Car manufacturers

Dancerfan said:
Bullshit!! A big 3 vehicle is a damn good one!! Just check some of the JD Power Results!
I dunno where you guys get off criticizing Big 3 vehicles,we work damn hard and we do a quality job and that old myth about never buying one built on a Monday or Friday is a bunch of crap too!!

I don't know so much about Ford and Chrysler.

But GM?

Biggest loads on the road.

3 words.

Plastic Intake Manifold

And that's nothing to do with the guys who build them, but everything to do with guys that design them.

If GM can save 1 cent on a part they will take it, even if that 1 cent is a better quality part. As long as that part meets the spec, low price gets the nod regardless of higher quality.

Every time.
 
short said:
[B, japanese manufacturers have a different lifestyle than north americans - as they work on saturdays also. [/B]

We do too ya know,we run 3 shifts in the plant i work in and while Saturdays are overtime,we do work them,you think its just the Jap companys that do this??
Not everyone works 9 to 5 with weekends off you know!!!
 
The auto industry has fundamentally changed but the attitudes re: corporate / union / quality have stayed the same. Generally, in measurable quality issues as tracked by the manufacturer's themselves (in-plant inspection, SPC, dealer feedback) and 3rd party (JD Powers), the newest or newly refurbished plants produce the best quality vehicle. The court of public opinion, usually the correct one, is formed by longevity, repair bills, service shop customer experience and friends opinions.

The continuing quality issue with Big 3, since inherited by VW, is solely attributable to a paradigm shift in procurement by Jose Arriortua, a “guru� headhunted by GM from South America in the late 1980’s. He totally revamped GM’s purchasing methodology by doing intensive business case analysis of each GM supplier, meeting with them, presenting results of his analysis and dictating a diminishing sliding scale of what GM would pay for that part or assembly over its lifetime. Usually it started with an immediate 30% price reduction going to about an 80% reduction. And then, he and his team would get up and leave. No negotiation. This practice, immensely successful for GM, caused the massive losses, plant shutdowns, layoffs, etc. in the auto industry at the time and helped to precipitate the 1980’s recession.

Companies that weathered this adopted a new design and engineering model where the per unit price is everything. Generally, an automotive component design cycle is 80 – 90% cost reduction, giving rise to auto industry jargon “latest and greatest�. Anybody who has ever dealt with Big 3, or any tier suppliers, will use this term every day as a component goes through hundreds of revisions. The result, component design is whittled away at the altar of lowest possible net part cost: the parts do not become inexpensive, they become cheap. Fundamental difference. This is in no way a union – quality – day of the week build issue. It is a fundamental weakness of design quality shared by the Big 3 as the others copied GM’s phenomenal success. Jose Arriortua was subsequently headhunted by VW, given “Executive VP� and hit with an immense lawsuit by GM, which was resolved after years of legal wrangling and a huge cash payment to GM. Guess what, VW went down the same road as GM, and almost bankrupted themselves with quality issues on new Bug.

Conclusion, Big 3 cars are generally very well built by a quality, caring workforce. But they are built with generally well made CHEAP parts.

The Japanese and German manufacturers employ different philosophy regarding quality and investment, but that’s another diatribe.
 
I've worked at a outsource supplier, and I have friends at Oakville, Kitchener and Alliston plants. Canadians are Canadians, and whether we like to be at work on monday or friday doesn't matter where you work. Mondays and fridays don't figure in quality assurance anymore, as there can be quality spills any day of the week.

I had first hand knowledge that GM forces their outsource suppliers to cut costs through "continuous improvement" each year of a contract to become more "profitable" or "efficient" by any means possible, and then were forced to give a percentage of their "found savings" back to GM. Part of that was cheaper supplies or less workforce, or more parts per hour, with less checks for quality. That philosophy trickled over to parts we made for other customers, so end result was N.A. Asian or Euro products all suffered.
 
