Hooker didn't warrant firing
lawyer: Broker took prostitute to office
Daryl Slade, CanWest News Service
Published: Wednesday, April 26, 2006
CALGARY - Stockbroker Jim Whitehouse should not have been fired for taking a prostitute to his Calgary office after hours, according to his lawyer's written final argument.
Gabor Zinner said RBC Dominion Securities has failed to prove it had just cause for summary dismissal of the investment advisor two days after the incident on Jan. 20, 2004.
RBC, accordingly, should pay Mr. Whitehouse $2,301,500 in damages, he added.
Mr. Zinner said his client admitted that taking a prostitute on to the premises after hours was an example of poor judgment, but did not warrant such drastic sanctions.
"The defendant has failed to show on the facts of this case, and at law, that the mere fact of having a prostitute on the premises after hours was a sufficient ground," Mr. Zinner argued.
Mr. Zinner also said there was no evidence that RBC, which countersued Mr. Whitehouse for $6-million, suffered any financial loss or damage to its reputation.
Mr. Whitehouse, 51, admitted at trial that he was intoxicated, going through marital difficulties and under tremendous stress of managing his clients' $125-million portfolio when he picked up Cassandra Stolarchuk on a downtown stroll.
Mr. Zinner said RBC had not proven there was any intention to have sex, although his client was initially leaning toward that.
The incident came to light only when Ms. Stolarchuk came back to RBC the following day and told a staff member she would kill the broker if he didn't pay her.
RBC lawyer James Rooney must submit his final argument to Court of Queen's Bench Justice Terry McMahon by May 5. Mr. Zinner then has another two weeks to reply.