Bertuzzi Lawsuit.....

Don

Active member
Aug 23, 2001
6,286
10
38
Toronto
http://www.cbc.ca/olympics/sports/i...ational/2006/02/15/Sports/bertuzzi060215.html

Though a bit excessive, I can understand and accept this:


Moore is seeking $15 million in pecuniary damages for loss of income, $1 million for aggravated damages and $2 million in punitive damages.


but this I don't


Moore's parents, Jack and Anna, who were watching on television when Bertuzzi blindsided Moore, are suing for $1.5 million "for negligent infliction of nervous shock and mental distress."

The lawsuit claimed that "Anna was screaming and crying hysterically. Jack was utterly frozen in shock ..."


His parents sueing for their mental anguish? LAME! How can you sue for that? What if Moore had his head down and Bertuzzi came flying in full force and (legally) body checked him into the boards? Would they still sue for their mental anguish?

Talk about trying to cash in.

Can you imagine Eric Lindross' dad sueing Scott Stevens for flatting his son and leaving him unconscious?
 
Cash grab

Yes Moore got hurt. But in the present salary structure, I doubt he'd ever make 15 million total.

Bertuzzi has paid for this infraction. Suspension, loss of wages and he took a huge shot in the court of public opinion.

Fighting, hitting and the occasional high stick / elbow / cheap shot is a part of it too. So are reprisals for chicken shit hits.

Moore never was, never is, and never will be that good -he's a marginal player who's trying to cash in.
 
The case gets thrown out Colorado, thrown out of Vancouver and now its in Ontario courts. Moore and his tribe of lawyers are sure reaching. When does it end?

I would like to know how they come up with $15 million in lost revenue. Moores living in a dream if he ever thought he would have made that kind of coin in the NHL. He played 30 games or so, and its not to likely he would have played many more in the NHL. So say the experts not me.

This should be a great example for those playing or who wish to play in the NHL. Your actions can always be held accountable so watch it.
 
Interesting how Moore's lawyer thought NOW would be a good time to come forward with this lawsuit. Just as the Olympics are beginning and Bertuzzi is front and center in the media. Perhaps some free press coverage?
 
dj1470 said:
Interesting how Moore's lawyer thought NOW would be a good time to come forward with this lawsuit. Just as the Olympics are beginning and Bertuzzi is front and center in the media. Perhaps some free press coverage?

I was thinking the same thing.

That is now 2 stories blowing up towards team Canada in these olympics.
 
healer677 said:
Yes Moore got hurt. But in the present salary structure, I doubt he'd ever make 15 million total.

Bertuzzi has paid for this infraction. Suspension, loss of wages and he took a huge shot in the court of public opinion.

Fighting, hitting and the occasional high stick / elbow / cheap shot is a part of it too. So are reprisals for chicken shit hits.

Moore never was, never is, and never will be that good -he's a marginal player who's trying to cash in.


You cannot simply look at lost wagers. What about pain and suffering, all the months he is spending in rehab, legal fees, permanent damage to his body, psychological trauma and so on.

Bertuzzi has paid for this infraction to who? Certainly not to Moore. Unless you are saying that Bertuzzi does not owe him anything.

Moore's hit on Naslund was clean. Naslund(the victim of the clean hit) said so himself(hence there's no argument there). Hitting is part of the game. Wrestling moves are not. Ramming a guys head to the ice while he has his back turned to you and landing on top of him is assault. Yes, even in hockey(unless you say that assault is also part of the game).

As for the parents. Yes I agree. They are pushing it. They are just trying to take advantage of the situation. The only way I can see the justification of a lawsuit is if one of them died of a heart attack after seeing the assault.
 
Kev said:
The case gets thrown out Colorado, thrown out of Vancouver and now its in Ontario courts. Moore and his tribe of lawyers are sure reaching. When does it end?

Was never thrown out in Vancouver. He is sueing in Ontario coz he now lives there and Ontario laws permits it.

Kev said:
I would like to know how they come up with $15 million in lost revenue. Moores living in a dream if he ever thought he would have made that kind of coin in the NHL. He played 30 games or so, and its not to likely he would have played many more in the NHL. So say the experts not me.

