Do Teachers have it Easy

Are teacher fairly compensated?

  • Teachers have it made in the shade. They don't realize how lucky they are

    Votes: 34 39.1%
  • Teachers are overpaid for what they do.

    Votes: 9 10.3%
  • I'd be ok with their salary if they worked 11 mos. of the year.

    Votes: 8 9.2%
  • Teachers are reasonably well compensated but not excessively

    Votes: 22 25.3%
  • The remuneration is low compared to other professions.

    Votes: 8 9.2%
  • Teachers are underpaid really and overworked.

    Votes: 6 6.9%

  • Total voters
    87
Sounds like hard idle is a teacher or knows some teachers because he is bang on.

Sorry but every 4 years they revamp the curriculum which means I have to adjust my lessons I have not taught nearly long enough to develop a bank of material large enough to deal with this.

So I guess I should get 75 x 4 pages tests plus 75 x 2 pages of quizes marked in my one 75 min prep period when on any given day that period may be cut in half to do hall, caf or classroom duty. Make phone calls and photocopy. If you have a cover your ass type principal there's also a ton of paper work to document exactly everything you've done to try and avoid the kid failing. Not to mention I need to prepare 75 min x 2 or 3 worth of presentations for the next day. Also did you know that tests if done in a strict department must be preapproved by other teachers teaching the same course to ensure consistancy and fairness. Writing a good test free of errors and balanced marking scheme easily takes another 2 or 3 hours plus an hour for someone else to review plus 20 min for you to revise it.

But like I said I'm happy but I think those outside of the biz need to do some more research.

Question? Does you company pay for your training? Ours doesn't. Not a complaint but certainly not unheard of in many other professional settings.

Oh yeah I didn't even factor in mark entry and making of the report cards. In high school its better about 11 hours over the course of 5 months. Not a lot but if you look at the 75 min work period that's about 9 days worth of prep time eaten up right there.

Phone calls home I usually have about 15 to 21 kids that require calls home. At 5 to 10 min per call plus follow up calls that's a lot of time which also eats into this prep period.

Anyways, my point is that if you think everything can be done between 8 and 3 you're kidding or going through the motions as a teacher.
 
frankcastle said:
Sounds like hard idle is a teacher or knows some teachers because he is bang on.

Sorry but every 4 years they revamp the curriculum which means I have to adjust my lessons I have not taught nearly long enough to develop a bank of material large enough to deal with this.

So I guess I should get 75 x 4 pages tests plus 75 x 2 pages of quizes marked in my one 75 min prep period when on any given day that period may be cut in half to do hall, caf or classroom duty. Make phone calls and photocopy. If you have a cover your ass type principal there's also a ton of paper work to document exactly everything you've done to try and avoid the kid failing. Not to mention I need to prepare 75 min x 2 or 3 worth of presentations for the next day. Also did you know that tests if done in a strict department must be preapproved by other teachers teaching the same course to ensure consistancy and fairness. Writing a good test free of errors and balanced marking scheme easily takes another 2 or 3 hours plus an hour for someone else to review plus 20 min for you to revise it.

But like I said I'm happy but I think those outside of the biz need to do some more research.

Question? Does you company pay for your training? Ours doesn't. Not a complaint but certainly not unheard of in many other professional settings.

Oh yeah I didn't even factor in mark entry and making of the report cards. In high school its better about 11 hours over the course of 5 months. Not a lot but if you look at the 75 min work period that's about 9 days worth of prep time eaten up right there.

Phone calls home I usually have about 15 to 21 kids that require calls home. At 5 to 10 min per call plus follow up calls that's a lot of time which also eats into this prep period.

Anyways, my point is that if you think everything can be done between 8 and 3 you're kidding or going through the motions as a teacher.
With the amount of time you spend on this board and the amount of time you spend hobbying I have no choice but to call BULLSHIT!
 
Yeah you're right I just make up the marks and make fake phone logs and tell jokes for 75 minutes in class.
 
frankcastle said:
Sounds like hard idle is a teacher or knows some teachers because he is bang on.
.

Like I said, you couln't pay me enough to spend a third of my day with kids.

But I have a pretty good memory of how my high school teachers spent their time - I skipped so many classes that I knew exactly what was going on in the department offices at all times - and I spent enough time arguing after class to know they could not have done any other work before going somewhere for a stiff drink!

(In other words frank -I WAS YOUR WORST NIGHTMARE - LOL!)

One of my former employers was a teacher in Europe and Saskatchewan but couldn't get hired in the GTA so he did other work for a while. It took him 7 years of supply teaching on call anywhere in Durham, Toronto, Halton-Peel And Dufferin to land a permanent post in a high school in 2002.
 