Re: Right on

maximadude said:
It's all about the marginal engineering, meeting minimal standards for outsourced parts, as well as being greedy with their profit margins. There's no need to blame the little guy nor the day of the week.

Its the little guy that pays the price in a plant closing,layoffs or what have you!!!
 
antaeus said:
.......Conclusion, Big 3 cars are generally very well built by a quality, caring workforce. But they are built with generally well made CHEAP parts. The Japanese and German manufacturers employ different philosophy regarding quality and investment, but that’s another diatribe.


i guess this would explain why gm is losing big time market share to the likes of other manufacturers.
 
Re: Re: Re: Right on

mtl_guy said:
A union job is not a god given right.

I never said it was,so stop trying to put words in my mouth!
No job is a god given right, and my point in all of this is that i resent what some of you think we do at work in a automobile plant,we work hard,its boring and the hours suck!
But i know no one who feels that we make a lousy product,ive driven nothing but big 3 products all my life and have had no major problems with any of them,all my friends do as well,and most of them are people NOT employed by any of the Big 3!
I worked at a plant in Scarborough which was closed in 1993,not because we did a poor job but mainly due to politics,most of us were fortunate enough to get jobs in other of the companys plants,but its never been the same for any of us since that happened,so what do you all want to see,all the big 3 companys go out of business,would that make you all happy??
I will without hesitation match up any we build in the same class of car or truck to anything made by any foreign manufacurer,and to anyone here who works for one of them,i dont run down your products,to each his own,so dont run down mine!!
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Right on

Dancerfan said:
I never said it was,so stop trying to put words in my mouth!
No job is a god given right, and my point in all of this is that i resent what some of you think we do at work in a automobile plant,we work hard,its boring and the hours suck!
But i know no one who feels that we make a lousy product,ive driven nothing but big 3 products all my life and have had no major problems with any of them,all my friends do as well,and most of them are people NOT employed by any of the Big 3!
I worked at a plant in Scarborough which was closed in 1993,not because we did a poor job but mainly due to politics,most of us were fortunate enough to get jobs in other of the companys plants,but its never been the same for any of us since that happened,so what do you all want to see,all the big 3 companys go out of business,would that make you all happy??
I will without hesitation match up any we build in the same class of car or truck to anything made by any foreign manufacurer,and to anyone here who works for one of them,i dont run down your products,to each his own,so dont run down mine!!

Hey, I went on a tour of that Van plant in 92 I believe. My ex girlfriend worked for EDS there.

She told me that they were closing the plant because it was a very old and inefficient plant, used to make refrigerators or something like that.

I certainly would not want to see the big 3 go bust.

What I would like to see is them build a better car, i.e. engineering wise. They are operating from the premise that North Americans don't recognize quality under the skin and won't pay for it (it's probably true mind you in some respects). They think that we want more coffee cup holders, powerpoints, seats that fold away than we do want reliable work horse engines and transmissions.

I love the old GM cars, truel LOVE them. The styling, the simplicity, the work horse strength of them. I had a friend who was scrapping an old Nova once with a straight 6 in it and just for a laugh, we drained all the coolant out of it just to see how much it could take before it bit the dust. You know what? We couldn't kill it. We drove that car for hours with no coolant, the light on and it kept going. In fact, he drove it for another week with no coolant until finally he drove it to the wrecker and got 100 bucks because it was still running.

You couldn't do that to today's vehicles.
 
Re: Right on

maximadude said:
The quality issue has nothing to do with your neighbour or mine working at the plant putting Sunfires,(Ugh) Alero's(ugh) and Cavaliers(ugh) together. It's all about the marginal engineering, meeting minimal standards for outsourced parts, as well as being greedy with their profit margins. There's no need to blame the little guy nor the day of the week.

Read my post.

I said, "This has nothing to do with the guys who build them and everything to do with the guys who engineer them"

Truth be told, I am sure the GM engineers are smarter than that, it's the bean counters. They figure, hey behind door number 1 is an aluminum intake manifold that costs $50.00 to manufacture, and behind door number 2 is a plastic intake manifold (made of chewed up carpets) that costs $25.00 to manufacture.

