Crime and Punishment and Sex Work

JakeSims420420

Active member
Apr 9, 2023
115
110
43
This is probably the weirdest post I've ever made but here goes:

I have always wondered what escorts/erotic masseuses think of Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment. Obviously, the majority of sex workers have probably not read it, because most people don't read Russian literature unless they have to. But for the ones who have read it who work in the sex industry, I wonder what they think of the character of Sonya, the very young streetwalker. She was my favourite in the novel because she seemed like the moral core of the novel (self-sacrificing for her loved ones, faithful, etc.). But I can also see how she could be read as a hooker-with-a-heart stereotype. In Lectures on Russian Literature, Nabokov also complained about one scene where Sonya is with Raskolnikov, the axe-murderer protagonist, and it's described something like, "the harlot and the murderer read the Bible by candlelight". Nabokov argued that this was drawing a false moral equivalency between them: Sonya was pressured into prostitution by her stepmother to support her family, whereas Raskolnikov chose to murder someone for money to support himself. I guess I just wonder what sex workers think.

Sorry mods if this is too pretentious and odd a question!
 
  • Like
Reactions: alwilm

that6969

Well-known member
Nov 18, 2024
269
319
63
LMAO...I read that book a few years back. Great read. Can't believe this topic exists. Back in the early 2000s we read Catcher in the Rye in high school that also would lead to some interesting questions. Weird topic haha. I wonder how many SPs actually read such a great book.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JakeSims420420

that6969

Well-known member
Nov 18, 2024
269
319
63
Madame Bovary was also I great read I did around the same time as reading that book. You should read that if you haven't. Just a suggestion.
 

JakeSims420420

Active member
Apr 9, 2023
115
110
43
Madame Bovary was also I great read I did around the same time as reading that book. You should read that if you haven't. Just a suggestion.
I'll check it out. I've heard of it but honestly haven't read much French literature. I went through a Tolstoyevsky phase in my twenties. Anna Karenina is another interesting book about adultery if you haven't read it.
 

that6969

Well-known member
Nov 18, 2024
269
319
63
Heard of that, but haven't read it. I believe it's a long read. I did read War and Peace once again around the same timeframe when I got into novels. I took a break from novels, but should get back into them. Great way to pass the time than just watching tv.
 

Ahri

Your Asian Escape
Apr 21, 2021
557
1,228
93
LMAO...I read that book a few years back. Great read. Can't believe this topic exists. Back in the early 2000s we read Catcher in the Rye in high school that also would lead to some interesting questions. Weird topic haha. I wonder how many SPs actually read such a great book.
For me we read How to kill a mockingbird and 1984 😂 I still remember forcing my self to read it in English class 🥶
 

Robert Mugabe

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2017
9,726
6,757
113
This is probably the weirdest post I've ever made but here goes:

I have always wondered what escorts/erotic masseuses think of Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment. Obviously, the majority of sex workers have probably not read it, because most people don't read Russian literature unless they have to. But for the ones who have read it who work in the sex industry, I wonder what they think of the character of Sonya, the very young streetwalker. She was my favourite in the novel because she seemed like the moral core of the novel (self-sacrificing for her loved ones, faithful, etc.). But I can also see how she could be read as a hooker-with-a-heart stereotype. In Lectures on Russian Literature, Nabokov also complained about one scene where Sonya is with Raskolnikov, the axe-murderer protagonist, and it's described something like, "the harlot and the murderer read the Bible by candlelight". Nabokov argued that this was drawing a false moral equivalency between them: Sonya was pressured into prostitution by her stepmother to support her family, whereas Raskolnikov chose to murder someone for money to support himself. I guess I just wonder what sex workers think.

Sorry mods if this is too pretentious and odd a question!
I enjoyed the cat and mouse interplay between Raskolnikov and Porfiry Petrovich.


pretentious.jpg
 

Cholla

Well-known member
Jun 5, 2020
1,086
481
83
For me we read How to kill a mockingbird and 1984 😂 I still remember forcing my self to read it in English class 🥶
Hi Ahri. You call yourself an “Asian escape”. I always wondered that we don’t know any of Asian literature. I guess, European and American literature are not known by Asian people. True or false?
 

JakeSims420420

Active member
Apr 9, 2023
115
110
43
Hi Ahri. You call yourself an “Asian escape”. I always wondered that we don’t know any of Asian literature. I guess, European and American literature are not known by Asian people. True or false?
There's a lot of quality Asian literature! Have you read Haruki Murakami? He frequently references Western literature and music in his books.
 

Cholla

Well-known member
Jun 5, 2020
1,086
481
83
There's a lot of quality Asian literature! Have you read Haruki Murakami? He frequently references Western literature and music in his books.
I am sure there are lots if great Asian literature! I haven’t read any, unfortunately. It’s too bad that we don’t know much about it.
 

FelixKrull

Member
Jul 8, 2015
72
5
8
Thank you! I heard his name before, but never read anything, unfortunately. I need to improve my knowledge of Asian literature, I am sure girls will appreciate that. 🙂
Read Kafka on the Shore, its not too long and is really good
 

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
40,244
7,559
113
This gets my vole for thread of the year. Noticed that Roberto enjoys a good foppery.

I actually slogged my way through The Brothers Karamazov. Dostoevsky is like Joseph Conrad on steroids, after Kara I never wanted to read another of his novels. There is a BBC mini-series on Crime and Punishment starring John Hurt as Raskolnikov. Been so long since I saw, cant remember it.

Why did I read The Brothers Karamazov? The film version had The Great Shat as the youngest brother Alexi, that was enough for me. lol

 

Robert Mugabe

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2017
9,726
6,757
113
This gets my vole for thread of the year. Noticed that Roberto enjoys a good foppery.

I actually slogged my way through The Brothers Karamazov. Dostoevsky is like Joseph Conrad on steroids, after Kara I never wanted to read another of his novels. There is a BBC mini-series on Crime and Punishment starring John Hurt as Raskolnikov. Been so long since I saw, cant remember it.

Why did I read The Brothers Karamazov? The film version had The Great Shat as the youngest brother Alexi, that was enough for me. lol

I actually read a Joseph Conrad novel from beginning to end without understanding a single fucking word. Although Polish, I believe, he was said to be a master of the English language. Lord Jim, I think it was. Another one that failed me, or I failed it was James Joyce's Ulysses. Haven't a fucking clue what it was about.
So much for literature. Maybe I'll check out woodworking.
 
Toronto Escorts