Finch LRT could see signal priority, increased speeds, as criticism continues to roll in
City councillors said Wednesday they’re hoping to unlock higher speeds and signal priority for the Finch Light-Rail Transit line after its opening day saw mixed reaction.
Coun. Jamaal Myers (Scarborough North), who is also the Toronto Transit Commission's chair, brought a motion to urgently speed up the new LRT routes at Wednesday’s board meeting. That motion passed.
“The simple truth is this: rapid transit must be rapid,” he said.
Line 6 of the TTC, which includes 18 stops, connects Finch West station to Humber Polytechnic’s north campus, according to the TTC’s website. Construction on the line began in 2019, and it was originally supposed to be open in 2021.
Instead, its grand opening happened Sunday with free rides for the crowds of excited transit users and local residents. But what was set to be a celebratory day was quickly tarnished with frustration as commuters realized the LRT line included fewer stops than the previous bus route.
A CBC Toronto reporter also rode the entire 10.3-kilometre line from east to west Monday, finding it took roughly 55 minutes to complete. The reporter’s eastbound return trip was closer to 47 minutes.
Bus 'zooming right past' LRT: advocate
Andrew Pulsifer, executive director of transit advocacy group TTCriders, said the Line 6 opening was “a debacle.”
“This is ultimately an own goal, folks,” he said. “We’ve been sounding the alarm for lack of signal priority on both the Finch and Eglinton LRT for a long time.”
Pulsifer said he saw a bus “zooming right past” and the LRT getting stuck behind left-turning vehicles.
“Reality sunk in,” he said. “The LRT is open and it is as slow, or slower, than we predicted.”
Wednesday’s motion asked the TTC and Metrolinx, which built the LRT line, to work together to institute transit signal priority on the route, which would keep lights green to allow the LRT to move through intersections without frequent stops.
Metrolinx points finger at city
In a statement to CBC Toronto Wednesday, Metrolinx said it’s the city that is not using the full extent of transit signal priority.
“If they wish to change that, they will find a wide-open door at Metrolinx to update the software accordingly,” the statement said.
As for increasing the speed, the city's transit expansion executive director Derrick Toigo said it’s not that simple.
“It doesn’t work that way. It’s very complicated,” he said Wednesday.
City staff added that instituting signal priority would change the speed of service. But for that to happen, Mosaic — the collection of private companies contracted by Metrolinx to maintain the line — would need to be involved.
“That would cause more maintenance on the vehicles,” Toigo said. “It’s not that they have an ability to say no to transit signal priority, but they do need to be informed.”
'Not a success story,' councillor says
Coun. Josh Matlow (Toronto-St. Paul’s) and Coun. Alejandra Bravo (Davenport) said the conversations between Metrolinx, TTC, Mosaic and the city need to be shared with the public.
“We need to find solutions and we need to be accountable and transparent in real time,” Bravo said at a news conference with riders and transit advocates Wednesday.
Matlow, who was also at the conference, said there’s no question that the speed is an “abysmal failure” and that Torontonians want and deserve answers.
“There is no way that one can rationalize spending billions of dollars, years of delays, businesses and communities impacted, to only have rapid transit that goes slower than the buses it’s meant to replace,” he said. “That is not a success story.”
Matlow said some of the issues have been perpetrated by a “dysfunctional relationship” between Metrolinx, the city and the TTC, which makes him feel “not confident.”
“The TTC is often told, rather than consulting with the Metrolinx organization, that it is accountable only to premier [Doug] Ford and the transportation minister, it seems, rather than us and the people of Toronto,” he said. “The behaviour of Metrolinx has been bullyish.”
Toronto Mayor Olivia Chow is set to bring a motion to speed up LRTs and streetcars to city council next week.