I had a friend that did Dr. B. He lost quite a bit, but put back on most of it. Dr. B treats the symptom but not the root cause. For some people, eating is their emotional crutch.
He also complained that the medical supervision was a crock. The doctor probably worked for Bernstien because he couldn't hold a medical job elsewhere in his opinion. Didn't Dr. B. get disciplined by the OMA or the College of Physicians?