Sugar babies do not have normalized practices like escorts.
You'll met girls that have never done sugaring before, those that have tried it once or twice, and those that have done it their entire adult life, including escorts that use the website to source clientele. The "pro SB" or escorts are typically easy to spot, because they have little interest in chitchat, know what they want, and want to move directly into an exchange. They exhibit behaviour that is higher risk.
By contrast a lot of SBs are skittish, very selective, want to get to know you, and working on information from unreliable sources, such as TikTok, word of mouth or new reports. It seems that the $500 PPM figure gets noted a lot in news articles, and coincidently it's what a lot SBs appear to be hoping for (at minimum).
I think you are overstating the mindset of the average sugar baby and their negotiating skills. While they are obviously in it for the money, a lot of the girls on Seeking are students or just entering the workforce. They are often not seasoned sex workers and do not behave like them.
Of course, I would be hard pressed to "trust" a sugar baby. I've met SBs that explicitly seek exclusive arrangements. This is likely more out of concern for their sexual health than an attempt to extract more money from men. They will tell you about the STI results, IUD, and get annoyed if you keep your profile up on Seeking. They may very well sleeping with others, may have a boyfriend or whatever, but they are probably not seeing new clients everyday on a regular basis.