Fox all time jays line up?

[Birf]

I would have replaced Martin with borders, I loved how borders played, although his offensive numbers weren't great. Martin was an overpaid scrub.

Also liked barfield or white over wells, the rest seemed good choices. No way I'd take gruber over Donaldson, even though Donaldson wasn't here long.

Anyone saying guerrero should be on there will dealt with accordingly, overpaid scrub.

 

[Insidious Von]

Is Rick Bosetti on the list?

 

[K Douglas]

Why do they have George Bell in CF and Vernon Wells in right. It should be Bell LF, Wells CF and Bautista RF, no? Like you I think I would put Devon White over Wells. If you take the best 4 seasons as a Jay for each of them you'd fine White has a higher WAR 21.2 to 18.4 and had 4 GG to Wells 3. He also has 2 rings to Wells none. Wells did play 8 full seasons as a Jay to White's 5 so maybe in totality you can make the argument for him. Bottom line is the Jays were very fortunate to have both of them manning centre.
At C I would definitely have Ernie Whitt. The rest I would agree with.

 

[Ref]

My all time 26 player Blue Jays team:

1. 1B: Delgado
2. 2B: Alomar
3. SS: Fernandez
4. 3B: Donaldson
5. LOF: Bell
6. CF: White
7. RF: Bautista
8. C: Borders
9. DH: Carter
10. Bench: Olerud
11. Bench: Molitor
12. Bench: Hill
13. Bench: Semien
14. SP: Halladay
15. SP: Stieb
16. SP: Key
17. SP: Hentgen
18. SP: Clemmons
19. BP: Henke
20. BP: Ward
21. BP: Eichorn
22. BP: Lamp
23. BP: Cecil
24: BP: Koch
25. BP: Osuna
26. BP: Wells

September Call ups
27. P: Stroman
28. Bench: Barfield

 

[Liam011]

The only one I can think to add to that list would be Black Jack as a backup. Always thought he was great, even in Detroit.

 

[Birf]

The only one I can think to add to that list would be Black Jack as a backup. Always thought he was great, even in Detroit.

Jack Morris, one good year with a 4.04 era, I love sarcasm.

 

[The Oracle]

My all time 26 player Blue Jays team:

1. 1B: Delgado
2. 2B: Alomar
3. SS: Fernandez
4. 3B: Donaldson
5. LOF: Bell
6. CF: White
7. RF: Bautista
8. C: Borders
9. DH: Carter
10. Bench: Olerud
11. Bench: Molitor
12. Bench: Hill
13. Bench: Semien
14. SP: Halladay
15. SP: Stieb
16. SP: Key
17. SP: Hentgen
18. SP: Clemmons
19. BP: Henke
20. BP: Ward
21. BP: Eichorn
22. BP: Lamp
23. BP: Cecil
24: BP: Koch
25. BP: Osuna
26. BP: Wells

September Call ups
27. P: Stroman
28. Bench: Barfield

I'd have Ernie Witt as my catcher over Borders.

 

[Birf]

I would put Edwin Encarnación somewhere in the lineup.

Only place would have been DH, hard to replace a guy who had a world series home run.

 

[Insidious Von]

My favorite Blue Jay.

When Goose Gossage trashed Jose due to the bat flip, it made me appreciate Cliff Johnson all the more. When they were both Yankees, Goose picked a fight with Cliff. He ended up on the IL with several new assholes. When he was with the Jays 1983 - 86, he taught the team how to win, nobody messed with our boys.

Gossage wasn't very smart, would you pick a fight with someone who looks like this?