Fighting Getty Images on Copyright Issue.

You're screwed. Images that are used on websites and other material have to have some kind of disclaimer stating it's permission for intended use for....

I used royalty free images, stock photos and other materials. Never have I payed for a license but there is a trick that your design contractor was obviously oblivious to. I wouldn't take the designers word for it. Remember, if he agrees he DID use it, then he is legally liable and can be sued. They will play ignorance and righteouness.

For those who want to use other peoples photos or images, you have to at least edit or change it so the image is at least 60% different from the original. You can copyright a photo of Michael Jordan, but you can't copyright a silhouette of Jordans less famous moves. The Air Jordan silhouette is a trademark and hence can not be infringed upon but his other moves can be silhouetted, even if they are clearly Michael Jordan in a pic from a professional photo. The trick was that you took out the photo quality and replaced with solid color. You effectively removed or changed 60% of the image.

All designers should know this. I sure do. ;) I have used countless images borrowed from stock photo sites. It might bite me in the end but I don't think so.
 
From the Canadian copyright act Section 38:

2) Where a copyright owner has made an election under subsection (1) and the defendant satisfies the court that the defendant was not aware and had no reasonable grounds to believe that the defendant had infringed copyright, the court may reduce the amount of the award to less than $500, but not less than $200.

(3) Where

(a) there is more than one work or other subject-matter in a single medium, and

(b) the awarding of even the minimum amount referred to in subsection (1) or (2) would result in a total award that, in the court's opinion, is grossly out of proportion to the infringement,

the court may award, with respect to each work or other subject-matter, such lower amount than $500 or $200, as the case may be, as the court considers just

I would still attempt to contact a copyright lawyer, but I would think that a letter back to them stating that you have taken down the pictures as soon as you were made aware of the possible infringement, and that this to your understanding is the proper civilized process for addressing such situation.

Tell them you respect their copyright protections under CANADIAN law, and feel confident that if they still wish to pursue further legal actions that you can easily show that you had reasonable grounds to believe that the material in questions was not in violation of any copyright.

You may even offer to pay them the minimum $200.

If there is actually a collection agency involved, I would contact consumer protection to have them stop any harassment, and make sure they remove any hits against your credit history that they may have files.

Good Luck.
 
woolf said:
I don't understand how it could have gone to a collection company? If the collection company contacts you again ask them for all their information and under which law they can collect for a company when there is no signed contract or court order to pay damages.

I would think that if this company wants to proceed, the first step would be to get a court judgement of copyright infringement. They can't just make up their own judgement that you are guilty and then come up with their own numbers as to the damages.

Report the collection agency to the proper government department (consumer protection I believe) and tell the company to send you a copy of the court judgement and the papers they filed to get the judgement (they need to make a reasonable effort to notify you of any impending litigation actions before a judgement can proceed.)

Of course, IAMAL, but I have stepped through the small claims court process, and these are my recollections of some of the necessary steps before you can demand money from someone.

P.S.

Please send me your name and address so I can send you my bill for services ;-)
that is very helpful thanks
 
ruck said:
For those who want to use other peoples photos or images, you have to at least edit or change it so the image is at least 60% different from the original.

Very interesting but how does something as arbitrary as 60% different get measured?
 
woolf said:
From the Canadian copyright act Section 38:



I would still attempt to contact a copyright lawyer, but I would think that a letter back to them stating that you have taken down the pictures as soon as you were made aware of the possible infringement, and that this to your understanding is the proper civilized process for addressing such situation.

Tell them you respect their copyright protections under CANADIAN law, and feel confident that if they still wish to pursue further legal actions that you can easily show that you had reasonable grounds to believe that the material in questions was not in violation of any copyright.

You may even offer to pay them the minimum $200.

If there is actually a collection agency involved, I would contact consumer protection to have them stop any harassment, and make sure they remove any hits against your credit history that they may have files.

Good Luck.

That is good and fair. Can it be the logic can prevail here? I greatly appreciate your advice. :)
 
LancsLad said:
Now that you mention it, remember the bar based sitcom Cheers and then later the Frasier spinoff. So do I, wish I wrote for them.

Is it true that Papasmerf was the head writer for The Beverly Hillbillies? I think he also had a part in the movie Deliverance "the boy on the bridge playing the banjo"
 
great bear said:
Is it true that Papasmerf was the head writer for The Beverly Hillbillies? I think he also had a part in the movie Deliverance "the boy on the bridge playing the banjo"



That little ditty that pops played in the movie is the background sound when Windows boots up for all computers sold on the Frankford area of Ontario near Trenton. Bill Gates must know about the inbreeding there.
 
LancsLad said:
That little ditty that pops played in the movie is the background sound when Windows boots up for all computers sold on the Frankford area of Ontario near Trenton. Bill Gates must know about the inbreeding there.


Fished many a time in the Frankford area on the Trent system. The locals all seemed to sport pointy ears. Could this be the result of inbreeding or wearing a touque right through to June?
 
great bear said:
Fished many a time in the Frankford area on the Trent system. The locals all seemed to sport pointy ears. Could this be the result of inbreeding or wearing a touque right through to June?



Both I think, down that way when they talk with pride about little Johnnie rolling his own for the first time, they are not talking about a smoke.
 
LancsLad said:
Both I think, down that way when they talk with pride about little Johnnie rolling his own for the first time, they are not talking about a smoke.

That reminds me of the conversation between a Frankford father and his son.

Son says "dad I'm going to marry Lillybell, and she's a virgin".

Father replies " Son dump her, if she ain't good enough for her kin folk she sure as hell ain't good enough for you".
 
Some guy in Frankford sys to his wife " So even if we get a divorce , you'll still be my ma, right?"
 
ruck said:
...For those who want to use other peoples photos or images, you have to at least edit or change it so the image is at least 60% different from the original. ...

Are you sure about this Ruck? I know that when I sell my work..it's 100% of the orginal. If anyone uses any portion in their biz promotion either I or the person who bought the image can sue them. If my image is copyrighted...then it's it's mine. If you use it..not matter how much, you have to pay. With that said, read on.

Getty has imbedded tags in their images that allow them to find the images online. It's like the google spiders. The image has an imbedded number, if you don't match up to the person who bought it they will come after you. Particularly if the image has not been sold by Getty before. I have told people who wanted my images and were looking at Getty for some shots as well ..PAY...or they will get you. They seldom lose. Getty is the primo photo agency. They have the money to make anyones life miserable.

If you used unwittingly a Getty copyrighted image, apologize. Tell them you dealt with a contractor who felt he/she was dealing with royalty free images. That will set the tone for further dialog.

In the mean time..hire a lawyer. How do I know..Getty represents me.

M2
 
MarkII said:
If you used unwittingly a Getty copyrighted image, apologize. Tell them you dealt with a contractor who felt he/she was dealing with royalty free images. That will set the tone for further dialog.
Are you mad?
Sure, if you want to plead guilty upfront and tell them take my money without a fight then that would be good advice. I have a feeling these guys send out hundreds or thousands of these letters. They possibly can't sue everybody.

My advice:
Don't do anything until you get served. Then hire a lawyer. Have your lawyer attend first hearing (approx. 600 dollars). Then offer to settle for 2000, they may come back with 3000.