Col Williams Gets A Pension

Yeah, it's on the CBC website as well.

It's insane.
 
Apparently the victims families want to know. Don't you think their thoughts count for something?

I don't think they're going to find the answer they're looking for. I don't think there is one.

There's nothing going to come out of this that's going to make anybody go, "Oh well that explains it, that's OK then". The guy was a psycho--that's the answer.
 
I don't think they're going to find the answer they're looking for. I don't think there is one.

There's nothing going to come out of this that's going to make anybody go, "Oh well that explains it, that's OK then". The guy was a psycho--that's the answer.

Fuji's circular logic: Why did he do it? Because he's a psycho. Why is he a psycho? Because he committed acts consistent with psychopathy. Why did he commit these acts? Because he's a psycho...

Just because YOU don't think there's an explanation doesn't mean we should stop looking for one. Human behaviour can't always be explained in a cause-and-effect equation, but it can't always be reduced to "just because" either.

Example: In the early part of the century, kids with Down's Syndrome were considered to be possessed by the devil, and thrown into institutions without any attempt to treat or understand their condition. Only after people started to study their behaviours without prejudice did we uncover the real problem - a genetic mutation on the 21st chromosome (trisomy 21) that caused the condition. If we took that same approach (throw them away and ignore them forever) then we wouldn't have developed any additional treatment options for people with DS, or the genetic screening that has reduced the prevalence of DS from 1 in 700 to 1 in 1000. Or any of the other cases where studying a disorder has led to better treatment options, and in some cases, cured the disorder entirely.

I know you prefer black-and-white thinking to actual consideration of alternatives, but that doesn't mean the rest of us see the world the same way. Personally, I'm much more inclined to examine ways of stopping potential murderers and rapists BEFORE they murder or rape people. Sweeping problems under the rug is counterproductive to that goal, and frankly, counterproductive to progress in general.
 
With all the details being revealed, it sounds like Williams was suffering from severe gender dysphoria, which manifested itself in an extreme form of antisocial personality disorder. He obviously couldn't deal with his internal pain, and it led him to do some horrible, disgusting things to innocent people.
You may well be right Nikki, and needless to say I belive you have an insight that others of us may not. However I still believe that there is a certain validity to what Fuji posted.

I don't think they're going to find the answer they're looking for. I don't think there is one.

There's nothing going to come out of this that's going to make anybody go, "Oh well that explains it, that's OK then".
Perhaps I'm hard to shock, and of course I'm not in the courtroom, however, thus far I haven't heard anything that explains the very late onset of his criminal behaviour nor his rapid escalation from clothing fetishist to murderer. The one piece of "new" news is that the police and the Crown believe that he has confessed to all the crimes he has committed.
 
You may well be right Nikki, and needless to say I belive you have an insight that others of us may not. However I still believe that there is a certain validity to what Fuji posted.

Perhaps I'm hard to shock, and of course I'm not in the courtroom, however, thus far I haven't heard anything that explains the very late onset of his criminal behaviour nor his rapid escalation from clothing fetishist to murderer. The one piece of "new" news is that the police and the Crown believe that he has confessed to all the crimes he has committed.

The best explanation I heard was he arrive at a point where what he was doing to that point was not satisfying him and that to this point he hadn't been caught and so did not fear being caught.

Strip clubs, then massage parlours, then Sp's, then Wicked then .....................
 
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...-killer-hiding-in-plain-sight/article1762519/

Will doctors be allowed to dissect his brain after he passes away?

To give you a serious answer, it would be highly unlikely to show anything useful. People such as Russell Williams have psychological rather than neurological abnormalities (e.g. software rather than hardware problems).

Took the words right out of my mouth, and he'd also have to consent to that if it were to happen - even a prisoner has a right to refuse post-mortem brain autopsy. I do hope that he continues to consent to psychiatric evaluation, and eventually, that those records and transcripts are made public. Or at least, made available to me in my future career; I think it would make for a fascinating (and possibly terrifying) read.

You may well be right Nikki, and needless to say I belive you have an insight that others of us may not. However I still believe that there is a certain validity to what Fuji posted.

Perhaps I'm hard to shock, and of course I'm not in the courtroom, however, thus far I haven't heard anything that explains the very late onset of his criminal behaviour nor his rapid escalation from clothing fetishist to murderer. The one piece of "new" news is that the police and the Crown believe that he has confessed to all the crimes he has committed.

To your first comment, there are a few points where my own experience with GID has given me some insight. For example, the media has portrayed his theft of undergarments as part of his "sexual depravity" but for a lot of people, it's more because it's awfully hard to obtain such items in a legal way. It also plays into the vicious cycle of "thrill/release/guilt" that causes a lot of mental anguish, and reinforces both the positive and negative feelings associated with such a condition.

Also, they claim that he burned the items because his inventory became too large; however, it's more likely that it was an act of "purging" where a person tries to eliminate that part of themselves once and for all, by removing all traces of their other side. I went through that cycle a few times myself, before finally accepting who I was, and I know the pattern is common to other crossdressers and transsexuals - I've heard it from many others. The human mind is exceedingly good at repressing feelings for short periods of time, but not very good at maintaining it for long.

