Global Warming..Why is it colder here than normal??

Asterix said:
Sure it would be. It would also take a hell of a lot of time and money. In practical terms, even Mars ain't all that close. By comparison the Moon landing was a piece of cake. We have been blessed with one incredible planet in which to live. So, do we take care of it, or not?


What we should be doing is developing our abilities to get to space and take advantage of all the energy that's there. Imagine solar power sats soaking up all the sunlight without the loss of energy from transiting through the atmosphere. Beam all that power to receiving stations on earth and now you don't need nukes or coal or nat. gas generators. Heck build enough of them and we won't need to pollute with wind towers or solar panel fields either.

If we continue to confine ourselves to one planet then eventually we will be fucked, whether it be by comet strike or climate change or just running out of resources (no matter how well you recycle it'll never reach 100%)
 
papasmerf said:
Ok

OJ landed in the Arizona desert.......Now you know what the war in the middle east is all about.
???
You've been nipping the Finger Lake wine again, haven't you? Must be pretty potent stuff.
 
Papa, the reason it seems colder now than usual is that scientists have wrapped the sun in tin foil paper.
 
<lurkoff>
I remember an article in National Geographic years ago which talked about how NASA had to rescue a satellite that had been placed into orbit and was supposed to be there for, I forget, ten years or something like that. But there was a sudden increase in "solar output" and the earth's atmosphere had expanded with the heat so that the atmosphere actually started to drag on the sattelite and caused it's orbit to decay faster than expected. They had to scramble a shuttle mission to grab the thing and bring it back to earth early.

Back then, before Global Warming was the new religion, people seemed to understand that the sun had a huge influence on things here on earth.

While I'm adding my $0.02, I see that globally in 2006 Big Oil flared off 168 BILLION cubic meters of natural gas worldwide. http://environment.newscientist.com/article/dn12250-rising-prices-could-end-wasteful-gas-flaring.html That's enough to run my house for, conservatively, 24 million lifetimes.

But I'm still supposed to leave my car at home and ride my bicycle to reduce my "carbon footprint"? Gimme a break.

And, seeing as I'm still ranting... those folks who, in the seventies, actually *caused* much of the carbon dioxide output when they went off, foaming at the mouth, with their cry of "no nukes", are now the ones crying "no CO2!". If they hadn't done the whole "no nuke" thing, we might not need any fossil-fuelled power generation plants at all by now.

But then, they'd have to find some other "the sky is falling" cause to get worked up over.

Ok, I'm stepping off my soapbox now.

<lurkon>
 
great bear said:
Papa, the reason it seems colder now than usual is that scientists have wrapped the sun in tin foil paper.


That damn bear I want him in my living room now



No Homo
 
digitald said:
<lurkoff>And, seeing as I'm still ranting... those folks who, in the seventies, actually *caused* much of the carbon dioxide output when they went off, foaming at the mouth, with their cry of "no nukes", are now the ones crying "no CO2!". If they hadn't done the whole "no nuke" thing, we might not need any fossil-fuelled power generation plants at all by now.

F*ck posterity! What's posterity ever done for me?

jwm
 
My fault - I left my windows open with the AC on

Sorry guys... It's been really hot in Philly and I didn't realiz my upstairs windows were open when I turned my AC on. I think that might have caused the cooler than usual temperatures in Buffalo.

I think most of us here realize you can't win this argument. Ice Age age coming in the 70's, Global Warming coming soon, Don't cut down the forest because they reduce CO2 and we need to protect the Spotted Owl... of course new trees create much more CO2 than old trees, but we still can't cut the old forest and plant new trees because of the Owl. Eventually we'll die and the Flyer's and Leaf's still will not have won another Stanley Cup... sigh!!
 
jackd1959 said:
Sorry guys... It's been really hot in Philly and I didn't realiz my upstairs windows were open when I turned my AC on. I think that might have caused the cooler than usual temperatures in Buffalo.

I think most of us here realize you can't win this argument. Ice Age age coming in the 70's, Global Warming coming soon, Don't cut down the forest because they reduce CO2 and we need to protect the Spotted Owl... of course new trees create much more CO2 than old trees, but we still can't cut the old forest and plant new trees because of the Owl. Eventually we'll die and the Flyer's and Leaf's still will not have won another Stanley Cup... sigh!!

Sorry - meant to say new/young trees use more CO2 and create more oxygen than old trees. Not too mention man made forests like the ones run by International Paper don't burn down... but that isn't popular either.
 
jackd1959 said:
Sorry - meant to say new/young trees use more CO2 and create more oxygen than old trees.
OK. I'll keep an open mind here. Any citation on this? What exactly are you comparing? Say an 8' new growth tree to an 80' tree, or something in between? By this logic I suppose we should cut down all the rain forests and plant them with new seedlings. True forests are a combination of the two, a mix of young and old.

