If Albert Einstein were alive today?

Garrett said:
I think you pretty much have an agenda when you say Tesla is much more intelligent than Einstein. They were both visionary scientists, and little doubt Tesla is not taught in the US public school system at the same level as, say, Edison. However, neither is Einstein really. He is the pop culture winner, based on image and something as seemingly simple as e=mc**2. However, for me, I still admire Einstein more. My own curiousity is what impact would they have if they were around today.

Einstein has 2 contributions, general relativity and special relativity. Tesla has AC power, AC motor and radio communications under bis belt, and that is the well known stuff, he has other things that never saw the light of day but was even more impressive. I believe Tesla has about 2000 patents to his name.

Relativity contributes greatly to the space program, satellite communications, power generation and gps. But I would argue that Tesla's work has a much greater impact on most people's lives.

I went a bit overboard with saying that Tesla was much more intelligent than Einstein. Relativity was brilliant, especially considering that at the time Einstein came up with the idea there were no obvious defficientcy with the scientific knowledge at that time to motivate such thinking. His relativity concept came purely out of his own mind. It was not until Eddington measured the shift of starlight during a total eclipse that Einstein's theory was tested.

In contrast Tesla's work was generally less creative than relativity as his stuff could be immediately applied to produce meaningful results.

You are right, it is all about pop culture, E=MC^2 sounds cool and Einstein's look is the poster child for brilliant mad scientist.
 
JohnFK said:
Einstein's work helped give the Good Guys the Bomb first (with all due respect to Tesla who I think is great, and probably Einstein did too).

One of Einstein's biggest regret was the Atomic bomb.
 
bishop said:
One of Einstein's biggest regret was the Atomic bomb.
He certainly didn't feel that way in 1942. After you've won and with20/20 hindsight, and since the scientists weren't likely to be leading troops ashore it was easy enough to say what a pandora's box we have opened. You wouldn't have found many in the military in August and September 1945 would would have felt that way.
 
Certainly you are right about hindsight. But maybe the world would have been a better place without the atomic bomb, the allies could have still won WW2. There might not have been 35 years of cold war and America might not have used the rest of the world as toilet paper.

Anyways lets say that Einstein and Tesla had an equal contribution to humanity and lets say they are both equally as smart. The difference would now be that Einstein was a media whore, and Tesla was not.

I read that at one point, JP Morgan (I think) was pissed off at Tesla and wanted to make Tesla look like a fool, so he arranged Tesla to meet with Einstein. JP knew that Tesla had a different opinion about relativity, and wanted to start an argument between the both of them and have it in the paper. I do not think they ever spoke about general relativity so in the end JP's plan did not work.

Tesla's life was full of tragedy, he almost died a few times as a child and when he was old he preferred to spend time with pigeons rather than people because pigeons never wanted anything form him. I do not think he was ever married or fathered a child. He was quite a good looking man, and was quite tall. No doubt he could have gotten tonnes of pussy based on either his looks, his wealth if he really bothered to acquire large sums of money, or his fame at the time.
 
JohnFK said:
Don't forget the military application of Einstein's equation (unfortunately).


The path towards the first atomic bomb entailed
fundamental and original scientific research activites
far beyond E=MC^2. As a scientist Einstein's role
in atomic bomb is a fundamental one but not decisive.

It would be fairer to say that Alexander Fleming was
more responsible for the development of Pencillium
into an antibiotic near the end of WWII
than Einstein was for the atomic bomb.

The fact is that with or without Fleming hanging around
after his discovery the idea of using Penicillum to
fight bacterial infection could have gone into
oblivion for decades if not forever were
it not for the superhuman efforts and scientific ingenuity
of the Oxford/Cambridge scientists under the direction of
one exceptionally brilliant mind of Howard Florey.

As for the atomic bomb the move of Enrico Fermi
from fascist Italy to the US who later joined
the Manhattan project could be the more fortunate event
than Einstein leaving Nazi Germany.

