death penalty justified?

China in the days long gone by (maybe???) would execute prisoners (whether they were guilty or not is debatable) and then bill the surviving family members for the bullet and costs.

If this happened in Toronto, Mayor Tax Me would of course tax you and then charge you $0.05 for any bags that were used :D
 
5hummer said:
I don't believe in the death penalty -- it's just an easy out.

I believe criminals should suffer for their crimes -- put in a white room with pictures of their victims and water-boarded tortures for the rest of their life.

So which is it then? Is the death penalty humane compared to not implementing it? That's just sadistic.
 
binderman said:
So which is it then? Is the death penalty humane compared to not implementing it. That's just sadistic.

Humane isn't a word I would use but it is a lesser punishment then life in prison.
 
papasmerf said:
No

It is beyond some peoples ability to understand that if you kill a person during or as a result of a crime you commit you murdered them


It seems you have little understanding of the concepts of applying actus reus & mens rea to specific crimes instead of copping to merely lumping everything together.

Considering the source this lack of understanding is hardly surprising.

Seriously... your world must be so simple that it looks like a 30s era cartoon.
 
themexi said:
It seems you have little understanding of the concepts of applying actus reus & mens rea to specific crimes instead of copping to merely lumping everything together.

Considering the source this lack of understanding is hardly surprising.

Seriously... your world must be so simple that it looks like a 30s era cartoon.

we could simplify justice if lawyers were not allowed to be judges.
 
Brill said:
If by "simplify" you mean dumb down to a 30s era cartoon, I agree.


No

By simplify I mean allow justice to be what it was meant to be. The rule of law applied and not held hostage by expedience.
 
gramage said:
But typically when your actions are not intended to cause death that's manslaughter which does not get punished with the death penalty.

I'm against the death penalty because I'm an atheist. To me when you kill someone they stop feeling anything, and that's not as severs a punishment to me forcing them to live a long life in a cell isolated from society. Death is only an increased punishment if you believe your sending them to hell, something even religions differ on and not a great way to set policy.
i have to agree in this case ,but there are some people that really do deserve the death penalty( see thread on manson family)
 
Sukdeep said:
Capital punishment is only punishment if the offender values his/her own life.

If you accept that capital punishment should only be applied in the most heinous cases, does it also not stand to logic that someone who commits gruesome and offensive crimes probably has little regard for life?

You mean the life of others.
 
I know a lot of people who say things like, “Do the crime, do the time,” and have no problem with making “Bubba” jokes.

The problem with the existence of Bubbas in the penal system, is that not all crimes are equivalent.

By Bubba, by the way, I mean the sort of human monster who needs a state sponsored execution.

I agree that if you steal my car, two years in jail is exactly what you deserve.

But not two years of torture at the hands of sexual psychopaths. And that’s what happens to your cousin’s kid, if he screws up on the path to adulthood, shoplifts once too often, or graduates to car theft.

Every one of us is guilty of something, from bawdy house violations, to tax fiddles, to drug violations, or maybe ‘blowing over’ while driving, something that could land us in the bucket, but so far-so-good, right?

Sorry, but we’re all just one bit of bad luck away from going to jail, and meeting this Bubba character we’re all so amused by on the outside.

And yes, sometimes innocent people and good people end up in jail. It could happen to any of us, and to guys on an Escort Review Board, more probably than the average guy.

Somebody slaps your girlfriend, and boom, you’re jailed for assault. Or maybe someone cries rape or assault on you out of a clear blue sky. A second of inattention while driving becomes vehicular manslaughter. Whatever.

Two years of torture, for stealing a car, or for any of the above crimes, is wrong, cruel and unusual punishment. As Johnny Fever of WKRP said, “As ideas go… that’s… Iranian!”

Most people here, who have never met the Bubbas of the world, can’t imagine how evil they are. Most people here probably don’t even believe in evil, except as an abstract, and imagine that psychopaths, and naively suppose they can be “cured” or rehabbed, if we throw enough money and love at them.

If you want to get an idea of who these death row guys are, go to “Dead man eating.com and see the last meals picked by inmates before riding the needle, and have a look at who they were and why they are there. Almost without exception, they are totally soulless, vicious, eat your liver, rape your children, torturing maniacs. They kill old ladies, for small change, and cut them up for fun.

Read about these MS13 gang guys to take an example. Kids are lining up to join. They’re turning them away in droves. And these guys aren’t even psychopaths. Just evil for evil’s sake.

In prison, they make prison a living hell for the rest of the prison population. They run around raping and torturing guys like us.

There is no way to keep other inmates safe from them. So we should absolutely cull the human population of a few of them, whenever we can, just to be sensible. Sorry, but even sensible animal lovers seem to accept that if a bear kills and eats a camper, we “put it down” because that bear has proven that we can’t share the planet with him/her.

Capital punishment is expensive, but worth it.
 
i dont know rob and this may be extremely simplistic, but i am not able to wrap my mind around the fact that somehow we as a society are justified in making a decision to wipe a human being off the face of the earth. havent we as a society failed these individuals to some extent? its the easy way out. the criminals activity and behavior is a result of the combination of "nature" and "nurture". sure most of these individuals are beyond any help but i think we still have some obligation in that regard.
like i said i think killing them is easy and i would consider it a backward evolutionary step.
 