Both will work, but the plastic one is only marginal in quality and will cause your engine to sieze after 122,000 km or the aluminum one which will last forever, but it DOES cost more.

"Go with the plastic one"
 
Re: Re: Right on

james t kirk said:
Read my post.

I said, "This has nothing to do with the guys who build them and everything to do with the guys who engineer them"

Truth be told, I am sure the GM engineers are smarter than that, it's the bean counters. They figure, hey behind door number 1 is an aluminum intake manifold that costs $50.00 to manufacture, and behind door number 2 is a plastic intake manifold (made of chewed up carpets) that costs $25.00 to manufacture.

Both will work, but the plastic one is only marginal in quality and will cause your engine to sieze after 122,000 km or the aluminum one which will last forever, but it DOES cost more.

"Go with the plastic one"

Could it be perhaps GM uses the plastic intake manifold (and other "doubtful quality" parts used) so that the cars won't last long, and they feel that by having a higher vehicle turnover rate for consumers, they will buy more cars......thus, producing more sales/revenues?? After all, isn't this the way GM does business anyway........they know they can't get much profits - also profits are unpredictable - with other competitiors in sight, so at least they can boost sales and revenues.
 
maximadude said:
Initial quality figures are bogus anyways. If you cant manufacture a car with at least initial quality, you shouldnt be in the car biz at all. A better measure is the models which are still on the road with least repairs/problems after a few years of wear and tear, generally reflected by how far manufacturers are willing to back a product with warranty. The big 3 cant compete here. Speaking to the owner of an indie garage in a small town of about 10,000 people, his point was, that if it werent for the BIG 3, he would be out of business, cuz the Japanese cars particularly, rarely ever need to come in. It's hilarious at our office watching all of the Big 3 owners constantly complaining about garage time for blown engines, trannies, etc etc etc etc. The Asian aficionados have been chuckling and ribbing them for years..and occasionally giving them a ride to pick up their cars at the garage. You will rarely see a Big 3 on a Consumer's, Lemonaide, or JD Power list of recommended used car buys. wonder why?
Pinto? Rusty Ford Owners' Club?
 
Disposable Society

The Business Plan of the Big 3 automakers is in tune with the "Disposable Society" Ethos of the 1980s and 1990s.

The manufacturer hopes that their customer will lease a new car every three years. They are looking for the engineering model that will allow the vehicle to function with a minimum of fuss for the lease period, then completely disintegrate. They are having trouble fine-tuning the process so the car makes it out of the warranty period. Most electronic products are built to this model IE replace don't repair. Unfortunately cars are subject to different amounts of usage, maintenance and weather conditions.

The Japanese automakers are after the long-term owner and repeat buyer of their product. Their model is to charge more at purchase time, but to make the-long term ownership of the vehicle painless enough so the customer will buy another of the same car when the time comes.

The most important people at the big-3 car companies are the cost accountants, chisellling costs down to allow "fleet purchase" prices that are attractive.

The most important people at othe carmakers are the engineers
who want to build parts right before cheap.

Most North American parts suppliers prefer to do business with the Japanese. When they suplly "cheaped-out" parts to the big-3 they are subject to some payback on warranty costs. So they are squeezed on both the cost and quality side.
 
Clipper has some very good points...

Bottomline Big Three (which will always be present) and a handful of Tier 1 suppliers will gradually remove the sleep from their eyes and emerge to find themselves free from Union business constraints, which will positively influence their ability to compete.

I am not a believer in today's world in Unions for an industry like making cars, unions need to be terminated like the CAW and UAW, just the US vs. THEM attitude, unwarranted merit increases, realistic job assignments enabeling smart, talented people to truely be a professional trades person able to multi task regardless of trade. The jobs, 50% to 70% of them should remain.

I firmly beleive the mantality of the Union leadership and the US vs. THEM attitude is tired, old and will never change freely...

