Finally justice - This is Canada

Well quarks, you are entitled to your opinions, just like I am and thankfully we live in a country where we do have that unalienable (inalienable??) right.

As for your comments: Not once did I say it was LEGAL. Please don't put words in my mouth (or my posts). I said it was practiced, BIG difference.

As for ethnic cleansing: You brought up yugoslavia and you might as well bring up bosnia. Sorry, it wasn't just the military doing the killing. It was private citizens as well.

Again, you jump to a huge conclusion. I never ONCE said a whole culture embraces any or all of the practices. I said there are "cultures" which there are. Are you trying to tell me that you CAN'T walk into a storefront in bangkok and see a bunch of teenage girls behind a glass for the purpose of prostitution? If everyone knows about it, and it goes on unmolested by the police, is that not a culture condoning the practice? Dick.....
 
tboy said:
…edit…The basic topic here is one culture's practice being overturned by an electoral body and whether or not it should have been.…edit…The point I am trying to make is that this is Canada. Here we have many rights and freedoms not found in many parts of the world. Being Canadian means that I have the RIGHT to accept some, all, or no religious or ethnic practices of other cultures. What that means is I can accept one practice by one religion and not another by the same religion. That is called freedom of choice.
Amazing how wide this tiny topic gas ranged. Lets be clear on what that basic topic was, and remember what actually happened: Before the election the question was raised whether fully veiled muslim women could be properly identified as qualified electors and vote. The proper authority, the person charged with enforcing the electoral law determined that they could. Some who disagreed—not whether the women could legally vote, but that veiled/masked women should vote at all legal or no—threatened to disrupt the election. The Electoral Officer, rather than endanger the voting process, chose discretion, bowed to the bozos and said the women would have to show their faces.

So if the cultural practice of veiling was overturned, it was by the bozos; the electoral body upheld it. Or tried to.

I appreciate what you say about freedom of choice. I don't have to like your beliefs and practices, nor you mine. The law will treat us all equally as having the same free choice within 'limits usual in a free and democratic etc.'. Clearly the Electoral Officer was of a like mind, and found nothing in the law that required the women's freedom of choice should be abridged. Sadly there's always a few who care more for forcing some kind of uniformity than for freedom, who think a practice they don't accept may therefore be suppressed.
 
Last edited:
fuji said:
In Muslim countries women identify themselves to security officers all the time. This is overblown. On the other hand it would be reasonable if elections officers made a best effort to have a female officer verify the photo, and only have a male officer do that if no female officer is present.

We probably live in a legal climate where a gesture like that would be used as a precedent to have it made a requirement. That's our fault, for having a shitty legal climate.

Finally an intelligent response. Thank you!

This whole debate seems to have taken place between the politicians in Quebec and the electoral authorities. I don't think any Muslims had anything to do with it. Muslim women routinely show their faces and allow themselves to be photographed for photo ID etc. I doubt that any Muslim expected the election in Quebec to be any different. I don't know why so many of you assumed this controversy was caused by Muslims requesting special treatment when it was all just PC politicians jockeying for votes and bureaucrats.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20070324.wxquebec24/BNStory/Front/

"...Shama Naz, a 30-year-old Montrealer who wears a niqab, said the issue has been blown out of proportion. She said Muslim women routinely remove their face veils for security matters. She has done so for her Medicare card photo, and each time she crosses the border to visit her father in New York State.

“It's common sense. Muslim women have no problem identifying themselves for security reasons,” she said. “If [elections officials] had spoken to me they would have known I wouldn't mind identifying myself at the ballot box.”

While she would prefer to do so to a female elections worker, she would do so for a man as well, said Ms. Naz, an economics graduate.

“People are usually scared of what they don't know,” she said of the uproar and yesterday's change in the law. “A lack of information is driving regulations like this.”....
 
You don't think Muslims would force women to wear the head gear? Just look at the woman from the 15 British captured soldiers.
 
Meister said:
You don't think Muslims would force women to wear the head gear? Just look at the woman from the 15 British captured soldiers.
And the guys in Gitmo wear the orange jumpsuits purely as fashion statements; jailers have always controlled prisoners' dress. Think before posting; the election's over and this thread should be allowed to RIP.
 
David Beckham 23 said:
Are you saying Muslims in Iran represent Muslims in Canada?
I am just responding to earlier posts where people said that Muslim men would never force women to wear the head gear.
 
oldjones said:
And the guys in Gitmo wear the orange jumpsuits purely as fashion statements; jailers have always controlled prisoners' dress. Think before posting; the election's over and this thread should be allowed to RIP.
Yes, think. Many prisoners all over the US are wearing bright colours. This is done in case they escape.
 
Meister said:
Yes, think. Many prisoners all over the US are wearing bright colours. This is done in case they escape.
So it woulda been OK w/ you if the hijab had been bright orange? When our/your jailers force the dress code, it's OK w/ ytou because it's for 'practical' purposes. And jumpsuits are well known to be universally acceptable dress in all cultures. [sarcastic smiley here]

When their jailers impose their dress code, it's not OK because it's …? Well what exactly?

If you believe jailer's behaviour typifies a culture—you did raise this incident to 'prove' muslim men force women to veil—then please explain how a headscarf (not a veil) is worse than the culture typified by Abu Ghraib.
 
oldjones said:
So it woulda been OK w/ you if the hijab had been bright orange? When our/your jailers force the dress code, it's OK w/ ytou because it's for 'practical' purposes. And jumpsuits are well known to be universally acceptable dress in all cultures. [sarcastic smiley here]

When their jailers impose their dress code, it's not OK because it's …? Well what exactly?

My point is that the head gear on the British soldier has nothing to do with orange colour, escaping, security or anything of that nature. The only thing I can think of is that these men think 'now you are in our care, our country, our religion, so you need to wear it'. Or, do you think the woman has asked to wear it to conform to Iranian traditions?
 
Meister said:
My point is that the head gear on the British soldier has nothing to do with orange colour, escaping, security or anything of that nature. The only thing I can think of is that these men think 'now you are in our care, our country, our religion, so you need to wear it'. Or, do you think the woman has asked to wear it to conform to Iranian traditions?
Bingo! "…these men think 'now you are in our care, our country, our religion, so you need to wear it'" In their eyes she's indecently dressed w/o it. Imagine a US jailer dealing with a guy from New Guinea who thinks he's quite decent wearing only a penis gourd, or a guy wearing only a dhoti. Neither one's gonna blend in if he escapes, are they? Nor would the Afghanis and Pakistanis in their customary dress.

While they may have utility as anti-escape measures (and the Brit Sailor would actually benefit from the scarf, if she escaped), prisoner dress codes are all about jailers' standards and power. Our jailers or theirs. Proves nothing about the greater culture's dress codes—though forcing guys to parade in plastic garbage bags sure says a lot about the greater society that permits it—and even less about the dress codes in a culture on the other side of the world, i.e Quebec muslims. You hadn't forgotten that was the topic had you?
 
Last edited: