Christopher Hitchens dies

from the article
" He was himself both hateful and cruel. Upon Bob Hope’s death, Hitchens wrote that he was a “fool, and nearly a clown.” When Ronald Reagan died, Hitchens called him a “stupid lizard,” “dumb as a stump” and “an obvious phony and loon.” On Mother Teresa: “The woman was a fanatic and a fundamentalist and a fraud, and millions of people are much worse off because of her life, and it’s a shame there is no hell for your bitch to go to.”

I take a different view, and do sincerely pray for a merciful judgment."

You do not have to quote the article for me. In contrast to other posters, I read the article before posting.
 
For a christian to suggest that a man who lived his life motivated by hate, and rejected the very idea of god, is going to be punished in hell, is not radical at all now is it?

It definitely is in the christian faith I was brought up in. Roman 14:9
 
You do not have to quote the article for me. In contrast to other posters, I read the article before posting.

oh? it didn't seem that you did from your post. the author of the article did not decide that hitchens was going to hell or condemn him to hell- in fact he indicated that he was praying for his soul's redemption and forgiveness. that seems fairly christian to me.
 
oh? it didn't seem that you did from your post. the author of the article did not decide that hitchens was going to hell or condemn him to hell- in fact he indicated that he was praying for his soul's redemption and forgiveness. that seems fairly christian to me.
You may have missed this sentence:

"The sadness is that there is a hell for Hitch to go to."
 
from the article
" He was himself both hateful and cruel. Upon Bob Hope’s death, Hitchens wrote that he was a “fool, and nearly a clown.” When Ronald Reagan died, Hitchens called him a “stupid lizard,” “dumb as a stump” and “an obvious phony and loon.” On Mother Teresa: “The woman was a fanatic and a fundamentalist and a fraud, and millions of people are much worse off because of her life, and it’s a shame there is no hell for your bitch to go to.”

I take a different view, and do sincerely pray for a merciful judgment."
So what's your point. I call bulls eye on each one of those assessments. Bob Hope.Parasite on the backs of American troops.Showing up with a USO show every Christmas.He got booed in Vietnam. As on GI said.He always showed up with the booze and the broads and then left.Leaving us in the mud to do the fighting.
Ronald Regan's war against Nicaragua and Guatemala.He supported the Guatemalan genocide of over 100,000 indigenous people in a period of a couple of years in the 80's.Mother Teresa, if you bothered to read his book, was a fraud. I don't see his shining a light on the bullshit activities of these people as hateful and cruel. I see it as exposing the truth.
 
You may have missed this sentence:

"The sadness is that there is a hell for Hitch to go to."


i read it. that doesn't condemn him to hell, but merely points out there is a hell, if god decides thats where hitchens should go.
 
So what's your point. I call bulls eye on each one of those assessments. Bob Hope.Parasite on the backs of American troops.Showing up with a USO show every Christmas.He got booed in Vietnam. As on GI said.He always showed up with the booze and the broads and then left.Leaving us in the mud to do the fighting.
Ronald Regan's war against Nicaragua and Guatemala.He supported the Guatemalan genocide of over 100,000 indigenous people in a period of a couple of years in the 80's.Mother Teresa, if you bothered to read his book, was a fraud. I don't see his shining a light on the bullshit activities of these people as hateful and cruel. I see it as exposing the truth.

hitchens spent his life hating other people and making derogatory remarks on their passing. you admire that I guess.
 
So what's your point. I call bulls eye on each one of those assessments. Bob Hope.Parasite on the backs of American troops.Showing up with a USO show every Christmas.He got booed in Vietnam. As on GI said.He always showed up with the booze and the broads and then left.Leaving us in the mud to do the fighting.
Ronald Regan's war against Nicaragua and Guatemala.He supported the Guatemalan genocide of over 100,000 indigenous people in a period of a couple of years in the 80's.Mother Teresa, if you bothered to read his book, was a fraud. I don't see his shining a light on the bullshit activities of these people as hateful and cruel. I see it as exposing the truth.

So the USO booked Bob Hope, the audience didn't like him and you blame him for that? You expected him to finish his show and then go man a mortar?

I don;t like Reagan at all, but one cannot be so vehemently against Reagan's actions but in favour of the Iraq war without some sense of nuance or relativism.

And many of his allegations against Mother T are disputed. It really was the height of his contrarian work. Do you believe all of his allegations whole cloth.

Plus he admitted it quite clearly, he went after these people out of hate and showed no grace or class in his attacks. He reaps what he sows.
 
