Copyright infringement....should I pay?

I work as a semi-professional photographer, and this is a frequent topic in our industry... although from the other side of the coin...

First off, ignore. As mentioned, it's a demand letter... essentially an invoice. As long as you are only viewing and not distributing the thing, there's not really any law being broken that isn't being broken by about a zillion people every day already. I stick images on-line all the time, with the expectation that people will look at them, download them and perhaps use them for their personal use. It's part of the way I market myself. Now if someone managed to download a high-res version of an image and started to make prints and sell them, or use it in some commercial way, then that's a whole different story.

All of this assumes of course that you didn't hack into someone's secure server and actually steal content.

So "technically" what you did (and we all do!) is illegal perhaps, but private parties don't levy fines. They send invoices. In order for you to be fined, they would need to take you to court and win a judgement. You are going to get a few more letters before it comes to that, so judge yourself accordingly.

And change ISPs. Apparently they misunderstand their job...
 
And change ISPs
This is key.

If enough people quit their ISP then they'll start to realize going after people is futile, not to mention bad for business
 
This is key.

If enough people quit their ISP then they'll start to realize going after people is futile, not to mention bad for business

All Canadian ISPs are required by Canadian Federal copyright law to forward the copyright infringement notice.

But in doing so, they do not disclose your information to the party giving notice. So until you open your yap, the party sending the demand letter does not know your identity. Only your IP address.

To get your identity, they would have to bring a motion for a Court Order to force the ISP to disclose the name of the account holder associated with that IP address. Or, they can get it by you responding.

So if you respond, they will then know your identity. Until then they have nothing and the paper is worthless..
 
Thanks Schlong, thats good to know
 
If you pay the settlement. They will have your credit card info and thus from that, they have your name and address. Plus, they don't even send you a receipt or any proof that you paid the settlement. They will also continue to send you more notices often stating that you downloaded the same file twice (even if you already paid it and you know for sure you only downloaded it once) knowing that you will pay again. So all your doing is feeding the troll.
 
Write a letter how you have no idea what they are talking about.You surely do nothing like that.Run said paper letter from ass crack to cock tip.All the way around the horn.Place it in an envelope with no return address and mail it to said U.S Firm.If there's any luck there you'll make half their office sick from your ass crack....tear up anything else that shows up......I don't steal....I sample....P Diddy taught me that.