Therefore, the change will occur by way of business pressure which is to say a continued loss of US Market share to competition will force change to occur in order to preserve Big 3 as we know them today.

Perhaps in Greater Detroit and a few other select communities the Big 3 may never change SOP, they may keep their local tradition and lose their current "preceived authority" in the market place Internationally.

The majority of communities where plants are located will be absorbed into organizations with different operating circumstances that enable them to compete, preserve jobs locally, nationally and deliver shareholder value.
 
maybe it is just me, but the loss in market share that the big three have experienced is not an unreasonable loss compared to the context of todays automotive market. 30-40 years ago GM/Ford/Chrysler were pretty much the only manufacturers around that had some semblance of a quality reputation and products to match. as more of the Import companies like Honda and Toyota continued to plug away at the Noth American market and increase market share it is only logical to see the dominance of the big three drop. In many ways this process is still on going with companies like GM offering 2 or 3 different model names all built on the same platform. That type of business practice has less to do with unions then it does the buying public who don't want to see what used to be seperate divisions like oldsmobile and Buick retired to offer a more streamlined product line like that offered by honda and Toyota. In short, the problems with the big three are much more complicated than a simple unionized non unionized work environment.
 
Impala77

Your attempt at logically breaking down what is going on is respected and appreciated. Profits, keep doors open and shareholders investing in your product, plus osme other key factors.

Generating 1.8% profit (as the leading Big 3 company does) and being happy seems to be a poor way to run a business. Reeks of the old saying "I'll make less profit per unit and make it up on volume". Competitors in this market regualrly post near 8% profit margins on their sales.

Unions play a huge role in the ability companies have to earn profits. So, as time goes by, the axe will gain more momentum and cut hard and deep unless change occurs in the fundamental sad truths that guide the Big 3.

Unionized workforces in today's North American market place are absolutely way beyond their useful purpose.

Modern technology in the auto manufacturing arena are causing the employees with 1960, 70's and 80's knowledge base to resist skill enhancement and cooperation for development and cross training the will eventually be a requirement.

Quality control and quality of matrerials are widely noted to be in favor of non big 3 products

Operating effeciences lean heavily toward non big 3 companies favor.

Brand loyalty, fuel economy, residual values all are indicators that are recognized but, blinders are on and wasted money by big 3 continues.

The problem is more complex than simply looking at Market Share. Roughly 65% of the US market share still is owned by the Big Three. Retaining the dominance is something I would prefer to have the Big 3 keep. However, there are many indicators which lead many of us to conclude they must feel protected or secure or not their problem, I call it "fat, dumb and happy" with the axe slowly being raised over their collective heads.

Going back to the original post in this thread, which type of car to buy. I guess that really depends on what you want for your money do you want to buy a Big 3 car to support tradition or feel like you are fitting in with the locals by purchasing a big 3 car. Some may want to look at the residual value, gas mileage, relaibility of the make and model, affordability if that is an issue, repair costs, insurance etc....

At this point for the dollar a responsible car owner would benefit in more ways if they purchased a vehicle not made by the Big 3.
 
Having been on both sides of the fence as a CAW member and as management I must tell you I trust neither.

I never actually got involved in the union movement, as I found many of the union 'faithful' to have been brain washed with a socialist agenda right from the start. Unfortunately for the unions, more and more of the new workers have a higher level of education and a more critical attitude when presented with union positions.

The problems with management usually have more to do with mid-level managers and directors (and ocassionally VP's) with their own agendas. To the workers it appears they speak for the company, but they often have their own agendas that have nothing to do with the real aims and goals of the company.
 
Re: Impala77

JJicq said:

Brand loyalty, fuel economy, residual values all are indicators that are recognized but, blinders are on and wasted money by big 3 continues.

The problem is more complex than simply looking at Market Share. Roughly 65% of the US market share still is owned by the Big Three. Retaining the dominance is something I would prefer to have the Big 3 keep.