Cynics tend to be unpleasant and no doubt Hitchens was extremely full of himself. As to Mother Theresa only she knew what she truly believed but absolute conviction is at the core of fanaticism. Doubt truly makes her a more human figure and allows for more complexity of character than blind faith.
 
hitchens spent his life hating other people .........................................

What kind of absolute nonsense is that?? "..............spent his life hating other people.....????"

You have no evidence of that whatsoever. Writing about Kissinger's misdeeds in Chile, is that hating other people? I think rather it shows empathy with other people.

I think it is very unfortunate that he is not going to write a orbituary about Kissinger. I would have looked forward to reading it.
 
What kind of absolute nonsense is that?? "..............spent his life hating other people.....????"

You have no evidence of that whatsoever. Writing about Kissinger's misdeeds in Chile, is that hating other people? I think rather it shows empathy with other people.

I think it is very unfortunate that he is not going to write a orbituary about Kissinger. I would have looked forward to reading it.

Hitchens explained: "For a lot of people, their first love is what they'll always remember. For me it's always been the first hate, and I think that hatred, though it provides often rather junky energy, is a terrific way of getting you out of bed in the morning and keeping you going."
 
i read it. that doesn't condemn him to hell, but merely points out there is a hell, if god decides thats where hitchens should go.

No, Sir, De Souza is using the old hypocritical trick used by preachers everywhere: "I pray for his soul, but he is sure going to burn in hell"

By the way, I am puzzled by the strong condemnation of Hitchens here. If you people believe in the omnipotent God, surely a magazine writer can be no threat. Is it because you have a nagging doubt??
 
No, Sir, De Souza is using the old hypocritical trick used by preachers everywhere: "I pray for his soul, but he is sure going to burn in hell"

You have failed logic. There is nothing hypocritical in that statement at all.

Let me help you. I am a Steelers fan. With four minutes left in the game last night I could desperately pray for the win, while knowing they were almost certainly going to loose.

Same for Hitch.
 
You have failed logic. There is nothing hypocritical in that statement at all.

Let me help you. I am a Steelers fan. With four minutes left in the game last night I could desperately pray for the win, while knowing they were almost certainly going to loose.

Same for Hitch.

Except that logic does not apply to religion. Religion is faith, not facts or logic.

Let me explain: There is a Steelers team, they play football in a real arena, real people watch.

There is no record of anyone having been to Hell and back, even if some people use that expression.
 
No, Sir, De Souza is using the old hypocritical trick used by preachers everywhere: "I pray for his soul, but he is sure going to burn in hell"

?

you said he condemned hitchens to hell. but he didn't. now you are using the fuji technique of changing what you said.

By the way, I am puzzled by the strong condemnation of Hitchens here. If you people believe in the omnipotent God, surely a magazine writer can be no threat. Is it because you have a nagging doubt??

i never claimed hitchens was a threat. I think he was a sad figure, who attacked others with vitriol. I think my first post in this thread was something like "god has forgiven him"
 
you said he condemned hitchens to hell. but he didn't. now you are using the fuji technique of changing what you said.

There may be some truth in that, and I apologize for that.

i never claimed hitchens was a threat. I think he was a sad figure, who attacked others with vitriol. I think my first post in this thread was something like "god has forgiven him"
I am guessing that you have read very little of Hitchens' writing over the years, and rely on the article by De Souza. I have read a lot of his articles, and I find it bizarre to call him sad and an attack dog. He was a brilliant writer, who always was enriching to read, because he made you think. Sometimes he was right, sometimes he was wrong, as is the case with most people.
His books about God or the absence of God, are certanly not hateful or sad, but shows an unlimited trust in the human spirit. His point in a nutshell, which you of course may not agree with, is that humans do not need religion to be good. I consider that a very uplifting and positive message about the human spirit.
 
I take his message as religion does not make you good that is a personal decision.
 
There may be some truth in that, and I apologize for that.


I am guessing that you have read very little of Hitchens' writing over the years, and rely on the article by De Souza. I have read a lot of his articles, and I find it bizarre to call him sad and an attack dog. He was a brilliant writer, who always was enriching to read, because he made you think. Sometimes he was right, sometimes he was wrong, as is the case with most people.
His books about God or the absence of God, are certanly not hateful or sad, but shows an unlimited trust in the human spirit. His point in a nutshell, which you of course may not agree with, is that humans do not need religion to be good. I consider that a very uplifting and positive message about the human spirit.


i have read his books. they are ok. i don't find them offensive or illuminating. more pedestrian really. his public quotes and articles are full to the brim with vitriol and attacks.