Police, province probe construction deaths Four dead, fifth man in hospital with serious injuries after falling 13 storeys when suspended scaffolding breaks in two December 26, 2009 By SUSAN KRASHINSKY
With a report from The Canadian Press
TORONTO -- The bodies of two fallen construction workers lay uncovered on the ground yesterday afternoon, a day after scaffolding collapsed at an apartment building in the Rexdale neighbourhood of Toronto.
Thirteen storeys above where they lay, half of that same metal platform hung from the building, swinging heavily in the breeze. Five workers had been repairing balconies at the apartment on Christmas Eve when the suspended scaffolding snapped in two, sending the men plummeting.
Four were pronounced dead at the scene. The fifth was found alive and rushed to Sunnybrook Hospital with life-threatening injuries. None of their names have been released. The bodies were eventually removed from the scene just after 6 p.m., more than 24 hours after the accident, after officials were able to secure the scaffolding above.
It's rare for so many deaths to occur in a single incident. In 2008, 10 workers in Ontario died from falls, according to the Construction Safety Association of Ontario. Since 1990, the Ontario construction industry has had between 12 and 36 workplace deaths a year. Last year there were 19, the CSAO said.
Falls are a leading cause of construction-related accidents, according to the association.
Police are investigating Thursday's accident and have launched a probe with the Ministry of Labour. An employee from the Ministry of Labour was on the scene yesterday, but said the ministry would not comment on the case.
Staff Sergeant Egidio Roseto of the Toronto Police confirmed that the survivor of Thursday's accident underwent surgery yesterday morning. The man was in an intensive-care unit in critical condition that afternoon, said George Akleh, shift manager at the hospital.
Police Constable Tony Vella said Thursday that all five men had been repairing balconies on the thirteenth floor of the high-rise when the scaffolding gave way.
"The scaffolding broke for unknown reasons," he said. "All five men fell to the ground."
The Ministry of Labour's Construction Sector Plan for 2008-09 identifies issues involved in improving health and safety on construction projects. On residential projects, which includes low-rise and high-rise buildings, falls were listed as one of the five "major hazards" involved in doing such work, along with the moving of equipment and materials, electrical hazards, excavations and occupational disease.
Among the "key issues" related to such work in the report, scaffolding was the first item listed. Other issues included an unskilled work force, the underground economy and a transient work force.
It was unclear yesterday whether the men involved in the accident were migrant workers, as some local reports indicated earlier.
"We're still trying to confirm identities," said Staff Sgt. Roseto. One of the men had an Ontario driver's license, he said. "My impression is they're not migrant workers ... they're people who lived here," he said.
Yesterday, a City of Toronto order to remedy an unsafe building hung on the front door of the high-rise, citing a contravention of the Building Code Act. The notice said that the scaffolding had failed, "resulting in two sections being held by a single anchor each, creating an unsafe condition."
Workers entered the building just after 2 p.m. yesterday to secure the scaffolding so it would be safe to walk underneath, said Gary Howard, a consulting engineer brought in to work on the site. Because of the unsecured scaffolding, it was too risky to retrieve the remaining bodies until the evening when it was fixed to the building. "If it does blow down and fall, that could be serious injuries," Staff Sgt. David Gillis said earlier in the day.
The numbered company that owns the building released a statement yesterday calling the event "a tragic jobsite accident." It added the owners would continue to co-operate with the investigation.
Building resident Zainab Fatima said she was first alerted to the accident by the multitude of emergency vehicles gathered below her window on Thursday.
"I saw all these police cars at the bottom so I was pretty surprised," she said.
Ms. Fatima said the building's residents had all been told not to go onto their balconies as they were being refurbished.
After about two months of work to fix cracks and fortify the balconies, Ms. Fatima was told Wednesday she could start using her balcony again.
"I feel so sorry for those people," she said. "They finished their work finally and then this."
The incident occurred around 4:30 p.m. Thursday at 2757 Kipling Ave.
The men were all between 20 and 40 years of age, Staff Sgt. Roseto confirmed.
******
A HAZARDOUS JOB
161
Number of Ontario construction workers killed in falls since 1990.
10
Number of Ontario construction workers killed in falls in 2008.
91
Number of workplace deaths, province-wide, included in Workplace Safety and Insurance Board claims in 2008.
0
Ontario's stated goal for the number of annual workplace deaths. While the Ministry of Labour's annual reports cite the goal repeatedly, it doesn't include the current number, which appears to be about 100 a year based on WSIB applications.
104
Cost, in millions of dollars, of Ontario's Occupational Health and Safety program in 2008-09.
700
Number of workplace safety prosecutions struck up by the province in 2008-09.
130
Number of construction workers seriously injured last year.
250,000
Number of people injured in all Ontario workplaces each year.
35.5
Fatality rate per 100,000 construction workers in 1966.
4.3
Fatality rate per 100,000 construction workers in 2008.
Sources: Construction Safety Association of Ontario and Ontario Ministry of Labour