Going back to the original post in this thread, which type of car to buy. I guess that really depends on what you want for your money do you want to buy a Big 3 car to support tradition or feel like you are fitting in with the locals by purchasing a big 3 car.

Brand loyalty is part of the problem for the big three. GM has 5 domestic car lines all of which are offering products in all or most segments. While they may share major components, there is still 5 different body designs to build, five different models to market to the public. Compare this Toyota that has just 2 brands in NA and you start to see the difference btw the big 3 and the imports.

For GM to have higher profit margins it would probably be beneficial to get rid of 2 or 3 other divisions. The problem is like in the case of oldsmobile retiring, all those potential olds buyers did not automatically go to chevy for their next car. Removing brands could have an even more adverse effect on market share.

Basically I realize that there are issues between unionized workers and management but quite a lot of the trouble that the big 3 have with using quality materials are made by upper management not the unionized assembly person. The unattractive car designs that are approved to be built is done by management not the assembly worker. The advertising campaigns are approved by upper management and are quite often contracted out to non unionized workers. Basically the union builds the product that management gives them.

as for a reason to buy a big 3 car, why do you think it is done out of nostalgia or conformity? Clearly most people believe that Imports rule and if one was to buy a car to conform then toyota and honda are the benefactors not the Big 3. When I buy a car I'm looking for a car that offers the features I'm looking for at a price I feel is fair. I don't buy for nostalgia or conformity or even on the hope that it will have a high resale price. A car is not an investment to make you money, it is a tool to help make getting around a lot easier.
 
To me the union benefits and the Japanese currency manipulation are factors that will continue to make it difficult for the big 3 to sell an equal quality car for the same price as a Toyota, Honda etc and make the same profit. Vicious cycle for them I don't see any easy way out of.
 
Re: Re: Impala77

impala77 said:


Basically I realize that there are issues between unionized workers and management but quite a lot of the trouble that the big 3 have with using quality materials are made by upper management not the unionized assembly person. The unattractive car designs that are approved to be built is done by management not the assembly worker. The advertising campaigns are approved by upper management and are quite often contracted out to non unionized workers. Basically the union builds the product that management gives them.

as for a reason to buy a big 3 car, why do you think it is done out of nostalgia or conformity? Clearly most people believe that Imports rule and if one was to buy a car to conform then toyota and honda are the benefactors not the Big 3. When I buy a car I'm looking for a car that offers the features I'm looking for at a price I feel is fair. I don't buy for nostalgia or conformity or even on the hope that it will have a high resale price. A car is not an investment to make you money, it is a tool to help make getting around a lot easier.

Issues with Big 3 is if they need to reduce cost they hold their suppliers hostage in order to achieve the cost reduction. Meaning if they need to reduce cost by 5%, they tell suppliers they are paying 5% less. All well and good, another major issue relates to Unionized workforce, Unions are full of overpayed, under utilized, talented people who have been getting top dollar wages and benefit programs with little to no accountability.

Kind of like the kid in the classroom who is acting up, mouthing off, whatever and basically dares the teacher to take disciplinary action, you all know the scenario. Teacher basically has no authority or recourse so the tail is wagin the damn dog, so to speak.... same thing with the union, they do what they want when they feel like it at their own pace becaseu they know there is basically no action anyone can or will take against them.

Manufacturing facilities is where I see the greatest opportunity for Big 3 to make changes that will positively improve their productivity, quality, reliability, reduction in warranty costs and reduction in head count with more capable and motivated professionals running their facilties.

Believe me, I know many people in three seperate US communities with local big 3 plants, they feel almost obligated to buy a big 3 car and to a man I listen to them complain about the cars they drive. go figure!!!

I agree with you, it is difficult to understand and beleive your logic again makes sense regarding why people feel obligated to buy a big 3 product.

Obviously a car is not typically an investment. I think you would agree with me that when it is time for a new car that obtaining maximum value for the car being traded is an objective when you find yourself in that situation. Therefore, yes, in my case residual value of the car I will drive and properly maintain is very important to me and many others.