How Safe Is Your Pension?

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Do you work in the private or public sector? How safe is your pension? If you work for the federal government, I guess they could always raise taxes and/or print the money. Not so in the private sector (just ask any Nortel retirees:mad:).
 
We have laws, but governments bypassed those systems for reasons that are not being disclosed and I think there could be some serious issues of underfunded pensions.
 
underfunded pensions means that if everyone in the plan cashed out (retired) today there isn't enough funds to fund that type of thing. A lot of underfunding is do to the low interest rates
 
There are a lot of large corporate plans that are under water right now, some of them by hundreds of millions of dollars. Some of those companies include CN Rail and Air Canada among others. Governments continue to allow companies to put off balancing out their plans hoping the economy picks up and the investment returns for these plans improves so they don't have to throw in a huge pile of cash. In the meantime a lot of these companies are trying to get the unions to agree to defined contribution plans as opposed to defined benefit plans as that would be cheaper for the company.
 
underfunded pensions means that if everyone in the plan cashed out (retired) today there isn't enough funds to fund that type of thing. A lot of underfunding is do to the low interest rates
Our private company pension plan currently allows retiring employees two options.
1) Take a lump sum in cash and run.
2) Take a monthly annuity forever (as long as the company is around to fund it).

Since our company is private sector, I would be inclined to take the lump sum and run.
 
Our private company pension plan currently allows retiring employees two options.
1) Take a lump sum in cash and run.
2) Take a monthly annuity forever (as long as the company is around to fund it).

Since our company is private sector, I would be inclined to take the lump sum and run.

That's what a lot of people retiring from my employer are doing. Our pension plan was very low for a lot of the senior people until the last 15 years (it's a great plan now for someone young and just starting out). So, some guys are looking at pensions paying 800-1000/month. Or they can take a lump sum. One guy I talked to that just retired said his lump sum was about $250,000. Of course, he has to throw that right into an RRSP to save the taxes. But the biggest reason for taking the money wasn't being concerned the company would default. It was because his wife pre-deceased him, so there is no spousal benefit when he dies if he had taken the monthly payment. This way, the money carries on in his estate.
 
One guy I talked to that just retired said his lump sum was about $250,000. Of course, he has to throw that right into an RRSP to save the taxes.
That would be a "locked in RRSP ("LIRA")"? Problem with a LIRA is it is much less flexible than a regular RRSP.
 
underfunded pensions means that if everyone in the plan cashed out (retired) today there isn't enough funds to fund that type of thing. A lot of underfunding is do to the low interest rates


That is not quite what 'underfunded' pensions mean.

Pensions are accumulated as people and companies deposit money.

Withdrawals occur as retired people start removing cash.

Actuaries do calculations depending on age, deposits, pension rates and life expectancy, etc.

A PROPERLY run pension is calculated and must be able to sustain itself for x number of years. OMERS for instance must be funded out 75 years. That means that, when all calculations are done, that the pension fund can carry itself. Teachers and Federal employees have the same set up.

No not all the money is there RIGHT NOW and must be available for payout. No , calculations on future deposits determine how much is required and/or if the fund is running a deficit. Most pensions are right now....due to INVESTMENTS and people living longer. Hence why retirement ages needed to be raised to 67 in the federal system and should be raised in private funds as well.

That would mean more years putting in and less years taking out. A balance so to speak!
 
I recently heard a retired actuary who is considered an expert in the field state that recently updated data in respect of expected lives is going to fundamentally change the approach taken under DB plans. Women are now expected to live to 92, men 89. Think of the Teachers plan where you can retire at 55...does it make sense to be able to retire after 30 years of service and expect to recieve a pension for just as long or longer than you worked? I think that this new data is going to either result in those currently in db plans contributing more, pushing out the retirement date, or reducing the payouts....perhaps a mixture.

my db plan was stopped and we are all going to a DC plan. it sucks but it is the way of the world.
 
Women are now expected to live to 92, men 89.
The financial planner at my local bank said they are using 90 as the age of longevity and age 100 if you arrive at age 60 in good health. I notice the CPP and OAS now allow you to defer the pension until age 70.

my db plan was stopped and we are all going to a DC plan. it sucks but it is the way of the world.
Our company did the same but they grandfathered older good looking guys like myself so I am still DB. The younger employees are all DC.
 
If you go to DC plans, typically the accrued time already in place is good.

Its a move used on a GO Forward basis, is it not?

For u guys that to switched over, how did the employers contribution stand up? Did they decrease it?

and is there options, or you still are mandated to be in the DC PLAN, like before in the DB plan?
 
