Bridge collapses in Minneapolis

. .
guyroch said:
Heard this morning that this bridge got a 55 percent rating ... What does that mean ? 50 percent means bridge replacement / or major restructing .. So
this bridge just sneaked by in regards to having to be replaced ..
It's called a sufficiency rating. Bridges are rated in several categories, to determine a overall score from 100 to 0, 100 meaning pristine, 0 meaning that the next stiff breeze could knock it down. You're correct about the 50% benchmark, but there are bridges with much lower scores that are still in use and still considered to be safe. The Tappan Zee Bridge in New York received a rating of 31 a couple years ago. After this disaster, NY state might want to take a closer look.
 
Last edited:
james t kirk said:
Dufferin, Dowling, Dunn over the CNR tracks.....
They need replacing.
But the 35W was being repaired when all this happened.

Are you saying an aging bridge needs to be competely replaced and not just fixed up??
 
Esco! said:
But the 35W was being repaired when all this happened.

Are you saying an aging bridge needs to be competely replaced and not just fixed up??
It's the law of diminishing returns. As bridges, or when any structure ages, problems such as stress fractures, metal fatique, deterioration of concrete, make it cost prohibitive to keep trying to shore it up. Most bridges built today have a very specific assumed life span. The Tappan Zee's was fifty years for instance, which it has now reached.
 
Esco! said:
But the 35W was being repaired when all this happened.

Are you saying an aging bridge needs to be competely replaced and not just fixed up??

It's not clear what was being done to the bridge. I heard it was just resurfacing. Hopefully they were not just adding a lift of asphalt! On bridges, you need to be very aware of dead loads.

As far as fixing verses replacing, it's simple a cost / benefit analysis.

Usually you can repair a bridge, but when it gets that bad, it's just not worth it and they should be changed out.