HIV infected SP's

syn

"tlc"
Aug 31, 2001
917
0
0
downtown toronto
Ever wonder about how many SP's have HIV? Items found on the HIV/Aids web pages:

Studies suggest that Canadian female prostitutes are no more likely to be infected with HIV or other sexually transmitted diseases than other women, unless they are also intravenous drug users.

Studies also show that in their sexual relations, sex-trade workers use condoms more consistently than other populations similar in age, race, and sex.

With respect to female SP's, the fact that the transmission of HIV from female to male is so difficult would suggest that the sex trade is unlikely to be a source of the spread of HIV/AIDS. Early studies of men who use female prostitutes confirm this; they did not reveal a single case in which a client was infected by a prostitute.

It is far more likely, particularly in the current legal context, which excludes sex-trade workers from the protection of the law, that prostitutes are at risk from their clients.

Laws do not protect SP's from acquiring HIV but focus on transmission. Example: MPA's are not permitted to have condoms in their room.

Public health initiatives and media accounts emphasize the role of prostitutes as infectors rather than infectees to such an extent that this view is widely accepted as 'common sense.'

The 'public' appears not to be concerned about whether prostitutes themselves die, but whether they transmit the virus to their male customers, who then pass it on to 'innocent' women and children.

Blaming prostitutes for the transmission of AIDS among the heterosexual population, it is forgotten that they are working women and men who attempt to maintain as much control over their working conditions, including hygiene, as possible.
 
SPs need education, too!!!!!!!!!

I used to know two ladies who was actually infected with HIV and they were both working at highly reputable agencies.. Just because nobody wanted to teach those ladies. Good thing is they are both retired now but they used to offer special service w/o protections for extra-cash!

Ladies... if you are interested in getting into adult industory... please do yourself a favor and do some homework... to protect yourself and others!!!! There's great organization such as Maggies@Gerrard St.!

Be very careful and play safe guys!

xoxo Kyoko

ps. please do not ask me for those ladies info... I cannot break the promises to those ladies!
 
Kyo
Do you happen to know if the two HIV infected ladies did anal sex especially without condoms?

Vaginal sex is not a very effective way to pass HIV to the female and almost impossible to transmit to the male. But anal sex of course is very easy.

I also assume the two ladies didn't also inject drugs.

Sexworkers seem to be almost but not quite as low risk as swingers, at least if not on the street. Their clients are very unlikely to have much HIV risk unless they are bi or sharing drug needles.

There has never been a case known of HIV linked to swinging and a Dr on the Presidents HIV committee doesn't think there ever will be since swingers have such low risk.

But swingers and sexworkers should always use condoms since other STD's are a real risk. And every sexworker/swinger should get the Hepatitis 3 shot vaccine. Hep is VERY easy to transmit and you usually don't know you have it till it has already caused serious damage.
 
Good info about the idea for Hepatitis shots, Dave. But really,
it is criminal to knowingly transmit HIV thru unprotected sex, not to mention totally irresponsible! It's hard to believe these girls didn't care about their own lives....I just don't get it. Just makes me shake my head & leaves me speechless.
 
I think what dave meant was that...

.... hepatitis, 3 shot vaccine...

hepatitis requires 3 shots months apart from one another in order to be effective...
 
sparkie said:
But really, it is criminal to knowingly transmit HIV thru unprotected sex, not to mention totally irresponsible! It's hard to believe these girls didn't care about their own lives....I just don't get it. Just makes me shake my head & leaves me speechless.

A response from the Aidslaw webpage:

Cases of HIV-positive persons who deliberately infect others, or intentionally or recklessly put others at risk of contracting HIV, are extremely rare;

The vast majority of persons living with HIV or AIDS pose no risk of HIV transmission; and, importantly,

In general, both partners engaging in sexual or drug injecting activity have a responsibility to adopt precautions to prevent transmission of HIV and other STDs - the responsibility does not lie only with the person who knows him/herself to be living with HIV or another STD.
 
My experience

I worked at an agency where completely unfounded rumours destroyed the reputations of two women who allegedly had HIV. One woman may have had HIV ... I dunno - but the other SP had her reputation destroyed by malicious, jealous and petty SP's who wanted to eliminate the competition. They were losing calls to her, so they started a rumour about her HIV status.

Syn
 
One of the lady knew she had HIV... she was very popular lady and offered BBFS for $250 extra.. at that point she doesn't care if she catches anything because she aleady had HIV..

The other lady found out she had HIV after 6month or so.. I am not sure about anal for eitther one of the ladies...

Either way... please play safe...

xoxo Kyoko

The reason why I quit the specific agency was because everyone knew that first lady was infected and I didn't want to risk myself!
 
Sorry for the confusion.

Hep B is most likely to transmit via sex while A and C from blood or contact with stools (HepC) (the shitty kind not ones you sit on).

And yes the vaccine for Hep B is a 3 shot series spread over a number of months (around six as I recall).

Yes, I have my shots.
 