As seminal as Einstein's E=MC^2 is the single
most crucial scientific discovery to atomic bomb
could be that of the nuclear fission of which Einstein had
nothing to do with. I doubt vey much that Einstein
ever regreted about his famous equation.
Einstein might have regreted about the warning he once made in a letter about nazi Germany winning
the race to the first atomic bomb. Whether it was his letter that initiated the Manhattan project I don't know. But If anything
Einstein's role is more of a statesman rather than
a scientist.
 
hans4u said:
Would he change his theory to:

E= MPAsquared? ...



E = MC2

P x R x T =$
 
I would ask him how it is possible to be so mathematically brilliant, and to understand very obscure and complex concepts, but how he could be so inept in basic philosophy.
 
bishop said:
Einstein has 2 contributions, general relativity and special relativity. Tesla has AC power, AC motor and radio communications under bis belt, and that is the well known stuff, he has other things that never saw the light of day but was even more impressive. I believe Tesla has about 2000 patents to his name.

Relativity contributes greatly to the space program, satellite communications, power generation and gps. But I would argue that Tesla's work has a much greater impact on most people's lives.

I went a bit overboard with saying that Tesla was much more intelligent than Einstein. Relativity was brilliant, especially considering that at the time Einstein came up with the idea there were no obvious defficientcy with the scientific knowledge at that time to motivate such thinking. His relativity concept came purely out of his own mind. It was not until Eddington measured the shift of starlight during a total eclipse that Einstein's theory was tested.

In contrast Tesla's work was generally less creative than relativity as his stuff could be immediately applied to produce meaningful results.

You are right, it is all about pop culture, E=MC^2 sounds cool and Einstein's look is the poster child for brilliant mad scientist.

according to wikipedia he contributed more than that:

Albert Einstein (German: Albert_Einstein_german.ogg ˈalbɐt ˈaɪ̯nʃtaɪ̯n ; English: IPA: /ˈælbɝt (-ət) ˈaɪnstaɪn/) (14 March 1879 – 18 April 1955) was a German-born theoretical physicist. He is best known for his theory of relativity and specifically mass–energy equivalence, expressed by the equation E = mc2. Einstein received the 1921 Nobel Prize in Physics "for his services to Theoretical Physics, and especially for his discovery of the law of the photoelectric effect."[1]

Einstein's many contributions to physics include:

* Special theory of relativity, which reconciled mechanics with electromagnetism
* General theory of relativity, a new theory of gravitation which added the principle of equivalence to the principle of relativity
* Founding of relativistic cosmology with a cosmological constant
* The first post-Newtonian expansions for the perihelion advance of planet Mercury and frame-dragging
* The deflection of light by gravity and gravitational lensing
* An explanation for capillary action
* The first fluctuation dissipation theorem which explained the Brownian movement of molecules
* The photon theory and wave-particle duality from the thermodynamic properties of light
* The quantum theory of atomic motion in solids
* Zero point energy
* The semiclassical version of the Schrodinger equation
* Relations for atomic transition probabilities which predicted stimulated emission
* The quantum theory of a monatomic gas which predicted Bose-Einstein condensation
* The EPR paradox
* A program for a unified field theory by the geometrization of physics.

Einstein published over 300 scientific works and over 150 non-scientific works.[2][3] In 1999 Time magazine named him the "Person of the Century", and according to Einstein biographer Don Howard, "to the scientifically literate and the public at large, Einstein is synonymous with genius."[4]:159

Ronnie,
Naughtylady
 
naughtylady said:
Einstein received the 1921 Nobel Prize in Physics "for his services to Theoretical Physics, and especially for his discovery of the law of the photoelectric effect."

Thank you for that. Most people forget (or never knew) that his fame in the physics world was mostly for his work on the photoelectric effect. While he published his first paper on relativity at the same time, it was only much much later that people began to identify him principally with relativity.