Hmm... Interesting.

jcpro

Well-known member
Jan 31, 2014
24,509
6,740
113
Ya - I ain’t buying an online study. We have no way to know their security protocols to ensure people were not repeatedly filling out the form, we have no idea of the questionnaire and if people lied about education level.

There is just no way fit a study like that to be believed. Same with online polls here.
 
Seems more than a little misleading.


As a for instance, the first two (of six) bars are meant to represent around 49% of the US population according to census statistics, while the last bar, the one that is the focus of the headline and first half of the article, represents according to the article about 0.2% of the total respondents.

The presentation of the data in this form might mislead readers to believe that almost 1/3 of US citizens with at-least a bachelor’s degree are among the most vaccine hesitant, when really, based on census statistics, 94% of these people are among the least vaccine hesitant.

I agree with Jenesis.

I’d call into question the validity of the data in general. Around 3% of Americans have a PhD, yet only 0.2% (10,000 of 5,000,000) respondents were people with a PhD? How was the respondent pool selected?

Researchers concluded that the most educated people in our society - the people certified to become doctors and treat the virus - are not only the most hesitant about getting vaccinated but are also the least likely to change their minds about it.

This is at-best misleading, and more accurately, inaccurate.

Almost all physicians In the US only have an MD, which is categorized as “Professional” on the chart they presented. It’s rare that you meet a practicing doctor in Canada or the US that is a ‘Doctor Doctor,’ that is, one that earned both an MD and PhD.

But if we’re talking generalities, ‘the actual people certified to become doctors and treat the virus’ are about half as “vaccine hesitant” as the article would lead its audience to believe, as they better fit into the neighbouring category on the chart.

Regardless, this AMA survey puts physicians at over 96% vaccinated as of the start of June.

If you don’t finish reading that article understanding that generally, level of education and vaccine hesitancy are inversely related in the US as it is in Canada, then you got duped.
 
Last edited:
Seems more than a little misleading.



As a for instance, the first two (of six) bars are meant to represent around 49% of the US population, while the last bar, the one that is the focus of the headline and first half of the article, represents about 3%.

The presentation of the data in this form might mislead readers to believe that almost 1/3 of US citizens with at-least a bachelor’s degree are among the most vaccine hesitant, when really 94% of these people are among the least vaccine hesitant.



This is at-best misleading, and more accurately, inaccurate.

Almost all physicians In the US only have an MD, which is categorized as “Professional” on the chart they presented. It’s rare that you meet a practicing doctor in Canada or the US that is a ‘Doctor Doctor,’ that is, one that earned both an MD and PhD.

But if we’re talking generalities, ‘the actual people certified to become doctors and treat the virus’ are about half as “vaccine hesitant” as the article would lead its audience to believe, as they better fit into the neighbouring category on the chart.

Regardless, this AMA survey puts physicians at over 96% vaccinated as of the start of June.

Given the sample-size, the PhD category is also most likely to be inaccurate, as it draws on the smallest data pool for potential respondents.

If you don’t finish reading that article understanding that generally, level of education and vaccine hesitancy are inversely related in the US as it is in Canada, then you got duped.
I didn't get duped. I.posted it because I found it intriguing. No more no less.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jenesis
Seems more than a little misleading.



As a for instance, the first two (of six) bars are meant to represent around 49% of the US population, while the last bar, the one that is the focus of the headline and first half of the article, represents about 3%.

The presentation of the data in this form might mislead readers to believe that almost 1/3 of US citizens with at-least a bachelor’s degree are among the most vaccine hesitant, when really 94% of these people are among the least vaccine hesitant.



This is at-best misleading, and more accurately, inaccurate.

Almost all physicians In the US only have an MD, which is categorized as “Professional” on the chart they presented. It’s rare that you meet a practicing doctor in Canada or the US that is a ‘Doctor Doctor,’ that is, one that earned both an MD and PhD.

But if we’re talking generalities, ‘the actual people certified to become doctors and treat the virus’ are about half as “vaccine hesitant” as the article would lead its audience to believe, as they better fit into the neighbouring category on the chart.

Regardless, this AMA survey puts physicians at over 96% vaccinated as of the start of June.

Given the sample-size, the PhD category is also most likely to be inaccurate, as it draws on the smallest data pool for potential respondents.

If you don’t finish reading that article understanding that generally, level of education and vaccine hesitancy are inversely related in the US as it is in Canada, then you got duped.
"Hmm... Interesting"

Sort of like the 'least educated and intelligent' or in other words 'the dumber and dumbest' of the species homo sapiens are the most prone to sniff, taste and eat the shit contained in the link and then go to bed sated and satisfied.
 

Conclusion: “A bias-confirming blog post headlined, “Study Finds The Most Highly-Educated Americans Are Also The Most Vaccine-Hesitant” was predictably popular among disinformation purveyors and those who believe them; it predictably mischaracterized research pending peer review on vaccine hesitancy. The research did not determine that PhDs are “the most vaccine hesitant,” it appeared to indicate that among definitively vaccine hesitant individuals, PhDs were least likely to change their views. The headline and its claims are not true.”
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: northofsixty
What field is the PhD in for this study, is it non specific? . I have know a PhD in music and another in history that are complete ignoramuses or ignorami in math and science, one of them cannot even do grade nine math. Another PhD ( Symbolic Logic) says that many aspects of the vaccine program and government decisions defy logic but he still got double vaccinated because he said that more or less it would be prudent based on the strong circumstantial scientific evidence of the efficacy of the vaccine program. Many people who got the vaccine were reluctant and skeptical but still made a rational decision.

Monkey see, monkey do I guess if you want to follow antivaxxer PhDs.
 
What field is the PhD in for this study, is it non specific? . I have know a PhD in music and another in history that are complete ignoramuses or ignorami in math and science, one of them cannot even do grade nine math. Another PhD ( Symbolic Logic) says that many aspects of the vaccine program and government decisions defy logic but he still got double vaccinated because he said that more or less it would be prudent based on the strong circumstantial scientific evidence of the efficacy of the vaccine program. Many people who got the vaccine were reluctant and skeptical but still made a rational decision.

Monkey see, monkey do I guess if you want to follow antivaxxer PhDs.
Also depends on what PHD refers to.
http://acronymsandslang.com/meaning-of/chat-and-sub-cultures/PHD.html
First on the list "Permanent Head Damage."
LOL.
Americans with Permanent Head Damage are the most reluctant to get vaccinated against COVID, study finds

Note: I changed the title for fun.