High Efficiency Furnace Questions

No. Is there any actual visible damage lol... that sounds so bogus

Her bricks in that area looks the same as her bricks on the rest of the wall. But, she is now insisting the vapors are creating tiny holes in her brickwork and maybe even seeping into her house.
 
Her bricks in that area looks the same as her bricks on the rest of the wall. But, she is now insisting the vapors are creating tiny holes in her brickwork and maybe even seeping into her house.

Does she happen to be wearing a shiny tinfoil hat?
 
The conversation with my neighbor just got a bit more complicated. She is now complaining that the emission from my HE furnace vent is traveling across my property and hitting her brick wall more than 2 feet away. She is claiming that the emitted gas hitting her wall is damaging her bricks and motar. Is she making any sense?
The emissions are acidic, as has been mentioned, and they can deteriorate bricks and masonery, which is why you may find a container of limestone chips in the condensate line (that clear plastic hose running to your floor drain from the furnace, also mentione earlier) to 'use up' and neutralize the acidity.

But how is it that your HE vent is just two feet from her wall and you're so concerned that she's proposing to put hers two feet from yours? Would they not each be providing the same degree of dspersion/safety?
 
In his thread regarding property rights, where the issue of the neighbour's furnace installation originated, based on the info Skyrider gave, the applicable code reference was provided which pretty clearly indicated that the installation cannot be done to code, along with the advice to call the TSSA if they proceed with the installation as originally described.
The TSSA will come inspect the install, find that it is not to code, and pursue the installers. There are some substantial fines involved, and it will be the contractor who will be paying the TSSA (they are a self-funding agency). If the contractor is a complete fly-by-nighter who disappears after the job, the homeowner will have to get the code deficiency rectified at their expense. But that furnace will most surely be shut down if the code violation constitutes a health/safety risk.
Its a pretty good system when people are aware of it and use it, in that it will pursue AND punish incompetent and/or dishonest contractors. But theres also a "buyer beware" aspect to it, in that if some guy gives you a ridiculously lowball price on the furnace install, he's most likely cutting corner with your safety.
Thanks for that. If I read it correctly, the TSSA won't come to inspect, or give an 'opinion' in advance, only once a suspected inadequate/uninspected install has been done, and likely all Sky would get from contacting them is their code citation which he could wave at the neighbour in hopes that they'd pay attention.

As with all such matters, the problem isn't as likely to be with the standard for safe, professional work as the enforcement of that standard, preferably before the work is done.
 
But how is it that your HE vent is just two feet from her wall and you're so concerned that she's proposing to put hers two feet from yours? Would they not each be providing the same degree of dspersion/safety?

Although the two walls are around 2.5 feet apart, there are some differences. Her wall is bare, but my wall has windows. Also, the walkway between the two walls is 100% my property and used only by the people in my house.

I spoke to a real estate lawyer and he confirms that her house is flush on the property line (as per the survey) and anything that protrudes from her wall is actually trespassing on my property. My vents are strictly on my own property.
 
Another question. Do single stage and multi-stage high efficiency furnaces discharge the burnt gas differently? My single stage HE furnace discharges in single bursts of several seconds. Do multi-stage HE furnaces discharge on a more continuous steady pattern?
 
But, her wall is 2 feet 3 inches away. Is there still a risk of deterioration at that distance?
There is always a risk. The issue is how low that risk can be made, in the case of furnace vents it is made lower by increasing the distance, and therefore the dispersal/dilution of the fumes. When code-makers come up with a required or prohibited distance, they're saying beyond that point we can live with the decreased risk or deterioration, closer than that point we cannot. But never think that a millimetre short of that imaginary line your bricks are in danger and a millimetre beyond they are not.

Same with the parts per million we use to quantify poisons in the air we breath—the fumes threatening those windows that brought on your questions—the limit number we choose is like drawing a pencil line somewhere on a gray scale and declaring one side is now black and the other is now white. Doesn't make it so.

What all this stuff comes down to is: There's a Code (thank goodness for meddlesome government and the taxers that pay for it) that says what you and your neighbour can and cannot legally do about venting your furnaces. It;s supposed to keep us all safe, and our properties all protected. You find out what it says, and you can see that it's enforced. If you think the code is not adequate for your needs and worries, you can try to get a happier agreement with your neighbour, and/or start agitating to get the code improved.

But there is only one sure thing in life.
 
Although the two walls are around 2.5 feet apart, there are some differences. Her wall is bare, but my wall has windows. Also, the walkway between the two walls is 100% my property and used only by the people in my house.

I spoke to a real estate lawyer and he confirms that her house is flush on the property line (as per the survey) and anything that protrudes from her wall is actually trespassing on my property. My vents are strictly on my own property.

So, as your OP title said, it's an issue of property rights, unless you can find the provision in the Code that says her plan would put the vent prohibitively close to your windows (windows which you couldn't get a building permit for now). Asserting nebulous property rights in a matter of noxious but legally permitted emissions, will be a messy legal morass, as has been said. So you take your tape-measure and chalk and mark that Code permitted/prohibitted line, and live with the install if it's beyond it. Or you talk/persuade/bribe your neighbour into a positioning you like better.

But given that your furnace discharges into the same space, near the same windows, I'd make sure it doesn't come on when the two of you are chatting in the walkway about why you don't want her doing what you are doing to yourself already.

Note: Again,as has been said, minor incursions beyond a property-line or required setback, like an overhanging eavestrough, or a vent hood are usually permitted, in some cases by specific wording in bylaws, in others by the common-law principle that such a trivial inconvenience shouldn't prevent the other owner from what is deemed necessary for their use of their property, e.g: you have to let them use the walkway to examine and maintain their wall. Just who has to replace the vent that keeps getting damaged by ordinary traffic in the narrow space is for another thread.
 
Last edited:
Another question. Do single stage and multi-stage high efficiency furnaces discharge the burnt gas differently? My single stage HE furnace discharges in single bursts of several seconds. Do multi-stage HE furnaces discharge on a more continuous steady pattern?


Single bursts???? what??? I've yet to see that before as your venter motor runs continuously it should be removing flue all the time the unit is on... your venter motor even runs continuously before gas or pilot is ignited....
 
My single stage HE furnace starts, blows, shuts down, pauses and then starts the cycle again after a bit of a rest.
 
I have a mid-efficiency. About 14 years old...no desire to replace it as it runs just fine. The problem with saving gas is the fixed cost of a gas account is pretty high. When I went travelling for 2 months and lowered my house temp to 8 degrees I only saved about $25-30 a month in gas costs...
 
Another question. Do single stage and multi-stage high efficiency furnaces discharge the burnt gas differently? My single stage HE furnace discharges in single bursts of several seconds. Do multi-stage HE furnaces discharge on a more continuous steady pattern?

Not sure what you mean... Single stage is either running or it's not so you tend to either have a greater range of temperature in the house or a lot of short cycles. With multi-stage they usually run in the low-fire stage so they run longer but keep the temperature more even in the house. More of a comfort thing I think. Plus multis tend to run a lot quieter.
 
Single stage is either running or it's not so you tend to either have a greater range of temperature in the house or a lot of short cycles. With multi-stage they usually run in the low-fire stage so they run longer but keep the temperature more even in the house.

I think the single stage and multi-stage vent the exhaust differently. The single stage seems to blow the exhaust out in short periodic bursts whereas multi-stage seem to discharge the exhaust in a more continuous but smaller volume. I think I can tell who has a single or multi-stage furnace by standing outside someone's house and looking at their exhaust vent pipe.