Does it have to be NHL revenue? His body is damaged and he has to spend time in rehab instead of doing what he wants to do.
 
kirmit129 said:
Ramming a guys head to the ice while he has his back turned to you and landing on top of him is assault. Yes, even in hockey(unless you say that assault is also part of the game).

It looked more like 'roid rage.
 
dj1470 said:
Interesting how Moore's lawyer thought NOW would be a good time to come forward with this lawsuit. Just as the Olympics are beginning and Bertuzzi is front and center in the media. Perhaps some free press coverage?


Well "apparently" he sued 2 days b4 the deadline to take legal action. Hence it was more of a timing issue.
 
I don't understand the stance u all are taking on this ......? Bert broke the guys neck, intentionally ....after Mooore laid a big legal hit on Naslund (with his head down not the first time that has ever happened in pro-hockey) the team's coaches and players lead by Bert promised revenge openly in the days preceeding the attack. he lead and perpatrated an attack from behind that lead to a broken neck on Moore..... the NHL suspended Bert for a long time, why? because that is not part of the GAME........ what Stevenson did on Lindros was within the limits of the game that is an excepted part of the game ......but going after a guy .... suckering him from behind to the point of breaking his neck..... that is not part of the game we watch and play....
 
kirmit129 said:
As for the parents. Yes I agree. They are pushing it. They are just trying to take advantage of the situation. The only way I can see the justification of a lawsuit is if one of them died of a heart attack after seeing the assault.

Like I said, that is where I have problems. I can accept Moore's lawsuit. The parents... that one is a reach and actually it makes their son look bad too.

As bad as the Moore incident was, it still is not as bad as what happend to Rudy Tomjanovich when his face got destroyed by Kermet Washington back in the '80s. No lawsuit by Rudy T, much less his parents.
 
That was simply due to the lack of message board chat gossip. :)
 
I'd Sue His A** Off Too

Name another sport that would have so many people sympathizing with a guy who blindsides someone much smaller and almost breaks his neck! Boxing??? UFC??? Football??? Not a chance. That was assault. Plain and simple. If you can't see that, there's no point continuing to argue about this.
 
kirmit129 said:
Was never thrown out in Vancouver. He is sueing in Ontario coz he now lives there and Ontario laws permits it.
I should have said, "not prosecuted in Vancouver and thrown out in Colorado."


kirmit129 said:
Does it have to be NHL revenue? His body is damaged and he has to spend time in rehab instead of doing what he wants to do.
And thats what they'll have to prove. Who created the injuries that Moore suffers from. Its not that cut and dry.
 
Don said:
As bad as the Moore incident was, it still is not as bad as what happend to Rudy Tomjanovich when his face got destroyed by Kermet Washington back in the '80s. No lawsuit by Rudy T, much less his parents.

Or Jack Tatum on Darryl Stingly.

If Bert is the hero of this Olympics, people will start forgetting about this, the same way the forgot about Doug Gilmours adventures in babysitting, or Craig MacTavish's driving problems.
 
Kev said:
And thats what they'll have to prove. Who created the injuries that Moore suffers from. Its not that cut and dry.


Yeah, he'll have to prove the involvement/link of the other people named in the lawsuit. As for Bertuzzi, I don't think Moore and his lawers need to prove anything. It's been proven already. Unless Bertuzzi's defence is: "Well maybe he fell in the ambulance and that's where the broken neck came from".
 
emvee said:
Or Jack Tatum on Darryl Stingly.

If Bert is the hero of this Olympics, people will start forgetting about this, the same way the forgot about Doug Gilmours adventures in babysitting, or Craig MacTavish's driving problems.

How about Jesse Beulirece's attempted murder of an opposition player that got him permanently suspended from the OHL. For some reason, unbeknownst to me, he made it to the NHL.

Bertuzzi's actions were bad enough, the fact that he gloated on the bench with his team-mates makes it even worse. Why Wayne Gretzky thought it wise to include a player with a history of violent stupidity (anyone remember the 2002 playoffs) is beyond me.

Don't look now but we've become The Ugly Canadians. So much for our hypocritical attitude that we're better than Americans. It won't upset me if another national team hands us our ass in men's hockey.