If you go to DC plans, typically the accrued time already in place is good.

Its a move used on a GO Forward basis, is it not?

For u guys that to switched over, how did the employers contribution stand up? Did they decrease it?

and is there options, or you still are mandated to be in the DC PLAN, like before in the DB plan?

it is my understanding that, by law, they cannot touch the past obligation under a DB plan.

in terms of comparing a DB and DC plan - as in did the employer keep you in about the same position - I don't understand all the calculations but I am told that it would have to be a very rich DC plan to keep you on par with a DB plan. at the end of the day the risk is now moved to the employee.
 
Will your pension disappear, post-Detroit?

We can always look to Detroit to feel good about the safety of our pension.


http://www.marketwatch.com/story/wi...pear-post-detroit-2013-07-24?siteid=rss&rss=1

State and local government workers with traditional pension plans might want to revisit
their retirement-income plans in the wake of Detroit’s filing for bankruptcy.


As many know by now, workers and retirees for that troubled city, which has an underfunded pension liability of some $3.5 billion, face the possibility that their pensions could be reduced drastically in a worst-case scenario.

A hearing to determine whether a lawsuit by the city’s 20,000-plus retired public employees can block the bankruptcy is scheduled to be held Wednesday. (See Detroit retirees brace for pension cuts.)

But no matter what happens, experts say that now would be a good time for public-sector workers and retirees—especially those whose employers have underfunded pensions—to revisit their retirement plan, crunch out a few what-if scenarios, and adjust their current or planned lifestyle accordingly.

“Despite their having earned their benefits through years of employment, alarming headlines are shaking current and future retirees’ confidence in their retirement security,” said Richard Schroder, president of Anova Consulting Group, a Brookline, Mass., market research and consulting firm focused on the retirement-services space.

According to published reports, public pensions aren’t the only ones in trouble. The Teamsters’ Central States, Southeast & Southwest Pension Plan, which is the nation’s largest multiemployer pension fund, faces tough times, too. Documents filed at the end of 2012 by the Rosemont, Ill.-based fund show that its liabilities are almost double its assets — $34.9 billion versus $17.8 billion, according to a recent BenefitsPro report,

Detroit’s bankruptcy and the underfunded status of the Teamsters’ pension are only the latest examples of an age of increasing uncertainty for Americans planning for retirement, Schroder said.

Create a worst-case plan

“Now more than ever, it is incumbent upon Americans to take increased responsibility for their personal financial well-being,” Schroder said. “At one point or another, most of us have been given the advice to ‘not put all our eggs in one basket,’ and the same concept applies to retirement.”

Schroder said worst-case “what-if” scenarios, such as the prospect of pension benefits being reduced, should be considered as part of retirement planning. He also said most Americans would be well-served by improving their financial literacy or having discussions with a qualified financial adviser.
What’s an appropriate worst-case scenario? Consider the case of Central Falls, R.I.: After declaring bankruptcy in 2011, that city slashed one in three of its retirees’ pension checks by more than half, with the majority of the city’s former public-safety workers set to lose tens of thousands of dollars a year, according to published reports. The former acting fire chief’s pension dropped by $41,684 a year, from $75,789 to $34,105; a former firefighter’s pension dropped by $37,628, from $68,414 to $30,786; and a former policeman’s pension dropped by $36,493, from $66,351 to $29,858. (See coverage by Rhode Island television station WPRI,

Given that example, part of your worst-case scenario planning should be to envision how you’d get by if your expected pension was cut in half. That should give you a sense of whether you could live on the reduced pension, or whether you might need to bump up your savings rate, or delay retirement, or return to work, or reduce your standard of living, or any combination of those actions. (MarketWatch has a “Retirement Planner” calculator where you can test various what-if scenarios.)

“Individually, each person may not be able to affect the outcome around her respective pension reform,” said Jeffrey Tomaneng, a financial adviser at Lincoln Investment Planning. “However, he or she does have the ability to control expectations and make adjustments to lifestyle and budget.”

From the planner’s view, Tomaneng said, you still use the same fundamentals of the financial-planning process. “You still discuss worst-case, best-case and variations of in-between scenarios,” he said. “Spend less, earn more, save more, work longer, retire somewhere cheaper and so forth.”
Tomaneng noted that in Massachusetts former Polaroid employees, in the wake of that company’s bankruptcy, are already receiving payments from the federal Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp. (PBGC) at a fraction of what they were supposed to receive. “Many have delayed their retirements and cut back on their lifestyles to give them a better shot of making sure they don’t outlive their money,” he said.