Sukdeep said:
I did not specify whether it was first or second degree.

But generally speaking, first degree murder is homicide done with intent (i.e., planned and deliberate).

In Canada, second degree murder is any murder that is not first degree.

Arson typically isn't a heat of the moment kind of thing (not like an argument). It is usually a deliberate action. If you accept that premise, intent to injure is not a big leap.


that is utter nonsense. unless you can prove the fire was set with intent to kill or injure a SPECIFIC person, it is second degree murder. Absurd to execute someone for that.
 
I'm against the death penalty, as it makes us all murders and requires someone to do the killing. It also unfairly traumatizes the family of the accused who have done no crime. What I WOULD condone, is a life sentence and providing the convicted with a suicide pill if they chose to relive socity of their presence.
 
nottyboi said:
that is utter nonsense. unless you can prove the fire was set with intent to kill or injure a SPECIFIC person, it is second degree murder. Absurd to execute someone for that.
Actually, in many common law jurisdictions (including the U.S), felony murder (when you kill someone while committing another crime, whether or not you had planned to kill someone in advance) is first degree murder. Normally, the underlying crime is something like bank robbery (BTW, in many jurisdictions, if you commit the felony with someone else, you don’t even have to be the one who pulls the trigger for the felony murder rule to apply). However, in this case, the court must have decided that arson was a felony that qualified and therefore the felony rule could apply.
BTW, do not assume that I am a supporter of the felony murder rule. I am only pointing out that with it intent is not necessary for someone to be guilty of first degree murder.
 
Sukdeep said:
I have never heard this argument before. But I thought that was what the different levels of detention facilities were for. I'm terribly naive.

Evidently.

The problem in North America is space, because so many people are bagged up for absurd drug offenses. In Ontario between Milhaven and Kingston combined, we only have room for about 1000 maximum time guys, to keep guys like Bernardo, safe from guys like Bubba.

But the Bubba's run wild in our overcrowded medium security prisons, where among other problems, corruption by and intimidation of guards is system wide.

To get a little window into the gang situation in Canadian prisons have a look at gang distribution stats here: http://www.insideprison.com/prison-gangs-canada.asp

What you fail to recognize is that career recidivists like the Bubba's of the world, often reoffend for lesser crimes than the one that they were convicted of, served 14 years of a life sentence for, and then released, despite the fact that any normal-thinking society would have and should have simply thrown him out the air lock door and into space.

I just read about such a one recently. A native kid, dealt life's worst hand imaginable. Fetal alcohol syndrome, domestic abuse, blah blah. So he turns into a sexual psychopath,/serial predator. Incurable. Corrections Canada experts say he's guaranteed to reoffend - no doubt about it - but he's served the required two-thirds of his seven year sentence for a six-hour torture rape, so we toss him loose instead of into a wood chipper.

How often do we hear about these guys?

Here's a primer. http://cancrime.com/labels/sex offender.html
 
Unless there SOLID UNSUBTANTIATED PROOF of guilt OR confession I have a hard time with this due to the DNA factors and innocent men being freed after years in jail.
 
spankingman said:
Unless there SOLID UNSUBTANTIATED PROOF of guilt OR confession I have a hard time with this due to the DNA factors and innocent men being freed after years in jail.

Well, me too, actually.
I don't know about the USA, but I think that back in the bad-old, death penalty days in Canada, if there was any doubt, even with a guilty verdict, the penalty wasn't applied, based on the "better to let 100 guilty men go free than to condemn an innocent man" principle.

And usually, it took a long, long, time regardless, with multiple appeals going on for years and years.
 
Sukdeep said:
So some a$$hole who detonates a bomb in a crowded market is only guilty of second degree murder?

Go back to your law school and ask for a refund....


Well ok, his intent was to kill masses of people, then yes, it is first degree murder as well. But if he intended to blow up a building, it was supposed to be empty and someone decided to stay late.. that would be second degree murder.
 
nottyboi said:
Well ok, his intent was to kill masses of people, then yes, it is first degree murder as well. But if he intended to blow up a building, it was supposed to be empty and someone decided to stay late.. that would be second degree murder.

Firefighters who have to fight these arson fires feel differently. The IAFF (The International Association of Firefighters) has mandated for years to make an arson that takes the life of a responding FF a death-penalty, murder beef.
They have been successful in many US states, when one of their members gets, well, murdered.

FF's try not to get killed, but when they do, they, their families, friends, and fellow firefighters take it personally.

Go figure.
 
Robinto said:
Firefighters who have to fight these arson fires feel differently. The IAFF (The International Association of Firefighters) has mandated for years to make an arson that takes the life of a responding FF a death-penalty, murder beef.
They have been successful in many US states, when one of their members gets, well, murdered.

FF's try not to get killed, but when they do, they, their families, friends, and fellow firefighters take it personally.

Go figure.


Well put !!! Their job is tough enough these days with meth labs,grow ops etc PLUS regular fires etc

A proud FF Dad