House flooring recommendations/advice

I would stick with hardwood flooring, its look is classic. You can't say that about tile. Tiles styles change quite frequently and will date your reno. Take a look at renos done 10 years ago with hardwood and tile floors. The tile floor looks more dated. If you get tired of your hardwood floor, you can get it restained or refinished. With tile, you are stuck with your original choice. Your floor is suppose to last 25 years, can you think of tile that has endured 25 years without being dated?
 
Tile is superior to vinyl in all respects.

It really is that simple.

Vinyl is something you put in a kitchen in 1972. It adds no value whatsoever to a house. (Truth be told it might add negative value because it would need to come out.)

If tile is too much work, consider hardwood.

True, but industrial vinyl lasts fairly well. Has to be re-polished constantly but is also way easier to replace then tile, when you want to update.
 
James T Kirk, you may want to specify for those who may not know, or to clarify this;
ONLY 3/4" tongue and groove plywood is acceptable for that

Is OSB ok for this application?

Without tearing out your whole sub-floor, as it may not be fully possible, would using 1/4 or 3/8 plywood over your sub-floor, glued and screwed, be sufficient in this case?
 
James T Kirk, you may want to specify for those who may not know, or to clarify this;

Is OSB ok for this application?

Without tearing out your whole sub-floor, as it may not be fully possible, would using 1/4 or 3/8 plywood over your sub-floor, glued and screwed, be sufficient in this case?

No, it probably won't be sufficient. I would have a minimum 1/2" original sub floor plus a layer of 3/4" tongue and groove. OSB will probably do for one of those layers.

Regarding vinyl, the products have come a long way since the 70's and look and wear a lot better.
 
The are a couple of instances where vinyl and in particular marmoleum is a better choice. It's used in hospitals because it's a natural product and its "naturally occurring anti-microbial properties help to inhibit the growth of many microorganisms, including allergen producing dust mites and the MRSA strains of bacteria".

Secondly, it comes in one piece so there is not tripping hazard. Large tiles are cupped and not perfectly flat, when they are put side by side you get uneven edges or lippage. You're not suppose to have a stagger (running bond) of more than 1/3 the length of the tile in order to minimize the unevenness. Wider grout lines help lessen the differences but designers love tight grout lines.
I've had elderly clients who literally shuffle their feet when walking and the unevenness of the tiles floor poses a tripping hazard.

In these instances where allergies or mobility problems are a concern, I would recommend maroleum over tile.
 
I would stick with hardwood flooring, its look is classic. You can't say that about tile. Tiles styles change quite frequently and will date your reno. Take a look at renos done 10 years ago with hardwood and tile floors. The tile floor looks more dated. If you get tired of your hardwood floor, you can get it restained or refinished. With tile, you are stuck with your original choice. Your floor is suppose to last 25 years, can you think of tile that has endured 25 years without being dated?

Tiles can look dated you are correct. That's because there are so many things you can do with tile.

But if you stick to the natural stones like marble, limestone, etc. you will also get a timeless look.

The big benefit to tile in kitchens and bathrooms is moisture resistance. Hardwood will absorb moisture, it will mold and mildew, rot and stink. Tile resists all of that. In addition, a large spill of water (drop a pot) in a kitchen with a tile floor will not leak through the ceiling below. Not so with hardwood.

The truth of the matter is that there is no perfect flooring. They all have their advantages and disadvantages. My personal choice is tile in the kitchen and bathrooms and hardwood everywhere else.

Never carpet, never vinyl, and never laminate.
 
James T Kirk, you may want to specify for those who may not know, or to clarify this;

Is OSB ok for this application?

Without tearing out your whole sub-floor, as it may not be fully possible, would using 1/4 or 3/8 plywood over your sub-floor, glued and screwed, be sufficient in this case?

My personal choice is always a 3/4" tongue and grove plywood floor for all floors - floors that support hardwood, and floors that support tile.

OSB is good for nothing frankly. (Well, maybe sheathing a shed.)

Glue and screw your plywood subfloor. Plywood always is installed tongue leading, perpendicular to the floor joists. All joints (on the short edges) to be centred on floor studs. 2.5" No. 8 wood screws through the plywood into the joists. (Always mark your joists.) Edges have to be screwed a LOT more frequently than intermediate joists. Like every 4 inches. This is because the edge will want to curl (or more accurately rotate) up at the edges and will crack your tiles. The slightest movement in your subfloor will crack your tiles. (The decoupling membrane like Schluter helps in this regard, but natural stones are especially susceptible to cracking over top joints. Ask me how I know.)

Also, sheets of subfloor plywood must be installed with the joints staggered (in a brick pattern). Avoid a continuous joint over one particular joist.

I've seen some guys install 2 sheets of plywood under tile floors. This would be super strong and a good idea as long as you glue the two sheets of plywood together in order to laminate them together. If you just screw them down, you really are not getting the benefit of 2 layers because they can slide over each other. Must be glued. The down side is heaven help you if you ever need to lift that subfloor.
 
First of all , you may also want to consider Centura tile , been around as long as Olympia.

Second if height is an issue and you are going with porcelain tile , you may NOT have to remove the vinyl as long as it well bonded - but you must use a primer for tile.

Fuck metal lathe ! very old school , go with Schluter Ditra uncoupling membrane if you remove the vinyl.

OSB not covered by warranty for most thinsets

Must be exterior grade plywood
 
Thanks for all the advice, I really appreciate it.

After looking at my current floor and situation, I may not chose ceramic. I guess you can say its a lot of work. First, that would be a lot of height added. The person that did built this house did shitty work. The heat vents are all crooked. I'd have to trim or get new doors as they won't fit with new floors.

I know ceramic is more luxurious. But does anybody have experience with luxurious vinyl plank or tiles. I live in a 2000 sq foot home. Would it be wise to put vinyl in?
If you are considering vinyl, do take jtkirk's advice to heart. I've heard the same from more than one realtor. But if all you want is comfort and practicality, who cares what they say.

Before you commit to vinyl though, have a look at Marmoleum™ It's the modern version of the classic Linoleum — the stuff that they supposedly installed in battleships — interesting colours and patterns, wears great, a better environmental choice than vinyl, and available as sheet-goods from a roll, as tiles, or as laminated on engineered flooring planks ('click-floor'). You will want pros to lay the sheet goods, but if you're reasonably careful and handy with tools you can likely lay the click-floor, which goes together so tight the seams are all but invisible. I did a couple of kitchens a decade or so back where I still visit frequently; they are looking good to this day. My own kitchen is still the 70 year old original linoleum, and has all the scars you'd expect with age, but no wear patterns, and still looks shiny and sweet after a mopping.

Notes about click floor: Not all of the under-material's suitable for 'wet' spaces. Be sure that's what you're buying. It is vital that the floor it will be laid over be flat. Just about dead-flat, with absolutely minimal bumps, lumps, divots or valleys. The manufacturers publish spec-sheets that state the details in terms like 'no greater variation than 1/8" in 36". Believe them; do better than they say. If you cheat, the planks will flex as you walk and the engineered joints will open and fail. Besides plywood subfloor, there are chemical floor-levellers and fillers you mix and carefully trowel flat. Use a plank on edge to check and fix any place you see daylight.

As for kitchen cabinets baseboards, doorframe casings and such where the new flooring's edges will butt and be seen: That's what quarter-round shoe-moulding was invented for. And recently someone invented oscillating power-saws that solve the same problem by enabling the installer to undercut many of those things to open a gap just tall enough to neatly slide the last tile or plank under that cabinet or casing. Noisy but nice. And if you're lucky, yours will have the levellers mentioned above.