The best explanation I heard was he arrive at a point where what he was doing to that point was not satisfying him and that to this point he hadn't been caught and so did not fear being caught.

Strip clubs, then massage parlours, then Sp's, then Wicked then .....................

I know people are making fun of the connection he had to his cat, but pets are extremely important to some people, especially those who are unstable; the unconditional love that your pet shows you is often irreplaceable, especially if you already feel a lack of connection to society. The death of a close pet can evoke the same powerful emotions as the death of a spouse, parent or sibling, and the resulting trauma might be enough to lead to a full-fledged emotional breakdown. It's just a theory, but I suspect that might have been the tipping point where he lost all connection to humanity, and went from being a tormented individual to a tormented rapist and murderer (which is also the point where I lost all sympthy for him).

My problem with Fuji's "point" (or lack thereof) is that he doesn't even want to consider alternative explanations for what happened, not to mention his circular logic which does nothing to enlighten the situation. If we don't even try to understand why it happened, we may as well resign ourselves to letting it happen again and again, ad infinitum. Maybe it's my youthful naivete, but I'm not prepared to go that route - not for a few more decades, at least.

Studying human behaviour is my discipline of choice, and this is one case which I plan to follow for as long as possible. Saying "he's just a psycho" isn't an option for me, nor should it be the end of the conversation for anyone who wants to know why people do what they do.
 
Fuji's circular logic: Why did he do it? Because he's a psycho. Why is he a psycho? Because he committed acts consistent with psychopathy. Why did he commit these acts? Because he's a psycho...

Just because YOU don't think there's an explanation doesn't mean we should stop looking for one. Human behaviour can't always be explained in a cause-and-effect equation, but it can't always be reduced to "just because" either.

Example: In the early part of the century, kids with Down's Syndrome were considered to be possessed by the devil, and thrown into institutions without any attempt to treat or understand their condition. Only after people started to study their behaviours without prejudice did we uncover the real problem - a genetic mutation on the 21st chromosome (trisomy 21) that caused the condition. If we took that same approach (throw them away and ignore them forever) then we wouldn't have developed any additional treatment options for people with DS, or the genetic screening that has reduced the prevalence of DS from 1 in 700 to 1 in 1000. Or any of the other cases where studying a disorder has led to better treatment options, and in some cases, cured the disorder entirely.

I know you prefer black-and-white thinking to actual consideration of alternatives, but that doesn't mean the rest of us see the world the same way. Personally, I'm much more inclined to examine ways of stopping potential murderers and rapists BEFORE they murder or rape people. Sweeping problems under the rug is counterproductive to that goal, and frankly, counterproductive to progress in general.

The purpose of a trial isn't to analyze what made him tick and there wouldn't be any anwers either. I don't see how this belief means someone sees the world in black and white or they don't want to know why people kill or rape, knowledge can still be gained when he's locked up and the key is thrown away especially since he's cooperative. We aren't sweeping the problem under the rug.
 
Nobody should pay any attention or care to what he thinks or why he did what he did:

Lock him up. Throw away the key. Never think of him again.

That's the quote I took issue with, Brill. I'm not talking about the end of the trial, but Fuji's desire to end the discussion on the reasons behind William's heinous acts. Luckily, that's not going to happen - this case will be discussed for years, if not decades to come. We can lock him up to make sure that he never does it again, but stopping others from committing similar crimes requires an analysis of what drove Williams to his breakdown.

Edit: Sorry if that came off as bitchy, I just don't like when people respond to inquiries about human behaviour with "that's just how people are, let's stop talking about it because it's useless." That kind of mentality stunts discussion, and hinders understanding and progress. As long as it's coming from an educated, open-minded perspective, there's no reason not to ask questions (unless the poster is deliberately trying to start shit, in which case they're just a troll and should be ignored).
 
He started his sexual break and enter spree long before the cat died. The death of the cat was not a catalyst to his perversion. (Pun not intended.)
 
He started his sexual break and enter spree long before the cat died. The death of the cat was not a catalyst to his perversion. (Pun not intended.)

It's true he was breaking into houses before the cat died, but it doesn't look like he raped or killed anyone until after the cat's death in late 2008. The rapes occured in September, 2009, Marie-France Comeau was killed in late November, 2009, and Jessica Lloyd disappeared on January 28, 2010.

So, it's entirely possible that the death of his cat precipitated a full-fledged mental breakdown, and was traumatizing enough to send him down the path to rape and murder. There's a qualitative difference between B&E/panty theft, versus the victimization and murder of human beings. The crown even said that his "sexual obsession escalated to rape and murder," a statement which I consider totally ignorant. The vast majority of people with unconventional sexual desires certainly don't rape or murder because of their desires.

Hell, guys who see escorts are often considered "sexually perverse" by those with strong religious beliefs and an orientation towards monogamy; being "perverse" doesn't mean that pooners will eventually turn into murderers.