Cellphone Ticket

I really don't understand what all the fuss about this. I essentially work from my car and use my phone constantly. Because I drive a standard, I have used a Bluetooth ear piece for years. As much as I need to use my phone while driving, I don't dispute for a second that using the phone is distracting to some extent. I try to avoid using it in bad weather, or in areas where traffic is bad.

People that try to tell me that they can text and email while driving are full of shit. Typing requires that you look at the phone and therefore you aren't looking at the road. Talking on a phone allows you to at least look where you're driving. This isn't rocket science. I use a Blackberry with voice dialling which works very well, especially with the ear piece.

I find that the best way to avoid the temptation to respond to emails while driving is to simply turn off the email ringer when I'm driving. I can't speak for anyone else, but I personally don't get emails that are worth dieing over if they aren't dealt with immediately.
 
Stoo, you speak with the voice of reason. Business and pleasure both got done efficiently and productively before cellphones, and when they came in heavy shoulder-bags no one demanded 'their right to use one, for safety reasons'.

If all cars were made with jammers so no cell would work with the engine running there'd be a short, loud anguished cry across the land, then we'd all get on with it. Or double insurance rates for anyone who owns a cell phone and doesn't install a jammer. Everybody equal.

It's that damn entitlement thing again, 'I am entitled to be as stupid as anyone else as long as it's my money'.
 
Stoo, you speak with the voice of reason. Business and pleasure both got done efficiently and productively before cellphones, and when they came in heavy shoulder-bags no one demanded 'their right to use one, for safety reasons'.

If all cars were made with jammers so no cell would work with the engine running there'd be a short, loud anguished cry across the land, then we'd all get on with it. Or double insurance rates for anyone who owns a cell phone and doesn't install a jammer. Everybody equal.

It's that damn entitlement thing again, 'I am entitled to be as stupid as anyone else as long as it's my money'.

If these jammers were ever used you'd have problems in emergency situations. you need an override or some such thing. Not going to happen as too many places don't have legislation regarding the use of phones.
 
I would totally agree with a heavy handed crackdown. My only problems with law is that:

a) it comes way to late in the game, it should have been in force by 1999 or 2000 before this behaviour became so entrenched.


Agree. Was the case in Australia in 1996 when cell phones first came out - $500 fine I believe back then

b) it does not explicitly extended to pedestrians, with provisions for enforcable penalties, which automatically renders it 50% ineffective in areas of high foot traffic, as well as creating an asymetry and discrimination which is fundementally offensive to our system of justice - it should apply equally to ALL public road users of any kind.

WTF: No point having a mobile phone if you can't use it when mobile - except for case a.

c) I think it's undermined by allowing the use of hand's free devices. This is a good start but it in a few years it should ultimately expand to outlaw all telecummunications as unacceptable distractions - at least on in-town streets.

Exceptions can be made for Highways where traffic moves in only one direction and there are no intersections, pedestrians cyclists or significant vision obstacles (bus shelters, trash piles, transit vehicles or parked cube vans...) to deal with.

But I firmly believe the ONLY things that belong in the driver's cockpit are a Steering Wheel, Pedals, Shifter, Emergency Brake, Turn Signal stick, Wiper switch and Defroster/ Fan contorls ... and perhaps an AM radio for weather, traffic & emergency broadcast.

There should have been legislation 15 years ago when all this started to prevent the sale vehicles with any sort home entertainment type devices, and require manufacturers to install emmiters which jam all wirelsess communications form within the cabin when the engine is on. These could be embeded into the headliner & door pannels and linked to the PCM so that any attempt to tamper with them would trip a fault code which locks the car in 1st gear, sabotages the EGR valve and activates the hazzard lights. Only dealers would have proprietary software which can clear the code at customer's cost, (the equivalent of a $160 ticket) and the tampering would have to be reported to authorities.


Why not just make the car blow up!
 
I don't have a problem with the cops doing that. While I do think that charges should be dropped for legitimate 9-1-1 calls ( a matter that can easily be verified through phone records ) I still think the police should deliver the lecture. At the end of the day if the reason for the call is SO important as to be worth thousands of dollars a person should then be willing to pay the fine in that case.

No need for charges to be dropped, as contacting emergency services is permitted under the law. And I'll pass on lectures from police for not breaking the law.

"Subsection (1) does not apply in respect of the use of a device to contact ambulance, police or fire department emergency services."
 
I doubt that there is a cellphone jammer that wouldn't jam everything within xx feet of the car - and why can't passengers use a phone?
 
If these jammers were ever used you'd have problems in emergency situations. you need an override or some such thing. Not going to happen as too many places don't have legislation regarding the use of phones.

Well somehow we handled emergencies w/o cellphones in the past. And I did suggest engin-connected jammers. Pull over, stop, take a breath and safely report that emegency with just that on your mind.
 
I doubt that there is a cellphone jammer that wouldn't jam everything within xx feet of the car - and why can't passengers use a phone?
Of course there isn't, trhere's no market. Change that and … well that's why they said man would never walk on the moon, no imagination, no faith.