Btw, on a sidebar, I deal with wood products quite a bit in my business. I have watched the quality, and density of the wood, drop dramatically over the last two decades. There is a price to pay for the accelerated farm grown trees we see today. One of my best memories as a kid, was flying from Medicine Hat with my dad on a float plane to fish on the Mckenzie river where it flowed from Great Slave Lake. For two hours or more, we saw nothing but Douglas Fir on the entire horizon. I still remember being stunned by the immensity of it all, and for a kid from Oregon where we have lots of trees, that's saying something. Treasure what you have.
 
Asterix said:
OK. I'll keep an open mind here. Any citation on this? What exactly are you comparing? Say an 8' new growth tree to an 80' tree, or something in between? By this logic I suppose we should cut down all the rain forests and plant them with new seedlings. True forests are a combination of the two, a mix of young and old.

A quick google of "tree co2" pulls up a number of references; not sure how authoritative any one of them are, though.
http://www.skakagrall.com/archives/000484co2_tree_planting_faq.html
The scientists have different models for this. However it’s worth noting that carbon absorption for most species is particularly high during the first 15 years, when it can be as much as 15 tonnes of carbon dioxide per hectare of woodland per year.

http://www.abc.net.au/catalyst/stories/s1901661.htm
http://www.co2balance.com/pages.php?pageid=14

Of course, there are additional considerations, as rotting wood will release much of its CO2 (and CH4) back into the atmosphere; you'd want to sequester the carbon in the woodfibre somehow (e.g. drop it all into an open pit; build houses; whatever). And animals and surrounding plants would be threatened as their local ecosystem is severely disturbed.
 
There are numerous sources regarding CO2 absorption between young and old trees. My source was a scientific paper my brother gave me who worked for International Paper. The study was done by scientists at the University of Virginia on a grant from the US government.

Some IP facts...

They plant four seedlings for every tree they harvest. It only makes sense from a business perspective... you need the resource to stay in business.

They care for their forests so a lightning strike doesn't cause millions of acres of forest to burn. The animals are plentiful and not killed off by fires. Again just a good business practice.

Wood quality is based on its use. Most wood used in construction is Pine becasue it grows fast, is plentiful, easy to use, and light so transportation costs are down. You won't find the good pine at Home Depot or Loews.

You can still get fine quality wood if you are willing to pay for it. It takes longer to grow and thus it costs more. You just have to find the right lumbar yard to get it.

With all of that said, this thread was about Global Warming but you proved my point. We can't solve any of the problems because their is always someone, somewhere who says but if you do that this will happen. The fact is, you want a natural way to reduce CO2, deforestation and replanting is one way to do that. If done correctly, even the animals fare well.
 
Ps

Having spent many years covertly traversing south American jungles, I can tell you that OLD forests don't do much in the line of young growth trees. The canopy from the taller older trees is too thick for young saplings to grow. You generally only see young growth where an OLD tree has died and freed up some canopy space for the sun to penetrate. You have a ton of underbrush and rotting leaves and such but nothing compared to the controlled harvesting in corporate forests. OLD forests are also fire hazzards in dry climates because of the buildup of underbrush and dead leaves. You get most of the new growth because of lightning caused forrest fires which is a rarity in a tropical rain forrest. I'm not saying the clearing of trees for farmland is necessarily a good thing since you aren't replacing those trees.
 
jackd1959 said:
The fact is, you want a natural way to reduce CO2, deforestation and replanting is one way to do that. If done correctly, even the animals fare well.
Goodness, this is alot to swallow. First off you can't continually harvest forests without the soil becoming seriously degraded. Secondly, farm forests by design tend to be mono-cultures and as such are very susceptable to disease. Thirdly, no I don't get my wood products from Home Depot, and I'm sorry, but most of what is considered high end lumber is junk compared to what was available one or two decades ago. Fourth, perhaps you can direct me to any credible source that suggests wholesale deforestation is in any way beneficial to the Earth, and where that has been done "correctly".
 
Asterix said:
Fourth, perhaps you can direct me to any credible source that suggests wholesale deforestation is in any way beneficial to the Earth, and where that has been done "correctly".


Forest fires. Mother Nature has been using them for years :) Apparently some trees need to go through a forest fire to get their seeds to sprout.

The Indians used to use controlled burns to increase the amount of new growth forest because they realized that the animals they liked to hunt were more plentiful in new forests.
 
Moraff said:
Forest fires. Mother Nature has been using them for years :) Apparently some trees need to go through a forest fire to get their seeds to sprout.

