Homstars.com

I never said "always". But I bet you they solicited your review and directed you to the website.

If I provide a service for a customer and I know they're satisfied, then I'm going to encourage them to write a review about it.

Similarly I'm NOT going to encourage an UNHAPPY customer to write a review.

This is not evil genius, it's smart business.
 
If I provide a service for a customer and I know they're satisfied, then I'm going to encourage them to write a review about it.

Similarly I'm NOT going to encourage an UNHAPPY customer to write a review.

This is not evil genius, it's smart business.


So is creating a "review" website for the lucrative home contracting business that makes its money from the advertisers being reviewed.

All I am saying is that I have first hand knowledge of being solicited to provide outright fake reviews from two unrelated friends who run lucrative highly rated Homestars rated companies. Make no mistake, they do good work. But there is a huge incentive in certain fields to keep your review count high and your company at the top of the listings, such that many resort to soliciting outright fake reviews. Such that there is a secondary SEO-esque industry to manage and promote reviews within homestars!

If I were to look for a contractor, I'd certainly look to homestars for information but as Jillian noted, and I'm stating, take the information with a grain of salt.

wis-weather.jpg
 
So is creating a "review" website for the lucrative home contracting business that makes its money from the advertisers being reviewed.

All I am saying is that I have first hand knowledge of being solicited to provide outright fake reviews from two unrelated friends who run lucrative highly rated Homestars rated companies. Make no mistake, they do good work. But there is a huge incentive in certain fields to keep your review count high and your company at the top of the listings, such that many resort to soliciting outright fake reviews. Such that there is a secondary SEO-esque industry to manage and promote reviews within homestars!

If I were to look for a contractor, I'd certainly look to homestars for information but as Jillian noted, and I'm stating, take the information with a grain of salt.

I don't disagree. Again, I was merely pointing out that soliciting a review after completing a job (and completing it well) isn't an underhanded practice in my books.

Homestars is one of many tools I use when deciding who to use for my various renovation projects. I would never rely on it exclusively.
 
I found an eavestroughing co there, did a little more research and decided to use them - all a very positive experience, so I put a positive review on the HomeStars board.
 
I've contributed reviews to Homestars, and I've also chosen businesses to patronize due to their Homestar reviews by others. If you're a careful and critical reader you can learn a great deal. And then you can patronize some little guy you would never have heard of otherwise.

My feelings about Homestars are only positive.