Contractor advice: sloping floor?

wetnose

Gamahucher
Nov 14, 2006
2,442
0
36
So I recently visited a buddy of mine in the Danforth area. When I was in the kitchen I noticed an odd sensation as I walked across it....then I laid a bottle on the floor, then gently nudged it....and it rolled down to a pillar 12 feet away from me. The previous owner had opened up the first floor and the whole second floor basically rests on this one pillar. The pillar is an ornamental pillar but is showing toothpick wide cracks running up the center of it.

He's lived there for the last 5 years and was aware of it initially, but said it hasn't gotten any worse, so he isn't worried. Plus there are no other cracks in the house.

What could be wrong and potentially....how much could it cost to fix? Also..who's a good contractor to take it on?

Thanks in advance....
 
Last edited:
So I recently visited a buddy of mine in the Danforth area. When I was in the kitchen I noticed an odd sensation as I walked across it....then I laid a bottle on the floor, then gently nudged it....and it rolled down to a pillar 12 feet away from me. The previous owner had opened up the space and the whole internal space basically rests on this one pillar. The pillar is an ornamental pillar but is showing toothpick wide cracks running up the center of it.

He's lived there for the last 5 years and was aware of it initially, but said it hasn't gotten any worse, so he isn't worried. Plus there are no other cracks in the house.

What could be wrong and potentially....how much could it cost to fix? Also..who's a good contractor to take it on?

Thanks in advance....
Mike Holmes!
 
Like he said, don't panic. Old houses—in the Danforth area where I live, many are anywhere from just over to just under a hundred years old—are only very rarely still plumb and level, but quite likely still solid. IF they haven't been screwed with. Although olden-days guys built cruder than we do (measuring devices were expensive) they built with better wood and more of it because they used first-growth, full-dimension lumber and put in lotsa partition walls. We have engineered everything down to minimums and like those small narrow houses opened up to the outside walls with no partitions, which can be problematic.

It's unclear whether the pillar you describe is upstairs in the kitchen, supporting the floor(s) above, or in the basement supporting everything, as wetnose deals with. But the basic principle is this: The weight (many tonnes) of your house has to be supported all the way from the tip of the roof to the earth underneath it. Any time the supports are not stacked one directly above the other, there must be a 'bridge' that's adequate to transfer the weight sideways to the supports below it.

The heavy timbers that support the floor (floor joists) do that, but they can be overloaded. Generally they can only span/bridge about 14 to 16 feet and for lotsa narrow old houses that'll take them from outside wall to outside wall and carry all the loads from snow on the roof and the floors in between all the way to the solid foundation. They will sag a tad, they're only wood and they're old wood at that.

But they do need support if the spans are greater, the loads unusual (like an oversized castiron bathtub) or the sag is intolerable. If there's a wall upstairs running along a single joist, it'll load it overmuch and there'll be overmuch sag (walls running across over many joists split their load). At those points there needs to be support below, and then support below that all the way to the earth. If there is support in the basement as wetnose described, and someone removed whatever was between it and the second floor, there might well be a serious, slow problem developing.

The cracks in new work, like the pillar, suggest* that the house has moved since it was installed, which is not good. But is that because there's inadequate support below, or inadequate support overhead? And what does 'fixing' it mean to a guy who bought it as is and lived with it? A couple of $60 telescoping steel posts and some 2x12 pads, one post in the basement and one upstairs might 'fix' it. It would be solid and safe, but the cosmetics and making it permanent would cost.

Use wetnose's ballpark for a basement-quality job on whichever floor, and budget for both. Start calling contractors who your neighbours have had good results from and pump them for insight and info. Your friend wants all the expertise there is going. They'll come and look, and talk and estimate for free.

Get them to quote the structural fix and the cosmetics afterwards separately. It's the cosmetics he can go cheap on or delay. Talk about what's involved in levelling the sags. It can be done, though it will require ceiling-removal below, serious plaster damage will occur in unpredictable places, and plumbing and electrical may need re-routing. But the talk will be instructive.

Do not take the lowest price because it's the lowest; this is the structure of your house. You want a guy who you trust to be as solid as you want it to be. Someone with a business and a rep that he cares about as much as you care about the house.

*Or maybe the crack was just bad drywall work, and new lumber shrinking. That's movement too, but inconsequential.
 
You need a structural engineer, not a contractor. Odds are that the structure has been compromised by some fool "opening it up" in the past. People just think that they can knock out columns, or load bearing walls, etc. etc. and come up with all kinds of fucked up ideas.

Hire an Engineer to do an investigation and come up with a proper solution to code. Most Contractors don't even own a building code (yet they run around spouting code this and code that).

As Mike Holmes would say, "Do it right"

As far as what Engineer to hire

1. Yellow pages under "Engineers - consulting"

2. Halcrow Yolles used to have a small business unit.

3. Mike Holmes website:

http://makeitright.ca/Mike_Holmes_Online/mikes_contractor_list.php


You want the Engineer to do a structural analysis of the house, determine the issues, propose solutions, then provide you with sealed drawings and specifications.

You then apply for a bulding permit.

You then go out and give the drawings and specs to 3 or 4 good contractors and ask them to give you prices based on the engineered drawings. You then pick your contractor, check his references, etc.

While you're in there, you might probably consider doing some reno work because now will be the time.

Anyone who tells you any differently than the above is incorrect and doesn't know what they are talking about.
 
He is right. You may well find a contractor who will tell you the same thing as the engineer, but the engineer's advice attaches his professional standing to it. And he's got more to lose than the contractor in that regard.

But the contractors will come, look and talk just on the prospect of getting the work. You'll still want one in the end, and you'll want to be as knowledgeable as you can get to be the farther you go, because—unless the someone calls the Building Dept in to condemn the house—only you decide in the end. So I'd still get busy interviewing. And start a notebook.
 
if the floor is concrete, there are tons of guys in the GTA who will put overlayment and make it even. when it comes to hairline or toothpick cracks. the best patch i've encountered is epoxy floor patch. again, tons sold in the GTA.