designed to ensure that the sex worker understands health and safety issues, like, basic sex ed., what a condom can do, and what it can't, how to check for disease, etc. There could also be regular testing for STD's and infectious diseases.

In theory the license should be revocable if any major health violations are found--like it turns out the SP is found to provide bareback full service. It'd also give the authorities a way to get someone out of circulation if they refused to quit after testing positive. I am not suggeting anyone go and hire inspectors, though.

2) "Public" advertising of services should be illegal, meaning no street walkers, no billboards by the road, no large store front signs. Advertising in newspapers, on the internet, etc., would be fine. I basically want the streets to be places people feel comfortable walking with their kids, and a big sign advertising top quality blowjobs would make many people uncomfortable and probably lead to urban rot as a result of their moving to "nicer" places.

The CRA should also add an enforcement arm to make sure that sex workers pay their fair share of taxes.

Given that, and the law we ALREADY have that you can't run a business in an area zoned for residential use, I don't see any need to limit how a business is run or how many people work there or where it is or who owns it. So long as the workers understand safe sex, and they pay their taxes, who cares how they run their business?
 
Good points, fuji.
I don't see a problem with allowing escorts to work out of their homes if they choose to do so. Plenty of businesses are set up in this way, if they're going to crack down on zoning then they better nail everyone else who has an office in their den.
 
Cities would likely have a by-law against it that would be more for show than something they would actively enforce, unless they got complaints.

Licensing and mandatory health checks for individual SPs would be pointless bureaucracy. Are there large numbers of insane escorts out there now intentionally trying to catch and spread STDs? If there ever was one, would it stop her? What makes you think they don't know enough to get themselves tested on their own? No one ever seems to suggest mandatory tests for the hobbyists. And you know a SP having to display a 'disease-free approved' certificate would only result in idiot guys demanding BB everything "since I know you're clean".
 
Yeah, neighbors call LE to complain about barking dogs. They'd blow a gasket for an SP conducting biz out of a private home. Legalization would mean that would happen on a wide scale; the amount of calls LE would get would be overwhelming.

A red-light district or brothels located in a commercial/industrial area would work and has been successful with Amsterdam, Germany, Australia, and New Zealand, and with SCs in North America.
 
Hmmm...at the risk of comparing apples and oranges here, what if we considered another incall vice? Gambling, in particular, the city of Las Vegas.

Las Vegas was started by, built by, and run by criminals. The only government regulation was the Nevada Gaming Commission which pretty much let the casinos do whatever they wanted, but did have certain guidelines to be followed. If the casinos got out of line, they had their licenses revoked. Eventually, the criminals developed enough of the city to attract corporate interests, which ultimately eliminated the criminal element and made Las Vegas safe and appealing to a wider audience.

The same could be done for brothels. A regulatory commission would establish basic guidelines such as no underage SP and reasonable precautions against STDs. Any brothel which does not comply would be shut down until it complies. Perhaps, like Las Vegas, enough popularity and enough market will be generated to attract corporate interests to legitimize it.
 
Svend said:
Good points, fuji.
I don't see a problem with allowing escorts to work out of their homes if they choose to do so. Plenty of businesses are set up in this way, if they're going to crack down on zoning then they better nail everyone else who has an office in their den.

Most businesses running out of people's homes aren't open to the public; clients rarely and probably never drop by. They are often places where people work over the phone, and serve as the home base for a salesperson or consultant who typically goes out to meet customers and clients.

Would you really want to live next door to a business that had 50+ men streaming through all day and all night, staffed by women who didn't live in your building? Were it legalized they'd have no reason to try and fly under the radar and would be horrendous neighbours. Move the same establishment to a retail space and nobody would be bothered much. Oh, some cranks would complain about strangers in the neighbourhood, but literally, nobody would lose any sleep over it.

You've listed the least obnoxious case which is a single escort working from her primary residence--a place she has a stake in too. Were it legalized, though, you'd more likely see agencies renting units to use as incall locations for their staff of 20+ escorts, who would have no connection whatever to the building, and, if legalized, no reason to try and fly under the radar such as places like roommates, friends, and oasis do now when a complaint from a neighbour could trigger a police problem.

There is a reason why massage places locate in retail spaces rather than residences. I think it's appropriate.
 
rubmeister100 said:
The Oase Sauna Club idea with people hanging around socializing, drinking, getting a massage etc is ripe for organized crime. It is not much different than the strip club atmosphere we have here. Also, it really is a pain having these vulture girls hassling you.
I don't know what experience you have had there, but I kind of liked being groped and fondled under my towel by naked women. I have never heard of anybody disliking FKKs.
But, then again I can see how some guys could be uncomfortable at first.