Comic book collectors

oral.com

Sapere Aude, Carpe Diem
Jul 21, 2004
921
535
93
Toronto
I need some advice from the collective. I have a very large comic book collection that I’d like to liquidate.
Most are comics from the bronze age a few from the silver age. The vast majority are in excellent condition, only read once, bagged and stored.
I have not had them CGC certified.

I obviously don’t want to give them away and I am aware some are quite valuable, Any advice would be appreciated.
 

LTO_3

Well-known member
Aug 27, 2004
998
720
93
Niagara Region
I'd be inclined to take them to at least one or two reputable stores that deal in comic books and have them give you an overall appraisal including if any or all of them should be CGC certified since that will help boost prices, especially for more rare comics.

LTO_3
 
  • Like
Reactions: y2kmark

Knuckle Ball

Well-known member
Oct 15, 2017
7,318
3,443
113
I’d unload the less valuable comics at your local comic book store.

You might want to consider selling the more valuable comics on eBay or some other online site if you think you can do better than what the store offers.

Maybe do some research online and see what other comparable comics sell for.

Good luck.
 

xix

Time Zone Traveller
Jul 27, 2002
4,175
1,407
113
La la land
Well it looks like this is going to be a full time job for a month.

Create an Excel sheet a tab for each series you have and one tab for miscellenous. Maybe a column of cost, date purchase, year release and title. Not in this order.
Youtube it.

Ebay or amazon or where ever there may be a website (facebook) that sell comics and see what the popularity is and prices.
Go from there.

When I unloaded mine collection, I was glad the guy took it.
Last I checked at the comic store, I heard Star Wars and Transformers were the top notch collectors, even toys, every thing else were way below or a waste of the travel time and finding someone to buy it. Lego is with Star Wars.

Talk to the comic book store sellers and ask what is a collectible now a days, ask about SW and Trans. See what they tell you and gauge from there.
 

onomatopoeia

Bzzzzz.......Doink
Jul 3, 2020
21,251
17,340
113
Cabbagetown
If your collection is worth $5K or more, consider contacting Heritage Auctions, [HA(dot)com] by e-mail. For inventories of that size or larger, they would send their Toronto representative to you for an appraisal. HA wouldn't buy your collection; they would look to find a buyer or buyers for either the full collection, or individual lots of one or more items, for a percentage commission on sold items.

Here's a sample link from a recent auction:


I've never bought anything from them, nor sold anything to them, but I have had a number of e-mail conversations with a couple of their reps, and I'm on their e-mail mailing list. They handle auctions for all types of collectibles, including comic books, original comic book art, trading cards, video games, action figures, etc.

For vintage video games/ action figures, they're probably only interested in items which are still in the original packaging.
 

Jenesis

Fabulously Full Figured
Supporting Member
Jul 14, 2020
9,334
9,359
113
North Whitby Incalls
www.jenesis.ch
Like any collection, you need to do a lot of research on each item before you sell. You have to research the best places and not all places are good for the lot. Only pieces of it.

So do your research. It will take time to unload of them. Get some of the certified and sell personally.
 

MrPrezident

A Big Man For a Big Job
May 30, 2002
1,134
439
83
Red House over yonder.
Are R Crumb Mr Natural, Flakey Foont comics from the hippy era collector's items now? If you live long enough a lot of what you have accumulated can become antiques.

I still have stacks of vinyl music albums from that 60s era and a few good porno tapes from the Ginger Lynn Christy Cannon 80s. One person's junk is another person's treasure.
 

oral.com

Sapere Aude, Carpe Diem
Jul 21, 2004
921
535
93
Toronto
Are R Crumb Mr Natural, Flakey Foont comics from the hippy era collector's items now? If you live long enough a lot of what you have accumulated can become antiques.

I still have stacks of vinyl music albums from that 60s era and a few good porno tapes from the Ginger Lynn Christy Cannon 80s. One person's junk is another person's treasure.
I still have a collection of Freak Brothers comics
 

onomatopoeia

Bzzzzz.......Doink
Jul 3, 2020
21,251
17,340
113
Cabbagetown
I still have a collection of Freak Brothers comics
I have those, too, but well read, never-bagged that would probably be graded VG- or G+.

