Hey Mr Wilson, you lied!!!!

blackrock13

Banned
Jun 6, 2009
40,084
1
0
After Joe Wilson's impromptu speech and his indignant comments comments on national television, it didn't ake long for him to be put under the microscope.

Read this;


DID JOE WILSON MAKE UP STORY ABOUT PRACTICING IMMIGRATION LAW?
Yesterday Congressman Joe Wilson talked to reporters about his claim that the President was lying about immigrants having access to health care subsidies under the President's health care plan. According to the NY Times:

“I’m for immigration,” [Wilson] said, adding that he had been an immigration lawyer, although he did not specify exactly what he had done. “But people who come toour country and violated our laws, we should not be providing full services.”

It struck me immediately that this would be bizarre if true. Going from representing immigrants to being a member of the virulently anti-immigrant Immigration Reform Caucus and getting an A- rating from anti-immigrant group Numbers USA as well as support from the anti-immigrant fundraising group ALIPAC would show a dramatic tranformation in one's views.

I've been practicing immigration law in the South for nearly 20 years and know a lot of my fellow immigration lawyers in this region. I didn't recognize the name Joe Wilson from West Columbia, South Carolina. So I decided to call some of my friends in the Carolina immigration bar - including some from Columbia - and no one is aware of Congressman Wilson ever handling immigration matters.

South Carolina's immigration bar is not large. And immigration in the state has only been substantial in recent years. Wilson left private practice in 2001 so the odds of him having an immigration practice that escaped the notice of the state's handful of other immigration lawyers is extremely remote.

Did Congressman Wilson - who is making national headlines for calling the President a liar - lie to the national media about his being an immigration lawyer? If so, why? Was it somehow to make it seem like his incorrect reading of the health care bill's immigration provision was accurate?

Congressman Wilson can clear this up by producing evidence of having filed immigration cases and actually having knowledge of immigration law. Former immigration clients of Joe Wilson - speak up and show the world your former lawyer is not the liar he accuses the President of being!

Hmmmmm!!!!
 

Aardvark154

New member
Jan 19, 2006
53,749
3
0
Before we go too far down this path. Practicing Immigration Law, principally practicing Immigration Law and being a member of the American Immigration Lawyers Association are three separate things.

Perhaps the unnamed source in the New York Times believes that practicing Immigration law only means the second or perhaps the second and the third together?

Perhaps things are different "in the South" in the North I know of a number of Immigration Lawyers who will not take clients who never legaly entered the country (as opposed for example to visa overstays). Hence I don't think opposition to Illegal Immigration is particularly good 'evidence' of whether or not one practices Immigration Law.

Now if one really wants to get exercised over immigration law read the following - and if you are a U.S. National consider writing your Representive and Senators urging support for the Private Bill introduced by Representative Duncan:

http://www.thedailytimes.com/article/20090917/NEWS/909179994
 
Last edited:

OddSox

Active member
May 3, 2006
3,148
2
36
Ottawa
All very interesting, but what about his claim that "the President was lying about immigrants having access to health care subsidies under the President's health care plan".

Is it true or not?
 

WoodPeckr

Protuberant Member
May 29, 2002
46,954
5,789
113
North America
thewoodpecker.net
All very interesting, but what about his claim that "the President was lying about immigrants having access to health care subsidies under the President's health care plan".

Is it true or not?
Depends on who you listen to, Obama or Mullah Limbaugh!....;)



The problems we face today will not be solved by the minds that created them
 

kupall

Member
Nov 4, 2005
380
0
16
Depends on who you listen to, Obama or Mullah Limbaugh!....;)



The problems we face today will not be solved by the minds that created them
doesn't matter who you listen to, i'm pretty sure there is a written truth to it... so woody whats the real story? will they or will they not be able to get healthcare through this bill? i would want to know too...
 

WoodPeckr

Protuberant Member
May 29, 2002
46,954
5,789
113
North America
thewoodpecker.net
In spite of all the rabid GOP and special interests obstruction, it looks like it is going to happen. A lot of very GREEDY folks who have been profiteering off the status quo are worried the Gravy Train they have lived off is coming to an end!...;)



The problems we face today will not be solved by the minds that created them
 

Bearlythere

Lost IN the Shwa
Aug 20, 2001
1,147
136
63
Oshawa
It is amazing how the spin was to attack Wilson while ignoring his claim that Obama was lying on illegals getting health care under the new plan. Technically both are right. Obama isn't lying because he will grant amnesty for all the illegals are part of his plan, therefore giving the people currently in the US illegally healthcare because they wont be illegals no more. Wilson is right because no one with half a brain knows what the end game was on this one. Obama wants EVERYONE to have his government plan in the end, even those in the US illegally because they wont be illegals when the time comes. Let Big Daddy government solve all your ills....it works SO well in Cuba does it not? How about that North Korea thing? The USSR???
 

Bearlythere

Lost IN the Shwa
Aug 20, 2001
1,147
136
63
Oshawa
doesn't matter who you listen to, i'm pretty sure there is a written truth to it... so woody whats the real story? will they or will they not be able to get healthcare through this bill? i would want to know too...
Woody wont answer any questions he know he isn't right on. It is that blind loyalty his is cause and not logic that makes him so refreshing...
 

WoodPeckr

Protuberant Member
May 29, 2002
46,954
5,789
113
North America
thewoodpecker.net
It is amazing how the spin was to attack Wilson while ignoring his claim that Obama was lying on illegals getting health care under the new plan.
Not amazing at all!
You, being partial to Joe, just swallow Wilson's lies and go with the far-right spin machine, like the lemmings who listen faithfully to their piper Mullah Limbaugh!....:rolleyes:



The problems we face today will not be solved by the minds that created them
 
Toronto Escorts