The Indians used to use controlled burns to increase the amount of new growth forest because they realized that the animals they liked to hunt were more plentiful in new forests.
You are absoutely correct. Also small forest fires clear out small brush, and reduce the fire risk to older more etablished trees. Even after a major fire, most forests regenerate surprisingly fast. Many tree seeds are amazingly resilaint to heat. That, and the burning of any trees itself releases a huge amount of minerals back into the soil. Which was my point earlier. We can't expect to view trees as something we can farm in the long run, because the soil won't be able to keep up. Farming, and yes I depend upon it as much as anyone, is probably the single most damaging thing humans have done to the Earth. The amount of topsoil lost every year in this country is truly staggering.
 
Asterix said:
The amount of topsoil lost every year in this country is truly staggering.


Well, I've always wondered..... Everytime you buy a bag of potatoes you end up with a handful of dirt in the bag. PEI exports lots of potatoes. How long before we reduce the province below water-level and have the world's longest dock? :)
 
Moraff said:
Well, I've always wondered..... Everytime you buy a bag of potatoes you end up with a handful of dirt in the bag. PEI exports lots of potatoes. How long before we reduce the province below water-level and have the world's longest dock? :)
Hmm. It's not just the dirt, but the potatoes themselves which reduce the net landmass of PEI.

Let's say PEI exports 2.8 Billion pounds of potatoes annually. That's about 1.290 million (metric) tons. Let's assume for now that the density of the potatoes, and the density of PEI soil, is about the same as the density of water. (They're both a bit more dense than water, but we'll hope the errors cancel themselves out. So our final answer will be a little off; so what.) That gives us about 1.290 million cubic metres of soil-equivalent.

PEI has a land area of about 5684 square km, or 5,684 million square metres. Its highest elevation is about 152 m above sea level (masl). A PEI marathon had elevations varying from 10masl at the start, to lower elevations, and up to about 50masl. For today, let's assume PEI has an average elevation of 10masl over its entire area, giving it a total volume of 56,840 million cubic metres (above sea level).

So PEI could export potatoes at its current (2006) rate for about 44,000 years (56,840 / 1.29) before the last bit of land disappeared to exports. (Of course, as more land disappeared, it would be more difficult to keep up the rate of production - but we'll assume that the increased rate of erosion would compensate. Aren't assumptions great?)

Now aren't you sorry you asked?

http://www.peipotato.org/why_pei.asp
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prince_Edward_Island
http://www.princeedwardislandmarathon.com/course_info/index.cfm
 
Anynym said:
Hmm. It's not just the dirt, but the potatoes themselves which reduce the net landmass of PEI.

So PEI could export potatoes at its current (2006) rate for about 44,000 years (56,840 / 1.29) before the last bit of land disappeared to exports. (Of course, as more land disappeared, it would be more difficult to keep up the rate of production - but we'll assume that the increased rate of erosion would compensate. Aren't assumptions great?)
]

I'm hoping you're not serious with the above jiberish!

1) Potatoes grow after they are planted so by your terms the land mass would elevate by the mass of the spuds.
2) Land mass would decrease by the size of the spuds when they are harvested with some minor amount of dirt going with it.
3) The dirt lost is offset by the amount of fertilizer (natural and otherwise) so you net lost is close to zero.

With regard to deforestation. Why do people who argue against it always take the extreme. Erosion is caused by uncontrolled deforestation. The thinning of old forests improves the forest and helps prevent millions of acres of burnt out forests. They've talked of doing this in California for years but people like you always seem to manage to prevent it. Instead we spend billions of tax payer money fighting fires from one end of California to the other during the dry season every year. Yes this is how nature deals with it but nature also hands out lots of other not very nice way to deal with things too. Famine is natures way of saying you have too many people living where nature can't support it, so should we just let nature takes its course or try to feed them? My tearn to be extreme. :)
 
jackd1959 said:
I'm hoping you're not serious with the above jiberish!

1) Potatoes grow after they are planted so by your terms the land mass would elevate by the mass of the spuds.
2) Land mass would decrease by the size of the spuds when they are harvested with some minor amount of dirt going with it.
3) The dirt lost is offset by the amount of fertilizer (natural and otherwise) so you net lost is close to zero.

With regard to deforestation. Why do people who argue against it always take the extreme. Erosion is caused by uncontrolled deforestation. The thinning of old forests improves the forest and helps prevent millions of acres of burnt out forests. They've talked of doing this in California for years but people like you always seem to manage to prevent it. Instead we spend billions of tax payer money fighting fires from one end of California to the other during the dry season every year. Yes this is how nature deals with it but nature also hands out lots of other not very nice way to deal with things too. Famine is natures way of saying you have too many people living where nature can't support it, so should we just let nature takes its course or try to feed them? My tearn to be extreme. :)

I agree with you on the tree part. However, the famine is not always nature dependant. In Africa farming is difficult because of subsidized farming happening mostly in North America, which stifles local farm production/