Could independent quebec survive

You base this dictum on what evidence or facts? What am I doing asking you for facts or evidence? I'm not expecting a creditable answer. Then again, I also believe in Karma.

Dictum. I read a very interesting observation, at least I thought it was.

Liberals.

First they were Liberals and practiced tolerance.

Then they change and became haughty and arrogant.

Next Liberals started to issue dictum at will.

I believe this is true. Actually the TERB user is subjected to it every time he/she logs in.
 
I don't think the PQ truly want to leave Canada , l as a political entity is really all they have , if they were to get independence, the people of Quebec would tire of them soon enough and another party will come to power.

As for them not allowing us to use their airspace, well Canada could do the same to them.

Marois would be immortalized forever as the mother of a nation. Don't be too quick to think she doesn't fantasize about it. Her top cabinet members would be remembered through the names of schools, streets, and parks for hundreds of years, long after everyone had forgotten who Stephen Harper was.
 
Dictum. I read a very interesting observation, at least I thought it was.

Liberals.

First they were Liberals and practiced tolerance.

Then they change and became haughty and arrogant.

Next Liberals started to issue dictum at will.

I believe this is true. Actually the TERB user is subjected to it every time he/she logs in.

Notice that LH didn't support his dictum with facts or evidence, standard SOP. That's why it's a dictum. He just brays and disappears. Haughty and arrogance is not limited to just Liberals. Just read some of LH's longer posts.
 
At this point- they would not be allowed to separate- it would be civil war. The feds would be forced to go in and take over- canada cannot loose its most important import and export shipping port. CANNOT HAPPEN.
 
Quebec reminds me of the fat chick you talk to when you're being a wingman for your buddy. Then she acts all "Im too hot for you, dont try to pick me up" and you go "listen fatass, im just distracting you while my buddy is feeling up your friend"...
 
also, let them leave, then when they come crawling back we give them new rules. Like no more french signs/distinct society etc. Like we do with our ex's. I say let them go as long as we have the balls to tell them theres a new sherrif in town if they want back in. We've kissed their ass long enough so they wouldnt leave. If they end up leaving, fuck that shit. Its Canada time bitches. multi lingual and you're the same as everyone else.
 
The whole point of separation is to have Quebecers looking up at this pie in the sky dream of having their own nation so they do not see all the graft that is going on right under their noses. This is why all the corruption has surfaced in Quebec. As separatism waned, people focused their attention on other things and discovered what was really happening. Can you imagine how rich the Quebec politicians will get negotiating for a separate Quebec?
 
Pretty similar with what's happening with Scotland. They would like to keep the British pound but they are being told that's not going to happen. Never understood why people want to separate (bascs, scottish, quebecois), it 's not they are psrt of some empire...
 
Sounds like she wants the divorce and still wants to live in the same house, share the dog, the car, the cottage, share the expenses and keep the joint bank account, but wants to be able to go out and fuck someone else....let them try going on their own. However when they go, they go, no common currency, no shared defense, no more federal transfers of funds, more anything that costs us money!
 
Toronto overtook Montreal as the biggest city after 1985 referundum because big companies moved their offices, and people too. Its the fear of independence that screwed Quebec economically, not the actual I dependence. If they actually had separated from Canada in 1985, I think they might have been better.
 
Toronto overtook Montreal as the biggest city after 1985 referundum because big companies moved their offices, and people too. Its the fear of independence that screwed Quebec economically, not the actual I dependence. If they actually had separated from Canada in 1985, I think they might have been better.

It happened earlier than '85. My immediate family was part of the exodus from Quebec back in 1972, lines of armoured vehicles were seen going down the highway. The FLQ success/failure didn't help the times.
 
IMO if Quebec ever separated and were cut off from Federal transfer/equalization payments, welfare etc, there would be a massive collective "holy shit!" moment from Quebecers. As mentioned their lifestyle would deteriate quickly. I then believe they would be trying as quickly as possible to rape and pillage their natural resource base in an effort to try to prop up lost revenue. They would piss off the environmentalists as they fuck up the environment BUT would be a necessity in order to try and maintain any assemblance of pre-separation life.