Dual Citizenship

fuji said:
I still don't see any problem with dual citizenship. Any problem you could describe, I think, boils down to offering services to people who aren't RESIDENT in Canada.

I still think we can fix all that just by tailoring social policies so that the handouts and freebies require some number of months or years of residency to qualify.

Thank you for being RATIONAL.

Some people actually think that stealing citizenship rights from people who have been paying Canadian taxes for decades and concurrently handing out free services to people who have never paid a dime and are NOT citizens is FAIR!!!!!!!! If that's not warped I don't know what is.

Some of us have entire families who have been contributing big taxes in this country since the 1960's and have never collected anything or asked anyone for help. We had jobs here from day one. Let's let the issue rest.
 
what if they pay taxes for twenty years and then leave to live elsewhere? is there a formula- (taxes paid less services taken equals surplus in account)
 
red said:
what if they pay taxes for twenty years and then leave to live elsewhere? is there a formula- (taxes paid less services taken equals surplus in account)
Is there a formula for giving people their money BACK if they leave? This is not manageable unless they just eliminate taxes and have everybody pay for everything. Which would be fine by me.

This is all just a Canadian inferiority complex. That's all.
 
Esco! said:
F__K that!!!!!!!!!

I've worked and lived in Canada and England, I should be able to collect my pension from both since I paid an extraordinate amount of taxes in the 2 countries.
Sorry, but I neglected to tell you that Canada has signed bilateral treaties with many countries on this topic. You'll get both pensions for sure. I can tell you from personal experience. I used to help senior citizens who can't even speak English fill out the forms.
 
Sergei said:
Some of us have entire families who have been contributing big taxes in this country since the 1960's and have never collected anything or asked anyone for help. We had jobs here from day one. Let's let the issue rest.
Some of us since the 1860s.
 
rama putri said:
Some of us since the 1860s.
1) There was no taxation in Canada back then.
2) The people who came here back then have a LOT of crimes on their hands. Some people were here WAY before you guys packed them into reserves.
 
Now the settlers of this country are criminals, lol.

Talk about people not being rational.
 
Really???

goodtime said:
You're correct. It's is allowed but they discourage it, sometime with strong wording.

My travel buddy has to be careful which passport he enter & exit U.S. with. If passport is close to expiration date, U.S. custom has the right to detain you, do background check & withheld your passport. According to one such chip-on-shoulder custom sob, to weed out 'fake' passports.

Whenever I enter the US it is with my U.S. passport, as per the protocol...you enter a country with their passport (assuming you have one).

Never had a problem....
 
Sergei said:
You obviously think that decimating the native population did not amount to a crime.


Not really, They had it, the settlers wanted it. The settlers had the edge and used it. Just like others before them.
 
Should there be some credit given for people who contributed for years and then moved away? Good question. I suppose it depends on the program. We don't have to apply the same solution to all of them.

For pensions that is already true--the amount of your OAS pension depends on the total number of years you were resident in Canada, not whether those years were recent.

I think for education and healthcare recency should matter more. You ought to be resident here immediately before consuming those services. Otherwise it's open to abuse: People will get Canadian citizenship, move to a low tax country for their retirement, and then come back here as soon as they run a health problem. That's abusive.

Another solution--we could allow people who move away but who still want to consume Canadian benefits to OPT to pay some Canadian taxes to be considered equivalent to resident. Not the same amount of tax as if they WERE resident, but something so that we aren't open to nation shopping.
 
MLAM said:
Whenever I enter the US it is with my U.S. passport, as per the protocol...you enter a country with their passport (assuming you have one).

Never had a problem....
Obviously! Wasn't referring to U.S. passport. Chip-on-shoulder Custom dude claim power to pull & withheld passports of other country.

BTW, you may consider buy a CDN passport sleeve to put over your U.S. passport, like most U.S. tourists while overseas.:o