Vaginal sex is not a very effective way to pass HIV to the female and almost impossible to transmit to the male. But anal sex of course is very easy.
Sexworkers seem to be almost but not quite as low risk as swingers, at least if not on the street. Their clients are very unlikely to have much HIV risk unless they are bi or sharing drug needles.
There has never been a case known of HIV linked to swinging and a Dr on the Presidents HIV committee doesn't think there ever will be since swingers have such low risk.
But swingers and sexworkers should always use condoms since other STD's are a real risk. [/B]

Unless you can support your statements and perhaps quantify what is a "real risk" and what isn't (and apparently you don't consider non-anal heterosexual transmission as a "real risk") with some real facts (i.e.references) then i suggest that you mix in a little of "in my opinion", because that is all this amounts to, your opinion.

Opinions about HIV on this Board should be represented as such and not stated as fact unless the sources are provided. You comment as if you are an authority on HIV and its transmission. If you are that's great, if you are not, then try and be a bit more humble in your commentary, which in this case is quite misleading.

For those who are interested in some recent data, from Health Canada
"HIV and AIDS Among Women in Canada"
http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/pphb-dgspsp/publicat/epiu-aepi/hiv-vih/women_e.html

Swingers or not....use condoms
 
I have researched and monitored the HIV situation for many years. In the U.S. the CDC data is very clear, there is very low spread of HIV from female to male via sex without other risk factors. The U.S. data is more detailed than the Canadian data and of course is based on a far larger sample base. I don't see why Canada risks should be any different than in the U.S.

See some of my extensive articles referenced and analysis on CDC data at: http://www.libchrist.com/std/contents.html

I have some updated CDC data not yet on the site, but the ratios and conclusions are the same. For example:

Few With Heterosexual Sex As The Only Risk Factor
The total cumulative AIDS cases adult and adolescents (excluding pediatric) was 724,656. Table 5 shows of the 724,656 only 74,4770 (10%), cumulative in 19 years was from "claimed" heterosexual contact and it was mostly women (47,946 women vs. 26,530 males). This even includes those who also had secondary risk factors such as having heterosexual sex with bi men, injecting drug users, etc.

Many studies have shown bi or gay males often hide or lie about their risk factors due to our cultures discrimination against bi and gay men, not to mention they may also not admit being injecting drug users. Bi/gay sex is even a crime in many states and of course injecting drugs is illegal in all states. So not admitting to illegal acts is also not surprising. Therefore the "real" heterosexual male reported number of 26,530 cumulative in 19 years, is probably significantly lower than the admitted transmission method the CDC shows in their data. Also some women may not admit to injecting drug use. But even the admitted transmission method shows the low heterosexual risk, especially for males. Since the rate is so low for heterosexual males, female partners of such males of course have very low risk since a partner has to be infected or the risk of transmission is zero - even for anal sex!

The low risk to swingers (and most of same arguements would apply to sexworkers) is based on the views of Dr. Scherzer, a professor of biology at Essex County College, teaching anatomy, physiology, and pathophysiology as well as being a Visiting Professor at Rutgers University where he teaches Human Sexuality and Human Health and Disease. He was named Outstanding Teacher of the year in 1995 at Rutgers. He has coedited various sexology books, has made many television appearances and has lectured on AIDS at numerous universities, AIDS task forces and national conferences for the last 15 years.

His views are at: http://www.libchrist.com/std/97Lifesty.html. While I wrote this in 1997 there has been no change in the situation.
 
Another study of interest:

Researchers ID Risk Factors for Heterosexual HIV Transmission
Source: http://www.ucsf.edu/daybreak/1997/08/826_aids.htm

In the nation's largest and longest study of heterosexual HIV transmission, UCSF researchers found transmission rates remain extremely low. Those rates, they said, could be even lower by eliminating certain risk factors identified by the study.

The researchers estimate the odds of a an HIV-positive male infecting a female partner in an unprotected sexual encounter is about 9 in 10,000. The chances are even lower for female-to-male infections. Females are about eight times more likely than males to become infected by their HIV-positive partners, says study principal investigator Nancy Padian, PhD, UCSF assistant professor of obstetrics, gynecology and reproductive sciences.

The study also found that the practice of anal sex, lack of condom use, injection drug use and the presence of a sexually transmitted disease (STD) are the best predictors of infection.

"We now know many of the risk factors that affect the likelihood of transmission between infected individuals and their heterosexual partners," she says. "Elimination or modification of these factors would result in reduced transmission of HIV."

Final results of the long-term UCSF study of Northern California heterosexual couples with one HIV-infected partner are published in the August issue of the American Journal of Epidemiology.

From 1985 to 1995, Padian and her research colleagues enrolled 82 HIV-infected women and their male partners and 360 HIV-infected men and their female partners into a study to examine rates of and risk factors for heterosexual transmission of HIV. Study participants were interviewed and given physicals at the start of the study and every six months. The couples were also counseled during each visit about safe sexual practices, and study staff were available at any time by phone.

While no new HIV transmissions occurred during the course of the study, 68 women and two men were infected by their HIV-positive partners prior to the start of the study.

The UCSF study showed that a history of STDs and injection drug use greatly increased HIV transmission risk from the HIV-positive male to his female partner. Of the 77 HIV-positive male injection drug users, 22 percent transmitted the virus to their partners. Of the 163 women who had an STD, 25 percent became infected.