Tomaneng said he’s also been addressing with younger clients the possibility of reduced benefits from Social Security. “For these union workers and retirees the discussion and planning needs to happen right away,” he said.

Is your pension funded?

Americans would also be well-served to check the degree to which their pension plan is funded.

Indeed, some cities and states are much worse off than others. For instance, in 2010, Joshua Rauh, a professor of finance at Stanford University, and Robert Novy-Marx, an associate professor of finance at the University of Rochester, identified the 10 major cities that they calculated would be the first to run out of pension-fund money. At the time, that list included Philadelphia; Chicago; Boston; Cincinnati; St. Paul; Jacksonville, Fla.; New York City; Baltimore; Detroit; and Fort Worth.

Meanwhile, the gap between the promises states have made for public employees’ retirement benefits and the money they have set aside to pay these bills was at least $1.38 trillion in fiscal year 2010, according to the Pew Center for the States’s analysis of pension and retiree health-care funding. According to the report, Connecticut, Illinois, Kentucky and Rhode Island were the worst among the states, with pensions funded under 55% in 2010. Pew also noted that states collectively had only 5% of the funds needed to pay for their retirees’ health care and other non-pension benefits—such as life insurance. And 17 states had not set aside any money to fund their retiree health-care liabilities.

Others agreed that it’s important to check the financial status of your pension plan. “Any type of plan participant, public, private, or union should always keep an eye out on the financial status of their employer,” said Ary Rosenbaum, an ERISA retirement plan attorney for his firm, The Rosenbaum Law Firm.

Rosenbaum noted that union plans and private pensions offer more safety to plan participants when it comes to providing information, because plan participants have a right to access their plan’s funding notice, which can tell them how underfunded their plans are. If their plan is covered by the PBGC and funding of the pension is less than 80%, then plan participants are required to receive a notice of the plan’s funding level. But the PBGC doesn’t cover most state and local public-sector pension plans.

“Plan participants should know that whether their plans are protected by the PBGC or not, there is always a risk that their pension benefits can be curtailed by bankruptcy court as what probably will happen to City of Detroit pensioners,” said Rosenbaum. “So they should plan accordingly.”

No need to push panic button?

Some experts don’t think that all current and retired state and local government workers need to push the panic button and redo their retirement plans.

Notwithstanding a few outliers, retirement benefits for the vast majority of the more than 8 million retired employees of state and local government are safe and secure, said Keith Brainard, the research director of the National Association of State Retirement Administrators, a nonprofit association whose members include the directors of many of the nation’s state- and territorial-level public retirement systems.

As of March 31, 2013, for instance, combined assets of these funds exceeded $3.5 trillion, more than 15 times what the funds pay out each year in benefits, he said. What’s more, Brainard said, these plans collect in employee and employer contributions each year much of the amount they pay in benefits.

There are undoubtedly some public plans in trouble, and some in serious trouble, such as those in the state of Illinois, Brainard said. Yet nearly every state has made changes to their retirement plans since 2009, some more than once. A number of states, including Colorado, Minnesota, Maine, South Dakota, Rhode Island and New Jersey, have reduced their unfunded liabilities, in part or in whole by reducing future cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs) for current retirees. In addition, many states have increased required contributions for employees, including current workers in many cases.

In the cases of Detroit and Central Falls, Brainard said a distinguishing feature is the decline in revenue those cities experienced. Reading between the lines, if you currently work for or are retired from a municipality where revenues are declining and there haven’t been changes made to the pension plan, consider working on your plan-B retirement strategy.

Because retiree health-care benefits generally have far fewer legal protections than pension benefits do, Brainard said, we are likely to see more reductions in those benefits than among pensions.

Bottom line: When it comes to your pension, leave nothing to chance. Create a just-in-case plan. Prepare for the worst and hope for the best.

Robert Powell is editor of Retirement Weekly, published by MarketWatch.
 
We need laws to protect these pensions

The first law should be to ban adding anyone to any public service benefit based pensions. Everyone should be on contribution based plans that build up over length of service and by definition can't be underfunded.
 
The first law should be to ban adding anyone to any public service benefit based pensions. Everyone should be on contribution based plans that build up over length of service and by definition can't be underfunded.
The problem with our public sector DB plans is that it is basically a "pyramid scheme". The problem with Teachers is that soon the ratio of active duty to retired teacher ratio will be 1 to 1. This is an unsustainable model unless their investments generate huge returns.