I believe it is a very complex issue in the 21 st century. Each sub culture seems to have it's own definition of what an Alpha male is. Does it mean the best RPGer? Does it mean the man with the faster car? Does it mean the guy who is the big shot pimp? It all depends on the the little sub culture where you exist. For me, a man who can stare down a mugger and then order a Chambertin with dinner is close to my personal perfect Alpha
I guess most men want to be with the Alpha male. Sadly the Alpha gets to pick who he is with, so most of us have to settle for as much Alpha as we can reasonably expect to entice.
At another level completely it is not as simple as "acting like the Alpha"; you need to be the Alpha. I suppose a 'pretend Alpha' is ok for a quick fling, but it is a LOT of work to pretend you think some faker is a real Alpha. Ok for a bit if we cannot attract a real Alpha, or even medium long term if we accept that we will never have a real Alpha.
Nothing is more repulsive than a loser pretending he is, or competing to be, Alpha of the losers.