Canadian Pacific

Looks like the CN bid has gone off the rail due to regulatory and shareholder issues.
 
Looks like the CN bid has gone off the rail due to regulatory and shareholder issues.

I saw that. And now some of the shareholders are calling for the CEO's head.


CN Rail's KCS deal under attack by U.S. regulator, key shareholder


Canadian National Railway Co.’s proposed US$30 billion takeover of Kansas City Southern is under attack after it failed to pass a key regulatory hurdle and faced an immediate call to drop the bid from one of its largest shareholders.

London-based TCI Fund Management Ltd., which owns more than 5 per cent of CN’s shares, said Tuesday it’s imperative Canadian National walk away from the merger agreement after the U.S. Surface Transportation Board rejected a request for a voting trust central to the deal. That provided an opening for arch rival Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd., which said its competing offer still stands.

If the railway persists in the face of the regulator’s opposition, it runs the risk of reputational damage and financial disaster, the fund said in a letter to the railway’s chairman, Robert Pace.

“From the start, it has been clear and obvious the bid would fail. That the Board sanctioned the bid, together with potential fees of CUS$2 billion, is an egregious failure of oversight and there must be accountability,” TCI Chief Executive Officer Chris Hohn and investment analyst Ben Walker wrote in the letter.

The pair said Pace and Jean-Jacques Ruest, Canadian National’s CEO, should resign immediately; they urged the board to replace Ruest with Jim Vena, a former Union Pacific Corp. executive. They also called for a board seat for Gilbert Lamphere, who has previously been on the boards of Illinois Central Railroad, CN and CSX Corp.


Canadian National did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Rival suitor Canadian Pacific lost no time reminding Kansas City Southern’s board of its US$27 billion merger proposal made on Aug. 10. The STB has already approved a voting trust for Canadian Pacific’s deal, which the railway said gives it “regulatory certainty.”

“The STB decision clearly shows that the CN-KCS merger proposal is illusory and not achievable,” Canadian Pacific CEO Keith Creel said in the statement.


‘FUTILE’ APPEAL
TCI said the most pressing need at Canadian National is to improve operations as its financial performance lagged behind other railways since 2016. “CN owns a unique asset -- the best rail network in North America -- so it does not need to acquire KCS to prosper,” the fund said.

“CN should also be the most efficient and fastest growing railroad in the industry, but change is needed to achieve this goal. History has shown that with the right leadership railroads can be fixed quickly. CN should be no different,” Hohn and Walker added. The Financial Times first reported the contents of the letter.

The voting trust would have allowed Kansas City Southern to be moved into a separate holding company while a regulatory review of the merger was completed. Kansas City Southern shareholders would be paid at that point -- essentially eliminating regulatory risk for its investors.

CN’s board is now faced with a decision to withdraw from the merger agreement, appeal the ruling, or try to proceed without a voting trust. But TCI argued that the STB’s rejection of the voting trust made it clear that regulators simply do not want the deal to happen.

“An appeal cannot be won, and it is not an appeal you would want to win, so do not embark on what would be an expensive and undignified charade,” they said. “Continuing with the bid would not only be futile but, knowing it will ultimately end in failure, would also be unprofessional and disrespectful to everyone involved in the process. Instead, the company should withdraw and save billions of dollars in break fees.”
 
I own about the same amount of stock in CP and CN.

Originally I really wanted a stake in BNSF, but it seems that the Oracle of Omaha beat me to it.

If the KC merger goes through it could be a big competitor to UP and BNSF in the trans american market
 
And... now for some fun internally at CN. :)


TCI Fund Management launches battle for control of CN following railway’s apparent failed bid for KCS


Activist investor TCI Fund Management has launched a battle for control of Canadian National Railway Co.

CNR-T -0.51%decrease

in the wake of the railway’s apparently failed bid to buy Kansas City Southern
KSU-N +1.31%increase

Railway Co.

TCI, run by British billionaire Chris Hohn, on Monday accused Canada’s largest rail carrier of being run by “incompetent” and “weak” leadership, and said it will soon call a special shareholders’ meeting to oust CN’s chairman, chief executive officer and other directors.

Ben Walker, a partner in TCI, said the hedge fund is winning support from other major CN shareholders in its campaign for control of the railway’s boardroom. “The arguments are overwhelming,” Mr. Walker said in an interview. “Other shareholders are telling us they agree with us. They are reaching out to us.”

TCI’s move comes after KCS said Saturday it would renew takeover talks with CN rival Canadian Pacific Railway Co., reversing an earlier agreement to be bought by CN.

