How U.S. Lost Out on iPhone Work

Does Ontario have it's own international trade policy or does Canada do this at a national level?

National. I was just pointing out that Canada's free trade policy impacts different parts of Canada in different ways. It hurts manufacturing-oriented Ontario a hell of a lot more than oil-exporting Alberta. You asked if what I was saying would apply to Canada. It would. It might not apply so well in Alberta, whose oil economy makes it somewhat different. But the same factors that affect most of the United States definitely affect places like Ontario and Quebec.

It's not optional because the tit-for-tat trade barriers that would result from the US not allowing imports of electronics, toys, clothing......

Removing free trade would surely be reciprocated! But that doesn't make it "not optional". It's clearly an option, the only question is "good option" or "bad option". But to say it is not optional is silly.

would be far worse for Americans than the current situation AND would make everyone poorer....

"Make everyone poorer" only in an overall average sense. Trade barriers would provably result in a lowered US GDP, the country as a whole would be a little poorer.

However it's wrong to say it would make "everyone poorer". That is not true. It would make some people poorer, and some people richer. The question is, would it make more people richer than poorer? And the surprising answer is yes, it would.

That's because the benefits from trade have accrued primarily to a minority of the population. While net GDP has risen as a result of free trade, it's been concentrated in a few hands. Rolling it back would result in lower total GDP, but more equally divided. The result would be a net gain in wealth for a majority of Americans, coupled with net greater fall in wealth for the minority of professionals and managers.

I think you're wrong, the facts show that middle class household incomes have gone us substantially in the last 30 years.

Net incomes would have gone up anyway, even without free trade, and to a large extent have gone up only because people are now working longer hours (specifically, women are working longer hours).

You haven't come close to making the case that net incomes have risen generally due to free trade, but the COSTS of free trade are very, very real and obvious.
 
There is another logical alternative to the problem that the gains from trade concentrated in only a few hands, while the costs have been more widely borne. That would be, tax those who benefit from free trade, and redistribute the wealth to those who would otherwise have lost. Since there are net gains from trade, there is in theory enough money to go around to make everyone better off.

The trouble is that's too academic. In the real world you know what would happen--the rich would move their assets out of the United States.

You could work hard on closing all the loopholes that would allow them to do that. I would argue, that in the end, your tax code would be indistinguishable from a trade tariff, as it would be designed to extract a certain percentage of the proceeds from trade and redistribute it generally. It would probably be simpler and cheaper simply to tax trade directly.
 
Ah... not in the deleted thread repository after all. Just no reply from OTB...

I don't delete threads or put posters on ignore.

We disagree, that's fine, at this point you're debating yourself, that doesn't require my response.

OTB
 
There was a time when what was good for GM was good for America. Now it is what is good for Apple is good for China. With Apple's blowout quarter, you can be sure China got a few billions too.