The man who thinks all food is delicious will never starve!
For me, I think that experience, including hobby experience, as well as the prevalence of porn on the internet, has "lifted the veil" for me. I see a woman's physical flaws as easily as I see her virtues. And that's just the physical attraction side. I can also now size up a woman's personality pretty quickly as well, sometimes within a few minutes of speaking with her. As a result, I'm pretty sure pretty quickly whether I could picture having sex with a woman. Also, I'm less driven to the thought that I must spend my time dating/bedding women, as opposed to all of the other things there are to do with my time. I've been there and done that, so novelty sex experiences are already off my bucket list. As a result, I have to find something extraordinary (by definition, unusual) about a woman to think about having sex with her. I don't think that anyone with my mindset could find 50 women in an hour that they honestly would have sex with.
Just to be clear, I am not looking down on women or on men whose preferences are more flexible than my own. However, I do think that there are a lot of people who have not really been honest with themselves about what they really want or don't want.