CN’s offer is in doubt after the U.S. railway regulator last week blocked a key part of CN’s takeover. The U.S. Surface Transportation Board rejected the Montreal company’s proposal to form a voting trust that would hold KCS’s shares pending approval of the takeover itself.

“The bid for KCS reflects poorly on CN’s management and board because it was obvious from the beginning that the bid would fail,” TCI said in a news release. “It was a copycat bid that reflected a defensive motivation and lack of strategic thinking.”

Mr. Walker decried the lack of railway experience on CN’s board, and said the company risked paying termination fees of as much as $2-billion by pursuing a takeover that had no prospects of U.S. regulatory approval.

TCI aims to replace “at least” five of CN’s 11 directors, including chairman Robert Pace and CEO Jean-Jacques Ruest, Mr. Walker said. “We need that number to effect change,” he said, calling it “shocking” Robert Phillips is the only board member with any experience in the rail industry, other than the CEO.

Mathieu Gaudreault, a CN spokesman, did not address questions about the KCS bid, the future of the company’s leaders or whether CN would negotiate with TCI to avoid a vote on board membership.

“CN values input from all of our shareholders,” Mr. Gaudreault said. “As we have done throughout the KCS process, and as we always do, we will make carefully considered decisions in the interest of all of our shareholders and stakeholders and in line with our strategic priorities.”

CP CEO Keith Creel said last week its US$27-billion bid for KCS expires on Sept. 12. The Calgary-based railway has already won STB approval for its voting trust.

Jason Seidl, a stock analyst at Cowen and Co. in New York, said it is possible CN will raise its offer to win KCS shareholder support without a voting trust. However, “we believe it is in CN’s best interest to walk away from the deal, given the clear messaging from the STB.”

KCS agreed in May to CN’s US$29.8-billion offer, turning its back on a March agreement with CP worth about US$25.2-billion. CP raised its bid by US$2-billion in August, arguing its proposal was the only one that would receive approval from U.S. regulators.

TCI is CN’s second-largest shareholder, with more than 5 per cent of the outstanding shares, a stake worth about $4-billion. TCI is also the largest owner of CP shares, at 8 per cent.

CN’s largest shareholder is Bill Gates’s Cascade Investment LLC. Mr. Walker said he has not discussed TCI’s Tuesday announcement with Cascade. He declined to say whether he supported CN director Justin Howell, who works for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation Trust. “I don’t know him,” Mr. Walker said.

A call to Cascade was not returned. CN’s major shareholders have declined to comment or not responded to questions.

TCI, also known as Children’s Investment Fund Management, was founded by Mr. Hohn in 2003 and has more than US$40-billion in assets under management. In 2008, the hedge fund joined with 3G Capital Partners to upend the board at U.S. railway CSX Corp., replacing four of 12 directors.

The investors accused CSX of poor management and lagging financial performance. CN is facing similar accusations.

TCI recently raised its stake in CN to be able to call a special meeting of shareholders. In a presentation it sent to CN’s board, TCI said CN is the only major railway in North America that has not increased operating profit since 2016.

CN’s operating ratio, a gauge of expenses versus sales that is closely watched by railways and investors, has fallen to the industry’s worst from the best since 2017. Since 2016, CN’s revenue has risen by 1.4 per cent, while expenses have increased by 18 per cent. “CN is the only railroad that remains below prepandemic levels on all key metrics,” TCI said.
 
Last edited:
  • Wow
Reactions: roadhog

In this case I don't believe so. Looking more likely Hohn is trying to implant Vena to try and recreate the turn around Harrison had at CP/CN/CSX.


Hohn is heavily invested in rail. Slide 2 above.

Beneficial owner of more than 5% of Canadian National’s outstanding shares, valued at $4bn

Other railroad investments: Canadian Pacific ($4bn) and Union Pacific ($1.3bn)
 
CP was built with private capitalist money on land gifted by the Government of Canada. CP is still a non-government owned corporation to-day. Pic of CP's head office in Montreal before they relocated to Calgary.
cp.jpg
 
On to the next stage...


Kansas City Southern to Accept CP Rail Offer, Rebuffing CN

By
Thomas Black

September 12, 2021, 12:57 PM EDT Updated on September 12, 2021, 1:57 PM EDT


Kansas City Southern said it’s backing out of a merger agreement with Canadian National Railway Co. and plans to accept a competing offer from Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd., the latest step in the fight over which railroad would become the first to operate in Canada, the U.S. and Mexico.

Canadian Pacific’s proposal was declared superior even though at about $27 billion it’s lower than Canadian National’s $30 billion offer, which began to unravel last month amid questions over whether it would win regulatory approval. Canadian National has about five business days to negotiate terms that could change the U.S. railroad’s decision, Kansas City Southern said in a statement Sunday.