KWI said:
every single week both schools are sending home this fund-raiser and that lunch form and this trip form and that and this and that. Every single week both schools with their hands out asking for money. And I don't mean your normal month pizze days and your terry fox runs. We are talking PJ day for a buck and hat day for a buck and selling these candy bars and the lunch lady and the milk orders and 15 for school agenda's ......... The list goes on and on. KWI

It's funny, but when I was in school this never ever happened.

Things have changed allot in 20 years.

I know this one high school teacher in york region and they have these INCREDIBLE school trips. New York City, Europe, even Australia.

When I was in High School in Hamilton, we went NOWHERE. Not even a day trip to Dundurn Castle. The only school trip I remember was the Grade 8 trip to Ottawa where we were out of control and stayed in the Dorms at Carleton University.

With these trips to exotic locations teachers are falling over themselves volenteering to go. I asked her once if the school trip was to say Kingston Ontario for the weekend to study the history of upper Canada would she still be volenteering to take the kids as was the case for NYC and Europe.

She just looked at me and laughed and said, "I don't think so"

So much for dedication.

Then again, the whole exotic trip thing comes down to parents paying the shot. In the Hammer in the 1980's no-one was going to pay for their kids to hop on a plane to Europe. Hell, most of the families I knew, the parents had never even been on a plane, let alone Jr.
 
james t kirk said:
It's funny, but when I was in school this never ever happened.

Things have changed allot in 20 years.

I know this one high school teacher in york region and they have these INCREDIBLE school trips. New York City, Europe, even Australia.

When I was in High School in Hamilton, we went NOWHERE. Not even a day trip to Dundurn Castle. The only school trip I remember was the Grade 8 trip to Ottawa where we were out of control and stayed in the Dorms at Carleton University.

With these trips to exotic locations teachers are falling over themselves volenteering to go. I asked her once if the school trip was to say Kingston Ontario for the weekend to study the history of upper Canada would she still be volenteering to take the kids as was the case for NYC and Europe.

She just looked at me and laughed and said, "I don't think so"

So much for dedication.

Then again, the whole exotic trip thing comes down to parents paying the shot. In the Hammer in the 1980's no-one was going to pay for their kids to hop on a plane to Europe. Hell, most of the families I knew, the parents had never even been on a plane, let alone Jr.

My eldest went on a trip to Quebec City this year. Very well organized by the teacher and only one teacher went. She took 12 parents and 34 kids all by her lonesome. According to everyone it was a wonderful experience. I guess it really depends on who the teacher is. There are lazy louts in every profession I guess. I still respect what teachers do but I understand the other "side of the coin" point of view. I remember some great teachers who inspired and I remember some real loser teachers who made me want to dropout. I guess what I'm trying to say is don't lump ALL teachers or anyone of any profession into one basket and call them rotten. I've had some real bad cab rides and I don't think all cabbies are assholes. Or do I? ;)
 
emailme84 said:
... They can just as easily stay at the school to mark their assignments but they take them home because they would rather be at home with their families... another benefit we do not have while at work
So now the fact that they take work home with them is a luxury?

Simple fact is that there are many good hardworking teachers and many average, bad, or lazy teachers. People like to complain because they always remember one or two bad experiences they had in school. Meanwhile, everyone likely had 20 or 30 teachers who did a decent, good, or amazing job helping them try to achieve their goals.

I see teaching as hugely important profession, both for individuals and society. I would love to see them get rid of the bad teachers but that would require finding someone good to fill their shoes (unless 100 students per class is good). In this climate of teacher bashing and the decent (but not amazing) pay how likely is it that you can find the fantastic people we need wanting to spend their days dealing with troubled youth, their afternoons dealing with overbearing parents, and their evenings dealing with complaining friends and neighbours?
 
Took a look at this year's yearbook we had 31 coaches that's just shy of 33% of the staff.

At your work do one in three offer to do unpaid overtime to the tune of 2 hour practices say 3 times a week plus 2 games each for another 2 hours a week for say 2 months? That's 80 hours of overtime for free and truth be told for sports like b-ball, v ball, soccer, football or hockey it can be more than that. And I haven't even thrown in time for tournaments and playoffs above and beyond regular seasons.

Here's one things I can say the further you get from a city centre the worse the school will be. When the guy mentioned oshawa/whitby I'm not surprised. More suburban schools tend to have older staff that have settled down thus harder for younger more enthusiastic teachers to get in there.

If you have the chance send your kid to a newly built school.... the chances of getting the extra curricular stuff will increase.

But let me say this I have coached for 3 years now and only 5 kids parents ever showed up for any games. Ask me how many bball games I catch of my students? All home games and playoff road games.

Sorry to say this but if you're out in the burbs with old established schools your kid might actually get short changed.
 
Complete idiocy

james t kirk said:
I realize that, but it's an informal poll on an escort review board.

But, I am curious to see pubic perception is all.

