OK
I see your point, and it is valid
Judging MM without makeup, against girls without makeup, I raise her to a six and one half with five as average
I see prettier faces all the time without makeup
On the posted ones I would say Heigl and Wilde are prettier and it is a draw with Cruz
Judging MM with makeup against only girls with makeup done by one of the worlds best artists then shot and retouched by one of the worlds best photographers I drop her to a eight
But beauty is in the eye of the beholder
It's your judgement and your call. I can't argue with your ratings. I don't think we're comparing apples and oranges, though. Heigl and Wilde's "no makeup" photos... there's a difference between ZERO makeup and "not made up". The right side of those photos are "made up to hit the town" makeup levels. The left side, for some of those women... no. It's worth noting that Heigl and Wilde's hair is done on the left side, while the rest of the women are either hat covering bed head or actual bed head hair. Monroe is pool hair.
I don't think Heigl and Wilde (and maybe Halle) are at ZERO makeup in their left side photos. They have "girl out and about" levels of makeup, which isn't "out on the town" levels by any means, but it ain't zero.
Women's makeup is a mystical, magical place where there are many, many different levels. Most of which we, as men, are blissfully unaware. If you really think you know a lot of girls' faces with zero makeup (outside of maybe sisters and your mom), you might be shocked at some point in the future.
Honestly, I think most men have better complexions than most women, simply because most men rarely ever put on makeup. That stuff, the vast majority of it, isn't good for your skin. The constant application and removal of all of that ain't pretty. I've known a lot of girls who carry the leftside Heigl/Wilde left side look with "natural" levels of makeup, vamp up to the look on the fight, but then end up looking life Zellweger when the makeup really comes off.