Canadian National said it’s continuing to evaluate its options and “will make carefully considered decisions in the interests of all CN shareholders and stakeholders and in line with our strategic priorities.”

The months-long saga has now come full circle, after Canadian Pacific and Kansas City Southern initially agreed to a deal in March, only for Canadian National to swoop in with a higher offer. The Canadian companies are battling for the rare opportunity to acquire a U.S. railroad and build a network spanning much of North America.

Canadian Pacific’s offer values the U.S. railroad about about $300 a share. Kansas City Southern ended last week at about $280 in New York trading, up from about $224 before the CP’s overture became public on March 21. Canadian National shares fell 5.2% to C$150.74 in Toronto last week, while Canadian Pacific declined 4.1% to C$86.91.

Regulatory Roadblock
Sunday’s decision by Kansas City Southern looked increasingly likely after the U.S. rail regulator rejected Canadian National’s proposal for a voting trust, which would have allowed Kansas City Southern shareholders to be paid even before the combination received regulatory approval. The Surface Transportation Board’s forceful ruling on Aug. 31 against the trust proposal suggested it was unlikely the regulator would give final approval to the deal.

Canadian National’s offer was further undercut after the regulator raised issues with a possible decline in competition that went beyond 70 miles of overlapping track in Louisiana that was to be addressed with an asset sale. What’s more, the STB cited concern that the Canadian National-Kansas City Southern tie-up could kick off more acquisition activity because the deal would isolate Canadian Pacific mostly to Canada.


The ruling was a “stinging rebuke” of Canadian National’s proposal, Cowen analyst Jason Seidl said in a Sept. 7 note. It also gave Canadian Pacific the upper hand because the STB already had approved its voting-trust proposal and said its merger would be judged under less-stringent rules than Canadian National’s.

Canadian Pacific and Kansas City Southern had initially agreed earlier this year to a $25 billion merger, which was derailed by a surprise $30 billion counteroffer from Canadian National that the U.S. railroad accepted in May.

No Bidding War
Although Canadian Pacific Chief Executive Officer Keith Creel vowed not to get in a bidding war and predicted that the regulator would swat down the Canadian National proposal, he increased his bid to $27 billion only days before Kansas City Southern shareholders were scheduled to vote on Canadian National’s trust. The U.S. railroad postponed the vote until after the STB’s ruling.

On Sept. 4, Kansas City Southern said it would take a second look at Canadian Pacific’s offer and re-engage in talks.


“We are pleased to reach this important milestone and again pursue this once-in-a-lifetime partnership,” Creel said in a statement Sunday, calling the potential union a “perfect match.” “This merger proposal provides KCS stockholders greater regulatory and value certainty.”

Three Nations
The potential Kansas City Southern deal puts Canadian Pacific on track to be the first railroad to operate in Canada, the U.S. and Mexico, where Kansas City Southern gets about half of its revenue. The combined companies would have 20,000-mile network spanning from Vancouver to Veracruz, Mexico’s largest port on the Gulf of Mexico.

The deal would also allow Creel to compete more effectively with Canadian National, which already has a T-shaped network that reaches coast-to-coast in Canada and down to the U.S. Gulf Coast at New Orleans. The STB consistently praised the Canadian Pacific-Kansas City Southern deal as an “end-to-end” arrangement. The two networks don’t have overlapping track and meet only in Kansas City.

While Canadian National could attempt to sway Kansas City Southern with more money, the railroad already is feeling heat from shareholders to drop the deal. TCI Fund Management, which owns 5% of the railroad, is leading that charge with plans to call a special shareholders meeting to nominate five director to the board and task them with replacing Chief Executive Officer Jean-Jacques Ruest.


If Canadian National walks away, it won’t be empty-handed. Under the terms of the prior deal, Kansas City Southern is subject to a breakup fee of $700 million, which Canadian Pacific has pledged to reimburse.



— With assistance by Scott Deveau
 
So, one is a done deal. However, I'm sure we'll hear from CN again.
 
A casualty of CN's failed takeover of Kansas City Southern.

"MONTREAL, Oct. 19, 2021 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- CN (TSX: CNR) (NYSE: CNI) today announced that Jean-Jacques (JJ) Ruest will retire as president and chief executive officer and as a member of the Board of Directors of the Company, effective as of the end of January 2022, or such later time as a successor has been appointed to ensure a flawless transition."
 
Approved.

Once done, CP will have rail lines going east-west and north-south.

I think eventually it will move its head office to the U.S.