I voted for No. 3 by the way. I'm ok with their salary if they worked 11 mos. of the year like everyone else in the world.

cheers

This whole thread is simply bashing. Let's call a spade a spade. First of all, any poll, in order to be valid has to be completely free of bias in its language so as not to influence the outcome. Second, the debate this fosters is all about perception and not about fact. This is a poisoned thread and I am surprised that the moderators have not judged it to be so publicly. Talk to me when you have followed a teacher around and gotten an in depth view of what the job entails. Even then there may not be a scale comprehensive enough o compare occupations. I once saw a study on stress levels and occupations and teachers were right up at the top just under air traffic controllers. I don't know how this started and who had a particular axe to grind but you can cut it out any time now. Tell me your occupation and I am quite sure I can make hamburger out of it. And to all you defenders, you are just giving this poster what he wants - attention. Do us all a favour and end it now.
 
Regular Guy said:
This whole thread is simply bashing. Let's call a spade a spade. First of all, any poll, in order to be valid has to be completely free of bias in its language so as not to influence the outcome. Second, the debate this fosters is all about perception and not about fact. This is a poisoned thread and I am surprised that the moderators have not judged it to be so publicly. Talk to me when you have followed a teacher around and gotten an in depth view of what the job entails. Even then there may not be a scale comprehensive enough o compare occupations. I once saw a study on stress levels and occupations and teachers were right up at the top just under air traffic controllers. I don't know how this started and who had a particular axe to grind but you can cut it out any time now. Tell me your occupation and I am quite sure I can make hamburger out of it. And to all you defenders, you are just giving this poster what he wants - attention. Do us all a favour and end it now.

Sorry to pee in your cheerios.

I don't despise teachers, that's for sure. I certainly recognize their contribution.

This thread is a splinter thread from Yuri's teacher thread about teachers pensions and the Ontario gov't being on the hook.

My only knock against teachers is that I get so tired of their nonstop whining / strikes / job actions / taking out commercial time on the air, etc. They seem to whine more than most and when I compare how I am treated by my employer vs. how teachers are treated, I think they are doing pretty good. Very good. I have a hard time understanding why they bitch nonstop.

I was curious about public perception. And public perception, at least on this board is that teachers are better off than most. (by over 60% if you look at the numbers.)

You can argue that it's bashing, but ask yourself, why is that? I mean, try starting a similar thread about nurses say, or pilots, or accountants, or engineers, or even doctors. Betcha don't get the same response.

Start your own poll, "Which profession features the biggest whiners?"

1. Doctors
2. Lawyers
3. Engineers
4. Accountants
5. Teachers
6. Nurses

etc.

I wonder who will win?

Whether you like it or not, public perception towards teachers is not altogether favourable. So again, ask yourself why? Sometimes, there is something there.
 
james t kirk said:
Based on Yuri's thread, I am curious to measure public opinion on teacher's remuneration vs. the effort they have to expend in their occupation.

The question is:

Do teachers have it made in the shade, or are they justly compensated for their efforts, or are they underpaid and over worked and under appreciated.

I speak from some experience as there are 4 teachers who are close relatives of mine. They do have a hard job BUT get 2 months vacation, the main problem I have with them is they don't realize the problems others like myself have in the real business world.
 
Just a point or two.....

Sorry to pee in your cheerios.

I don't despise teachers, that's for sure. I certainly recognize their contribution.

This thread is a splinter thread from Yuri's teacher thread about teachers pensions and the Ontario gov't being on the hook.

My only knock against teachers is that I get so tired of their nonstop whining / strikes / job actions / taking out commercial time on the air, etc. They seem to whine more than most and when I compare how I am treated by my employer vs. how teachers are treated, I think they are doing pretty good. Very good. I have a hard time understanding why they bitch nonstop.


Well first off I don’t think there is really an issue about you urinating in my breakfast cereal so let’s dispense with that.