One of my friends from high school drew comics for Marvel and DC for quite a few years, mostly as an inker. He was a much better artist than most people familiar only with his work in print would think. When he worked for Marvel, the editor-in-chief was Jim Shooter. What was most important to Shooter was meeting printing schedules. The quality of the product was of lesser concern.

My friend was often given two weeks to complete art which would normally take a month, because the pencil artist was late submitting. My friend was able to meet those deadlines, but the quality of his work suffered somewhat. He got a lot of work, because a lot of pencil artists worked slowly, or drawing comics was a low priority side gig for them.
 

forgo10

Forgotten One
Dec 18, 2018
189
259
63
I need some advice from the collective. I have a very large comic book collection that I’d like to liquidate.
Most are comics from the bronze age a few from the silver age. The vast majority are in excellent condition, only read once, bagged and stored.
I have not had them CGC certified.

I obviously don’t want to give them away and I am aware some are quite valuable, Any advice would be appreciated.
I am somewhat in the same position as you. I have a collection of mostly Silver Age +/- comics totaling about 750 pieces, also bagged and most in NM condition. The difference is, I am not looking to liquidate them. According to some guides, I have some worth over $13 g's.

What I found online, but have never used them, is a place in Toronto called Paradise Comics that apparently will appraise your collection for free. That might help give you a start. I would recommend you get a Comic Collector program first and enter your collection so you know what you actually have and most apps also have some kind of price for the comics based on grading. My gut says that if the majority you have is Bronze age, they are worth substantially less on the average than Silver age and likely in less demand. So, first get your books catalogued and the app will give you a total price of your collection. It will also give you some idea if some are worth a lot more than just a few bucks. Then, check out and get the free appraisal. If you are in Toronto, then you could just go in and see what they might give you for the whole lot. Remember, you won't get any where near the price that is in whatever program you find. Most programs offer a free version so you can get some idea if there is actually gold in "them thar hills". LOL

I will probably check them out myself with many that are duplicates and some that I may just want to get rid of. So if you do use Paradise, let us know what you think of them, ie. leave a review here. :)
 

onomatopoeia

Bzzzzz.......Doink
Jul 3, 2020
21,251
17,340
113
Cabbagetown
FYI:

Silver Age comics are from about 1956 - 1970. Bronze Age is about 1970 - 1985. The boundary is approximately when the cover price changed from 12 cents to 15 cents, (ie: all 12 cent comics are Silver Age).

Many of the better comic book artists were active during the Bronze Age. In many cases, who drew the book is a bigger factor in determining the value than the popularity of the lead character or a low issue number.

Bronze Age 'hero' comics from the 1970's are considerably more valuable than anything from about 1981 or later, (except certain key issues). The early 80's was when sales/ distribution shifted from news stands to specialty comic book stores, and it's mainly the 1980's and 1990's collectors who bought comics solely for investment purposes, often 'bagging and boarding' new comics without reading them. When thousands of copies exist in Near Mint or better condition, there is little appreciation; everyone who wants the book already has it.

Only a small percentage of comics published after 1990 are worth even the cover price today, mostly because 'key issues' had enormous print runs.

When comics were sold on news stands, unsold copies were shredded, so the potential pool for future collectors was limited to sold copies. When comics were primarily sold in specialty shops, the print run was 100% based on the number of copies ordered by stores. News stands generally received about 20% discount on the cover price, and all unsold magazines were returnable for credit. Comic book stores received 40% - 50% discount, on a non-returnable basis. The valuable comics after the mid 1980's are usually the ones where stores underestimated the popularity of a title, so the demand exceeded supply.

There can be a huge difference between the selling price of 1990's and later comics, and their value for someone who wants to sell. A store puts one copy on the wall, with a high price sticker. If the book sells, they just get another copy from the stock room to fill the spot.
 
Toronto Escorts