Greatest American

Andrew Jackson is a disgrace to America

Peter Griffin said:
I'm surprised that Scott Francis key and Andrew Jackson aren't nominated. Jackson and his troops further established America as a truely independent union by defeating the British army.

Scott francis Key penned an inspiring poem during the battle of Fort McHenry. The poem later on became Star Spangled Banner. I thought both Key and Jackson had incredibly significant roles in the founding of this great nation. It bothers me that they're not nominated but Michael Jackson and Oprah are.

I find it hard to believe that any thinking person with knowledge of american history and a sense of decency would pick Jackson. First of all, as pointed out in another comment, his military contribution was minimal. But just the fact that he was responsible for a lot of death and destruction as an army general, makes his consideration suspect.

But that aspect is really nothing compared to two other things he did to damage the dignity of America.

The first is the Spoils System and the following is taken from a web page on historical comment.
"The Spoils System was the name given by its critics in the 1830s to the policy of filling government offices with adherents of the winning political party. The practice of discharging officials appointed by one's predecessor and replacing them with those who had rendered service to one's own party had been common in the United States ever since political parties became well established during the presidency of Thomas Jefferson.

The spoils system, however, became most closely associated in the public mind with President Andrew Jackson, partly because his administration practiced it so widely and partly because he so explicitly endorsed it.""

But most important, Jackson contributed far more to the suffering of Native Americans than any other president, or perhaps any statesman, in american history. He was directly responsible for the genocide that occurred when the Cherokee and other indian nations were transferred by force from their fertile lands to the hostile environment of Oklahoma. Americans at the time pleaded with Jackson to no avail. He gave the order, not some underling, to go ahead with the genocide. The whole story is too long to go into here, but it gets sadder the more you learn about it.

Presumably, a major reason his face is on a $20 bill is that much having to do with currency took place while he was president. But why this man, who was also vulgar and disgruntled much of the time, is accorded a place on US currency, is beyond my comprehension.
 
I voted for Reagan.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I voted for Reagan.

OTB
I also would have voted for Reagan (I assume you are talking about elections and not the contest) but I still think that picking him as the greatest American is a joke. Still, I don't think much of Canada's choice for greatest Canadian so I will be reserved in my criticism.
 
I am a little disappointed in Americans, even more so than usual. As I said earlier, Reagan was a great communicator, a good leader, and a good president. Heck, he might have been the best president of the last 50 years. But the greatest American ever? I don't see it.
 
TOVisitor said:
Keith Olbermann on Countdown, before announcing the order of the top 5, ran down the list of the US' 10 Greatest Monkeys.

Wait, 10 Greatest monkeys? Now, that's a list I can get interested in. Let's see... King Kong, Curious George, Bonzo, Cheeta, Cornelius from Planet of the Apes, Milo the first monkey in space, Chim Chim from Speed Racer, Magilla Gorilla, Donkey Kong, Mojo Jojo from the Power Puff Girls. That's my list.

Oh, and Davy Jones and Mickey Dolenz. How could I forget them?
 
Lincoln - no contest

In the most difficult time in american history, if it wasn't for Lincoln the US would never have made it through. It doesn't take much knowledge of that era to realize it was his leadership that made the difference.