Only two men had become infected by their HIV-positive female partners. In the first infection, both partners reported several instances of post-coital bleeding from the genital area. In the second case, the woman appears to have infected her partner with both HIV and chlamydia within a short period.

"Because there were only two instances of female-to-male transmission, we could not examine risk factors for these events statistically," Padian says. "However, the fact that chlamydia was transmitted simultaneously with HIV is striking."

Researchers observed dramatic behavior changes during the course of the study. At the start of the study, no couple abstained from sex, only 32.2 percent ever used a condom, and 37.9 percent had anal sex. At the final follow-up visit 10 years later, 14.5 percent abstained from sex, 74 percent used condoms, and only 8.1 percent had anal sex.

The fact that no transmission occurred among the 25 percent of couples who did not consistently use condoms shows that there is very low infectivity among heterosexual couples with one HIV-positive partner, according to the UCSF study. Infectivity increases greatly with injection drug use and the presence of an STD, as well as other factors such as risky sexual practices and lack of condom use.

Other similarly conducted studies have reported higher rates of heterosexual transmission, particularly from females to males, Padian says, adding that geographic differences in sexual practices and co-factors for infection (such as intrauterine contraceptive devices) and misclassification of transmission due to other sources (such as needle sharing) may explain the UCSF study's lower transmission rates.
 
In summary my views are not an opinion but based on years of research and monitoring HIV data.

But again... I always encourage all sexworkers and customers to ALWAYS use condoms. There are other STD's that are very easy to catch vs low risk of HIV. And everyone should have Hep B series which consists of three shots spead over a number of months.
 
stinkypete said:
Unless you can support your statements and perhaps quantify what is a "real risk" and what isn't (and apparently you don't consider non-anal heterosexual transmission as a "real risk") with some real facts (i.e.references) then i suggest that you mix in a little of "in my opinion", because that is all this amounts to, your opinion.

Opinions about HIV on this Board should be represented as such and not stated as fact unless the sources are provided. You comment as if you are an authority on HIV and its transmission. If you are that's great, if you are not, then try and be a bit more humble in your commentary, which in this case is quite misleading.

For those who are interested in some recent data, from Health Canada
"HIV and AIDS Among Women in Canada"
http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/pphb-dgspsp/publicat/epiu-aepi/hiv-vih/women_e.html

Swingers or not....use condoms

Excellent point stinkypete!!!!!!

There are a lot of women who have contracted HIV through vaginal sex.
 
the need for clarity

I appreciate Dave's detailed response to my prior post. I am glad that the bottom line for both of us is that the use of condoms is a must in non-monogomous relationships, such as those relevant to the TERB populous.

Dave, you are obviously very interested in HIV and fell the need to educate others about what you have read, and you should be commended for that. But when you mention that you have researched, it could be misconstrued that you are in fact a scientific researcher, which is not the case.
I also note that while Dr Scherzer may be quite reknowned, he has not published any scientific HIV research either. I don't disagree with most of what you have paraphrased on his behalf, but he is not a primary source.

I have had a chance to look at your site, it is very interesting indeed.
But recognizing that all data is open to interpretation, I must admit that comments such as:

"In practice condoms are seldom used by swingers, yet there are hardly an,y known cases of STD's, much less HIV.
If AIDS could be effectively transmitted man-woman-man though intercourse, the entire swinging community would be riddled with it and it would have paralleled the spread in the gay community. . That, of course, hasn't occurred and there is increasing evidence that it's very difficult for a woman to get it from a man and virtually impossible for a healthy heterosexual male to get it sexually from a woman, absent open sores from STDs."
http://www.libchrist.com/std/inswing.html

are concerning, since they once again have the effect of trivializing heterosexual HIV transmission. In fact it is justifying non-condom use amongst swingers, a group whose risk you have equated with SP's.

While transmission rates may be low,in the absence of other risk factors, it remains that there IS A RISK and the disease is deadly.
 
Stinkypete,

Since there are no known HIV cases ever directly related to swinging but taking into account that there are only a few million swingers in the U.S., I would broadly estimate that the RISK is about the same as stepping out of your home and being hit by a airliner crashing into you. Yes, there is a RISK. But its so low as to not effect activity. The risk of driving in Toronto traffic, being hit my a lightning bolt on a clear day etc are far higher then the risk to a swinger getting HIV. But just because its sexual people tend to be afraid of risks that low and take much higher risks every day. These risk are also deadly just like HIV.

I also do not justify non-condom use in fact always encourge it since other STD's are a more real issue , although not deadly have a far higher risk of getting . I headed and hosted many parties for the Phoenix couples group with 350 participants. Anything sexual always used condoms. Swingers also seem to have a low STD incidence, although I don't know of extensive studies. But swingers and sexworkers are for the most part very std aware and act often more responsibly than a pick up at a bar.

Back to HIV in swinging. As you noted on the link to my article you referenced, that was the only case ever even indirectly linked to swinging. We do not consider it a direct link however due to the circumstances I discuss in the article.
 
Here's a contrast to other post mentioned today. I wear a condom for fear of contracting other STD's than HIV.

Fernie