I am pleased that somebody recognizes the contributions of teachers and I applaud your generosity of spirit. Not once in this entire thread has it been mentioned though that contributions to education are not only made by teachers. Some of the most influential contributions come from principals, and school boards who set their own brand of policy at their respective levels. Some of the most dramatic influences have their authorship with the Ministry of Education. The most devastating negative influences on the education of our children have their authorship from within this venerable albeit Ivory Tower organization. Consider the Whole Language initiative as a case in point. If memory serves me correctly some of the whining which came from teachers was against this harebrained piece of idiocy. A volume could be written about the wonderful job many teachers have done trying to teach in spite of this. Yet the agents I mentioned above seem to get away scot free.
The pension issue is another matter. At one time the pension was almost entirely controlled by the Ontario government. The entire fund was invested in Ontario government bonds. The returns were less than spectacular. With the advent of the Rae government the union approached with a request that the fund be made into a separate entity and professionals hired to manage it. There were advantages for both sides. The amazing subsequent growth of the fund caught the notice of the public. Certainly it is now a benefit to be envied by all. But in the end analysis the teachers should be congratulated on their success not denigrated. But their success in no way abrogates the original relationship the Ontario government has with the fund.
In terms of job action it is unfortunate for them that teachers perform a service which so completely touches the lives of almost all the people of a province. The optics are not as innocuous as for the employees of say, Xerox. It certainly amplifies any action in the eyes of the public.
A second issue involves initiatives by the Harris government to target major public groups in the service sector to achieve promised budgetary cutbacks. Doctors, with an excellent bargaining position, were ultimately able to prevail. Nurses chose a more subdued approach. Their profession subsequently suffered to the point of a pronounced job dissatisfaction and decline. They are still trying to recover. Teachers chose to fight in the public forum. Again such a path makes for poor optics. The fight got ugly, not guaranteed to arouse sympathy among a public whose tax dollar pays the tune. Harris was no fool. He just couldn’t lose public backing on this one.
Notwithstanding the fact that like in all professions there are those who do not belong it is my belief that all of the above are largely responsible for the negative public image of teachers. In addition to this there are other factors. At one time there were excesses in terms of discipline still fresh in the memories of the older members of our society. Yet the schools were seen as one of the major influences in the socialization of our children. In the more litigious atmosphere of our society the influence of teachers in the socialization of children has been greatly reduced. Society by and large, I feel, has a sense of betrayal in that respect. In light of the fact that many parents have abrogated the responsibility for raising their children, some parents may feel that the system is failing them. Others, buying into the pop psych crap about the kinder gentler way don’t understand that the relationship between one on one is different than that between one on thirty. Such parents often fail to discriminate between being a friend to their child and being a pal. They invariably insist on the same approach on the part of the teacher. The policy of integration is another issue. Children or teenagers who have (to cite one of many examples) been identified as “extreme behaviour” cases are now kept in the classroom and fail to receive the ‘necessary’ intervention they require. Having an EA, if one is available does not begin to address the issue adequately. I will leave it to your imagination as to how that may change the dynamic within the class. And the stories children bring home can’t help but influence public perception.
I am sure I have not covered all of the issues but a more comprehensive treatment is beyond the scope of this forum. So if you wonder why I feel many here are “shooting from the lip”, that is why. The whole discussion up to now has suffered from an appalling lack of first, fact, second, objectivity and third, logical premise. Without these, it does teachers a great disservice and, second, definitely fails to rise above the level of “bashing.” IMHO educated people should refrain from being a part of any of the threads here related to this topic unless they are able to contribute in a more enlightened fashion. I don't feel this is an unreasonable expectation on my part.
 
Separate thread

This is a good contribution to the Thread, Mr. Regular Guy. Thanks for posting it. Sincerely, Jon .

Thank you Jon. On reflection seeing that this topic has spawned a few threads, I am going to copy my comments and open a new thread. A more comprehensive treatment needs its own thread.
 
KWI said:
Do your fucking job or let someone else who will do it right have the job. {not you directly}

Now you can go on about what you do and about how bad all the parents are in your area, but the responsiblity for teaching still lies with you regardless of whether the parents are involed or not. You decided to be a teacher knowing full well what the hours would be, what you would hve to do for your pay. {again not you directly}

KWI

Unfortunately, extracurricular stuff is optional and therefore not part of any teacher's job.

You're right you shouldn't get short changed but that's unfortunately what happens with limited resources. It's too bad more teachers at your school don't volunteer their time but realize that the key word is voluntary.

I think earlier detailed posts by me have come across in the wrong way. They were intended to specifically point out exactly why a 5 hour work day is a fallacy. But perhaps in all those words and numbers I've lost some people along the way.

Look as for teaching and parents...... for me to learn to read, write and do math it meant time at home with my mom and dad at the dinner table. Without that time I wouldn't be where I am today.

Also, knowing that I'd get my ass kicked if I got in trouble at school helped me to do well in school.

Even look at the effects of children who lack sufficient parental contact or supervision.

Educating a child takes a lot more than the 75 minutes of class time. That's why a lot of teachers also provide extra help (especiaally if the parent can't). But at the end of the day if a kid chooses not to come to extra help there are way more laws protecting him than me if I decide to drag his/her ass into a classroom and slap a pencil in their hand. HOWEVER, a parent CAN do those things.

I'm more than willing to do my job..... which is to teach but my hands are tied when it comes to forcing a kid to come for the extra help that they need.

Basically my job is to teach the kid not chase/drag them if it was I would happily do that as well.

Sorry but parents can't wash their hands of this. I have the kids for 75 min parents hopefully have them for a lot more time than that. The best scenarios for turning a failing kid around is when I have the parent's support.