Passengers could use their phones. When the car was stopped. Was their right to cellphone use enshrined in the Charter? But I'd bet the technoweenies could make a partitioned backseat a use zone if anyone cared. Cellphones are not necessaries of life or even happiness. And if they didn't work in cars we'd all have excuses to be phone-free for a few minutes now and then.
 
Can you get a ticket if you're talking with your mobile on speaker phone? I need to push the recieve button though and then talk as I have the phone on my lap or in my hand near my crotch, lol.

If I have bluetooth reciever in my ear can I dial a number on my phone while driving?

My understanding is that is allowed if the phone on your lap, but not if it is in your hand. Technically you probably have to affix the phone to the dashboard before it is legal to press the button. I believe you can buy holsters for your phone so you can attach it and make that legal. The holster would also position the phone so that your voice is clear on the speakerphone.

As for dialing, not if you are holding the phone in your hand. If you affix it to the dashboard maybe.
 
b) it does not excplicitly extended to pedestrians

You're forgetting that pedestrians have a right to use the road, unlike car drivers.

as well as creating an asymetry and discrimination which is fundementally offensive to our system of justice

There is no asymmetry: Everyone has the same rights when they are walking, and everyone has the same rights when they are driving. You have misunderstood the concept of asymmetry.

c) I think it's undermined by allowing the use of hand's free devices.

I tend to agree with you, but I think it should be evidence based. If studies show that hands free conversations are causing fatal accidents then the rules should be extended.

There should have been legislation 15 years ago when all this started to prevent the sale vehicles with any sort home entertainment type devices, and require manufacturers to install emmiters which jam all wirelsess communications form within the cabin when the engine is on.

That's a bit extreme, there is no evidence that it is harmful for the PASSENGER to be on the phone or using an entertainment device.
 
Here you go again with your imagined rights.

Point to me ANYWHERE that states a person has the RIGHT to walk ON the road....otherwise, STFU about it......and for the record? If I am legally licenced, own or rent or in possession of a legally licenced vehicle, then we DO have the right to drive on a designated motorway........
 
Here you go again with your imagined rights.

Point to me ANYWHERE that states a person has the RIGHT to walk ON the road....otherwise, STFU about it......and for the record? If I am legally licenced, own or rent or in possession of a legally licenced vehicle, then we DO have the right to drive on a designated motorway........

tboy, I thought you understood this from the last time.
If you are legally licenced, insured and following all the laws of the road you are permitted to drive. That's not a right, its a permission to use the road and if you screw up any one of those previously mentioned qualifier, then your permission is rescinded.

Now, from what I've heard about the jaywalking laws, jaywalking or walking on the road, is allowed unless it impedes a car. That sounds like a right with a qualifier. But then pretty much all of our rights have qualifiers. Free speech is free until you cross the hate/racism line.....The difference being that you don't need to get a license, pass a test, get insurance, verify your car is roadworthy and veryify the emmissions before you're allowed to speak.
 
Here you go again with your imagined rights.

Point to me ANYWHERE that states a person has the RIGHT to walk ON the road....otherwise, STFU about it......and for the record? If I am legally licenced, own or rent or in possession of a legally licenced vehicle, then we DO have the right to drive on a designated motorway........

No, driving is a privilege.
 
If I am legally licenced, own or rent or in possession of a legally licenced vehicle, then we DO have the right to drive on a designated motorway........

(Emphasis mine).

Come on, I would have thought at you, of all people, would be very clear on this, one of the most commonly forgotten rules of the road, and the first rule I was taught in driving school:

Driving is a privilege and not a right.

This is from "The top 10 forgotten rules of the road" http://www.wheels.ca/Article%20Category/article/535747

Section 31(a) of the Act states: "The privilege of driving on a highway is granted to, and retained by, only those persons who demonstrate that they are likely to drive safely."


So, even if you are fully licensed, fully insured, fully trained and qualified as a driver, you do NOT have THE RIGHT to drive on any highway.

It's certainly easy for us to forget, because we are all such slaves to commuting...

Anyways, just a friendly reminder...carry on
 
The thing you ALL are missing is the difference between being entitled to drive and the act of driving. No, driving in and of itself is NOT a right, but as stated, a priveledge. But being a licenced authorized driver, in possesion of a licenced legal street safe vehicle, I personally have the RIGHT to choose to drive, walk, ride a bicycle or motorcycle. That is MY right and is no less or more important than someone else's RIGHT to walk on the road.

You cannot say "person A has the RIGHt to walk, but you don't have the RIGHT to drive....." That's like saying only certain people have rights and others don't. Or that people who CHOOSE not to eat meat have MORE rights or more IMPORTANT rights, than those who do. No difference.

Get it? got it? good........tyvm...I'll be here all week, try the veal.....
 
My understanding is that is allowed if the phone on your lap, but not if it is in your hand. Technically you probably have to affix the phone to the dashboard before it is legal to press the button. I believe you can buy holsters for your phone so you can attach it and make that legal. The holster would also position the phone so that your voice is clear on the speakerphone.

As for dialing, not if you are holding the phone in your hand. If you affix it to the dashboard maybe.

One word, autodial (one button and/or voice command). That, with hands-free, and you are OK with in the eyes of the law.