Home Schooling

I understand that sometimes it is necessary to do this such as when you travel as you mentioned or because of our personal situations.

I believe that even though kids have programs and opportunities to join clubs leagues or hang with other kids they do not have the opportunity to be part of the system, get in trouble, figure out how the "system" works, how to exist within the system, and raise above it from within.

Schools are ever changing so dynamic, and kids learn how to adapt to this ever changing flux of generational progression or digression.

No matter how successful or smart as parents we think we are, there is something that we will never be able to give our kids, which they get from this system of change.

I grew up in a communist system, attended the pioneers, was fed propaganda a lot, saw a country erupt in war, then "moved" more like my parents ran to Canada for a new life. What this has thought me is in simple words that control is bad for a healthy society. Who wants a manufactured society or life or consent. This reminds me of the allegory of the cave. What is the absolute truth, do we know?

By doing this I believe we tend to define their (children's) world and take away their ability to develop their personality and reach their full potential. I also believe that this has potential for mommy and daddy issues when grown up, which I kind of see in my wife who was very controlled by her parents past high school.

I know I am out numbered in my opinion here, and maybe am wrong here, only time will tell. I am not saying that my way is the way and maybe I will realize one day that I am wrong. As you guys have stated you have personal experiences or know ppl that this way worked out.

Just offering another POV on this. In the end we as parents only want the best for our kids and want to give them them tools to be ready for the real world.

I traveled for 18 months and home schooled my son during that time. We had text books and supplies provided for us, and to be honest it was one of the most rewarding times, we really got to spend some time together and bond which is priceless. His social skills didn't suffer because we met with other home schooled children, he attended structured sports activities and we are just social people so we weren't sheltered. When he returned to a classroom in grade 7 he was actually academically more advanced than many of his peers, his reading was at a grade 10 level.
 
I think there are two weaknesses of home schooling.

First it depends on the parents to have the time and the mentality to do it right. I'm sure there are parents that can do a good job and others who won't. The school systems has the same problem but the plus is that a kid will have 20+ teachers during the schooling so if a few are sub par, they aren't stuck with them the whole time. I also wonder at people's motivation for doing it and the impact those personality traits have on their kids. Is the thought because they know they can do a good job and enjoy the challenge? Is it because they distrust the system? Is it because they don't want their children exposed to 'those' people? Since the parents are the main contact their kids have, whatever positives and negatives traits the parents have will be magnified with their children. If parents look in the mirror and don't like what they see, they should strongly consider not home schooling.

The second issue is the kids being sheltered. Since the parents are in direct control of all of their kids socialization, children may not get exposed to as wide a variety of people and learn the skills to deal with them. Yes, as with my first concern, I'm sure some parents make a conscientious effort to make up for it but it goes against human nature to allow your kids experience challenging situations.

Parents can be over-protective regardless if they home-school or not. Home-schooling does not mean locking your kids in the basement with no sunlight or human interaction, though some might take it to that extreme. The challenge with home-schooling is sticking to a set schedule because there are plenty of distractions at home (siblings, laundry, washing dishes, cooking, pets, toys, video games, etc.) Even more challenging if the parents are working from home.

I do agree that parents have to be careful not to impart negative attitudes in their kids when home-schooling, but that can happen in anywhere. It would be up to the parents to decide how to get their kids out of the house in a home-school situation. I don't think they will wind up warped unless the parents are truly over-protective and over-bearing. At the end of the day, kids can become "warped" in either type of schooling environment. Think about the suspects in the Sandy Hook and Columbine shootings. One was home-schooled and the other two attended regular school.

I don't think there is a "right" or "wrong" or "standard" way of addressing education. It just depends on the parents, and their kids. Remember that there was once a time when we didn't have a school system and kids essentially were home-schooled on the farm, village, etc. The other thing to think about is it is the kids choice on what they want in life and their academic success does not determine their success in life.